News
Fury in Britain after Peres says English are anti-Semitic
Ynet
Published: 01.08.10, 11:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
131 Talkbacks for this article
31. The British Foreign Office is DEEPLY anti-Israel
Zvi   (08.01.10)
It is INTENSELY pro-Arab. Support for Israel has been, when it existed, haphazard at best. Support for Arab positions, even when these amount to genocide, has been concerted and long-lasting. Peres is absolutely right. Chappison is wrong.
32. The UK isn't...
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.01.10)
anti - Israel - they are *only* pro Arab!! Congratulations to Peres for finally saying outright what we all know to be true.
33. #17 - No
A Jerusalemite ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.01.10)
No, Miki it wasn't. It was the UN against the recommendation of the UK that created modern Israel.
34. To #17: No! GB abstained in the UN Vote!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (08.01.10)
Read your history WikiMiki. They also armed the 22 Arab countries which declared war on the new State of Israel and did NOTHING to stop them from killing Jews! I would highly suggest reading Exodus for a good insight in Britain's relationship with Jews and Israel. Further, Britain has either abstained or voted against Israel in all the UN Sec Council Resolutions condemning Israel.
35. Watch the Beeb and you'll see England hates the Heeb
Yaniv ,   Israel   (08.01.10)
36. Germany much less anti-Semitic than England. Truth hurts.
Yaniv ,   Israel   (08.01.10)
37. Right Peres
Merca ,   Barcelona   (08.01.10)
It's well worth remenbering that UK did prefer bombing Dresde,Hamburg....during WWII and not helping jews by not bombing Auswitch,Mathausen,Dachau...
38. oh oh.... dear Brits.....
Dana Rothschild ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (08.01.10)
remember only your time in Palestine... remember your pro-Arab activities.... and foremost remember GUSH ETZION!!!!!
39. Peres is 100% right,Start with the BBC and The Guardian
Josh Reinier ,   EU/UK   (08.01.10)
Of the two the Guardian is the nastier,it has some of the nastiest articles that smear Israel.It uses useful Israeli idiots who are actually undermining the State of Israel with their anti-Israel articles.Some of their posters are actually racists.
40. peres comments
daniel baharier ,   tel aviv, israel   (08.01.10)
having grown up in England I agree almost totally with President Peres remarks .Having grown up and gone to school and university outside one of the large jewish blocks as an 'isolated' family I had almost daily reminders of anti semitism. The almost is of another england of those that arent anti semitic and even pro jewish in for want of a better word american way. but then thats england and the english some people try to fall over backward to be fair and then fall into traps of whichever block.others take a side and no matter what grind that axe and a lot are just anti semitic before they are anything else eg anti blacks anti muslim etc
41. England has one thing over the US
Steve   (08.01.10)
They've not elected a Muslim prime minister. Not yet.
42. Perfect case of the the truth hurting
DT ,   TA Israel   (08.01.10)
Took Peres long enough, slow in waking up to the fact that the UK is far and away the most anti-semitic of all Euro countries.
43.  # 25 . They are killed for being ISRAELIS
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (08.01.10)
.
44. Pres, Peres accurate statement
RayS ,   USA   (08.01.10)
BRAVO PRES PERES FOR TELLING IT LIKE IT IS..One would have to be deaf, dumb and blind to fail to recognize British anti-semitism. .
45. Brits are aopeaser losers
limey slimy ,   usa   (08.01.10)
Need I say anything But Cameron is another idiot we can do without. They are Arab puppets and cowards. LONDONISTA is what it is and I will never visit any Euro-peon country and espcially Germany Austria. The Brits are well documented antisemites for o very 60 years and the French are worse!!
46. to #14 thank you oh wise one.
ghostq   (08.01.10)
47. So you don't deny it?!
blash ,   Jerusalem   (08.01.10)
Peres says, "you're a load of anti-Semitic ingrates!" UK says, "how dare you make such a statement! we are no more anti-Semitic than any other European country! we have all these laws that preach tolerance (although we admit our media has gone to the trash)!" Response: so, you don't deny England is full of antisemitic nonsense?! Wow...
48. Peres is correct
Shayna Gezunt ,   London UK   (08.01.10)
Well done Shimon Peres open your eyes Anglo Jews. I was born and bred here in the Uk. why will no one in the Jewish community open their eyes to see the truth of what is happening here and what will be in the future .We are a declining minority here whereas the Muslims are an increasing minority. who will the politicians want to curry favour with?
49. If only Arab Israelis "suffered" like this!
David ,   UK   (08.01.10)
In the recent general election in the UK 3.2% of the MPs elected were Jewish even though Jews represent only 0.5% of the population. The leading contender for the leadership of the Labour party is Jewish. Jewish people hold high office in the legislature, executive, judiciary and in the world of commerce. Arab Israelis should be so lucky as to suffer this kind of discrimination!
50. Rubbish, if talkbackers cared to read the article they
David Solomon ,   London   (08.01.10)
wouldnt be writing with such hate and venom towards England. I am a very proud Jew and very Proud English man. If I or my family didnt like it here, then we wouldnt have been here (all that time since 1890 something) If you read the article, rather than skiming it, you see what people here have said, including Zionists and Jews..
51. #25 WELL SAID. Everyone read #25
Alan ,   London   (08.01.10)
52. Peres has got it right - A British Christian.
Doug R. ,   Gwent, UK   (08.01.10)
Peres has got it right and I say this with shame. I'm not Jewish, I'm British and Christian - and I know my own country. Those in denial will cite pluralism and tolerance but their case doesn't hold water. Cloaked in the more socially acceptable political/humanitarian euphemisms anti-Israelism or anti-Zionism it doesn't much effort on the part of a honest individual to see the basis of subsequent comments. Criticism of Israel, like that of any other nation, is quite normal as long as it is comparative, contextual, and fair. However, when the Jewish nation is the only party criticized for faults, often obsessively, that are far worse among other peoples, then such criticism crosses the line from being acceptable to being blatantly anti-Semitic. Even a blind man can see that Israel is singled out for special treatment and our leaders are obsessed with appeasing the Arab/Islamic world for their own interests. The UK has lost it's moral compass.
53. peres got it right!
OZ   (08.01.10)
look at recent history of the last 100 years.. everywhere the british empire had set its foot ,there's now chaos and mayhem.... iraq, india , israel/arabs, iran, syria and lebanon, vietnam.... the brits have been acute anti semites from way back when... now with a growing islamic population in their midst, maybe one day the brits will get it .......
54. Unbelievable
Max Maier ,   Germany   (08.01.10)
Israel inflicts people like Peres and Lieberman on the international community and it is surprised that it is isolated? Can anyone imagine the uproar if the head of state of a Western country bleated about US politicians pandering to the "Jewish vote" in an interview? Peres and Lieberman give Israel an image of aggressive and whining bigotry abroad. BTW, "The Tablet" is a Catholic publication. Perhaps you should at least get that right.
55. Not as bad
Ben ,   Unknown city   (08.01.10)
According to a survey published last week in the Jewish Chronicle most of British Jews ( 71%) are happy in Britain. It is also well known that Tony Blair Gordon Brow and now David Cameron are not against Jews This week was also published a report which shows that anti semetic incidents are down since January even if there was a rise due to the flotilla incident I'm not saying than everything is perfect in England but things are not as bad. The jewish community is well alive well involve in british life with many mps and lords. When i have a look on the Jc and the jewish telegraph i do see some good news and sometimes yes sometimes some bad news You also need to know that according to the ADL Britain is a less racist county to jews than other european countries ( france, spain ) that in this Fabulous and wonderful country that is America there were 1211 anti semitic incidents last year So please stop criticizing Britain and England which remains a good place for jews. I' d like to see British jews figthing bak this article Things are nots as bad so don't overdo it Last one thing you can criticize the Jewish State and not being anti semetic
56. WRONG!
jonathan ,   truro, ENGLAND   (08.01.10)
Don't confuse British establishment with British people, new Labour Party top contenders BOTH JEWS. Chief Rabbi voted most respected religious leader in U.K. by NON JEWS! Last Conservative Party leader a JEW! Could this happen in U.S.A? No chance!
57. #43 Israelis killed? this Ynet would be all over that if so
Sid Freedman   (08.01.10)
and they would be providing links to the stories of murdered Israelis in England if so. Lies, your making up lies.
58. Pakistan today burning PM Cameron dummies, flags.Israel same
French Jew ,   London, England   (08.01.10)
Is this reaction to modern countries a typical middle eastern/far east thing?? because it looks like from these talkbacks so why is Israeli acting no better than the Pakistani muslims at the moment protesting in such an animalistic and uneducated way (ref to talkbacks)? Pakistanis have been burning David Cameron dolls on the streets in mass riots all weekend, screaming death to Britain, sort of like this weird talk backs. Get a grip. I thought we are all better than this.
59. David #50
Steve   (08.01.10)
David, perhaps you do know about your country's administration of the League of Nations Mandate; the 1939 McDonald White Paper, limiting Jewish immigration to a mere 75,000 over the following five years. Thereafter immigration would depend on Arab consent, thus repudiating England's commitment to the Balfour Declaration which pledged the British would establish in "Palestine" a Jewish National Homeland. England consigned Europe's Jews to their horrible fate at the hands of the Nazis. In effect, England conspired with the Nazis in the fulfillment of Hitler's "Final Solution to the Jewish question." The British hunted mostly dilapidated ships filled with desperate Jewish refugees, fleeing Nazi occupied Europe. The British sank some, turned some back to Nazi occupied Europe; others were boarded, the "illegal" Jewish refugees were arrested, sent to detention camps on Cyprus and Mauritius. The British financed, armed and trained the Arab Legion for the 1948 Arab war against the newly declared Jewish state. Like Peres said, there is a history behind this.
60. Gaza Gaza Gaza
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (08.01.10)
Its not about hating Jews, its about Gaza. Jews like to cry wolf (antisemitism) every time they are criticized for their bad behavior...1400 dead in Cast Lead, 9 dead in the flotilla.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article