News
Ex-soldier presents cuffed Palestinian friends
Ynet
Published: 16.08.10, 15:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
81 Talkbacks for this article
61. The IDF should ban soldiers from posting on web sites
Danny Chiew ,   Singapore   (08.17.10)
Some of these soldiers are not mature enough to post on these sites.This silly girl has proven that soldiers should be censored.Before they post.
62. Stupid girl, no doubt. But Palis created this "culture"
iObserver ,   US-Israel   (08.17.10)
Ever wonder why Israelis don't trust Palestinians, regardless of who they r and what they look like? Perhaps it comes from the endless flow of Palestinian terrorists who take on every sable and form, age and sex, friend and foe. As if the "hardening" of the Israeli soldier isn't to be expected. Well, it should b and will continue until Israelis don't have to constantly fear for their lives and be humiliated by having to run with their children into bomb shelters as a daily part of their routine. If the Palestinians STOP acting like animals (enmasse: yes, blanket observation here) then perhaps people will stop treating them as such. Fine the girl and give her a week in the brig for being immature but don't blow this out of proportion: Israel is indeed a traumatized nation and often responds that way. We're only human.
63. A picture speaks a thousand words
Avi ,   Israel   (08.17.10)
It`ll take more than a press statement from the IDF propoganda machine to cover this one up.
64. Holocaust
Kishen ,   Australia   (08.17.10)
How do humans react to pictures of prisoners and labor camps during the WWII? Usually human reactions are compassion, empathy and helplessness. Looking at lot of of the comments on the forum, it looks like humanity is dead in Israel.
65. photos are fine
Glenn ,   Ft. Lauderdale, FL   (08.17.10)
I think the photos would have been fine even if the Arab was kissing her feet.
66. I SUPPORT HER, shove it if you dont like it.
Canadian ,   Vancouver, B.C.   (08.17.10)
Sad to hear her discharged, I'm fed up with people bashing her for a harmless photo...go bash U.S. soldiers posing in front of Iraqi prisoners if you care so much. Ill do the same thing in this photo when I join the IDF. I send her support.
67. #55; Matty, your outraged?
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (08.17.10)
Matty writes: "Such immoral behavior is to be expected as the IDF humiliate the Palestinians on a daily basis.... As with Abu Ghraib then an occupying force has complete control over civilians " Wow, your so upset. Tell me Matty, were you upset at the multiple beheading video's? How about Pearlman? Forced to say "I am a Jew". after which they used a rusty Machete to cut off his head while he was awake and alive. What? about 18-20 other beheading video's? Say Matty, your selective outrage, it's pure BS. When it comes to humiliation, forcing people to make statements against their will and slowly cutting their heads off, I think that rates a little higher on the outrage scale, don't you? Scaring some people with dogs, stripping men in front of women to humiliate them, put simply, BFD.
68. What's really frightening about her conduct
Disgusted !sraeli   (08.17.10)
is that she was completely unaware of her immoral behavior. She didn't see them as humans, and didn't think that what she was doing was/is wrong! That is a complete failure! I just don't know what to say, I'm dumbfounded at her lack of education, upbringing, lack of humanity, etc. Well, she has most definitely shamed herself for life.
69. The French, the German, Russian, Brits,They all did it
silvio   (08.17.10)
Even the IDF has stupid broads " serving " with honor ?. Was she trying to emulate Abu Graib --- is everything american " cool "
70. Where is the Facebook Administration?!
Salma ,   Palestine   (08.17.10)
Some Palestinian sites on Facebook, which is hardly offensive to Jews or "Israelis" deleted blink of an eye ! Ynet, I insist, this is the ethics of the "IDF" with very few exceptions.
71. interesting that her strongest supporters
cubo ,   NYC, USA   (08.17.10)
Are mostly in the USA. American Jews are a huge problem for Israel -- they are violent and inhuman, always pushing Israelis, who sometimes show more humanity, into aggressive behaviour.
72. #70 Salma
Cynthia ,   USA   (08.17.10)
We know how your Palestinian brothers have treated Gilad Shalit and murdered and lynched other Israeli soldiers. When Gilad is set free, you may talk about the ethics of the IDF.
73. I support her too.
Glenn ,   Ft. Lauderdale   (08.17.10)
Even if the photo had those prisoners kissing her feet it would be fine with me. I send her support also.
74. Agree with Cynthia
Glenn ,   Florida   (08.17.10)
I agree with Cynthia. She should have had a picture or two of those guys kissing her feet.
75. Reply to Glenn
A dude ,   Israel   (08.17.10)
What she did is by no means fine. IDF's purpose is not revenge, but defense, and comments like yours, that express hatred towards enemies or other people, only cause harm to Israel's and IDF's reputation. Thanks a lot really.
76. 25
zionist forever   (08.17.10)
They have this story on Yahoo and they are showing her face on there
77. soldier
jochanan ,   holland   (08.17.10)
this is shameles behavior! bad for israel and the soldiers that do good,,, this behavior brings down the whole idf..this should be adressed,,
78. #47 - AGREE!
Moshe ,   Jerusalem   (08.18.10)
79. to 51: if..if..if..if..if..if..if..if..
Izik ,   Holon, IL   (08.18.10)
IF a grandmother had had balls, she would have been a grandfather.
80. That's so sad..
Nadine ,   Jerusalem, Palestin   (08.18.10)
I am absolutely shocked that there's any kind of human being (no matter what race he/she comes from) feeling proud of such actions.. Now the posting of such awful pictures, then what?? I believe such pictures and even the comments of "you're so sexy" in this picture reflect the sad world we have come to live into. I am Palestinian and if I have ever seen a Palestinian soldier do this to ANY human being I would be very hurt and would move to do a change.. Such actions can NEVER be justified.. I can Never believe that a nation that has suffered so much in the past from opression and humiliation would do the same thing to another nation given that this nation had nothing to do with their humiliation by the Nazis... With all due respect to those who support this IGNORANT girl.. Please go get some education.. Thanks to those who refuse to be part of this disgraceful act.
81. You did great, Eden
Yaakov Mendel   (03.19.11)
Yes, she is disrespectful and that's precisely why she should be complimented because the Arab scum that wants to murder us deserves NO respect. The Arab Nazis must know that in Israel, their master is a beautiful Jewish young woman.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article