News
'IDF can destroy Lebanon army within 4 hours'
Roee Nahmias
Published: 27.08.10, 14:42
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
173 Talkbacks for this article
31. to Sarah B.
Asad ,   Beirut, Lebanon   (08.27.10)
Sarah, it doesnt matter how superior israels military is. They will lose in lebanon. history shows it. Look at ur nato who u say dont care about civillian casualties, are they winning in afghanistan? lol i dont think so. Look at what happend in iraq, they lost. Face it u cannot win in lebanon. just because u won those wars against those puppets doesnt mean u can win in lebanon. and if i remember correctly, didnt we kick u guys out in 2000? lol its all good though.
32. Israel should have done it already. The Arabs don't
Roger ,   Paris, France   (08.27.10)
understand words; they only understand actions.
33. Wait a second
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (08.27.10)
We didn't say anything. This was an AMERICAN stating that the IDF could take out the LAF in 4 hours. No Israeli threats at all. Though I think that it most likely could take out the LAF in a matter of 30 minutes. We have no desire to fight with anybody. It should be simple enough for even an Arab to understand. Leave us alone or die. Your choice.
34. #2 Serious English Comprehension Problems
Bill Foonman ,   Jacksonville USA   (08.27.10)
Precisely what does "destroying Lebanon's military infrastructure" have to do with wiping Lebanon off the map? If the Lebanese were smart they would be making peace with Israel and recapturing some of the past glory their country once had. Instead, they have gained a sense of false bravado instilled by the cancerous Iranian Islamic terror cell known as Hezbollah. Unfortunately for them, the Lebanese will only wake up and realize this when Hezbollah causes the total destruction of their country.
35. mofaz / bougui
haim ,   ariel   (08.27.10)
i do not andersteen why israel is always ask for a green green light before attacking !?
36. 2
zionist forever   (08.27.10)
The article says Israel is capable of wiping out the Lebanese army within 4 hours. Nobody is saying it will wipe the country off the map or even that Israel will destroy the army. This article states that Israel has that capacity if it came to it. You leave Israel alone and stop trying to provoke it into wars and Israel will try and make peace with Lebanon you want war though Israel will leave Lebanon with an army of dead bodies. Its up to Lebanon to decide if they want their relationship with Israel to be based on war or peace. Israel can handle either.
37. Threats from Israel
JUDAH THE LION   (08.27.10)
World citizen (I think the same person of yesterday from Holland).What drugs you been smoking today? Israel never threaten to wipe Muslim or Arabs country.You are admitting you have heard about Arab threat to Israel. If that so,how comes Israel is the true troublemaker in the ME. Go and carry on smoking your drugs and enjoy them.
38. As comments show, this article has hit a nerve.
Faruq   (08.27.10)
the truth always does hit somebodys nerves.
39. Wow...4 hours!!! Even US couldn't finish Iraq in 1 week..
John ,   USA   (08.27.10)
If this's meant to scare the Lebanese army,then i'm sure they must be shaking in their boots by now...4 hours???lol.The IDF must be playing a lot of CALL OF DUTY lately.lol..Israel's inflated invincibility was put it its place in 2006..All they hit were civilian targets.Of course they'll come out and say the terrorist were hiding in there...4 hours??? Evene the US with all it's military might wouldn't make such stupid statement...Get real...!!!
40. #2 - Do you know how to read?
Andy ,   ramat hasharon   (08.27.10)
Israel can and will destroy your entire army. You are cordially invited to stay on the map without one. See the difference, retard?
41. Sadly this makes the cast for S-300s in Lebanon
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (08.27.10)
Every country has the right to be able to defend itself, which Lebanon currently can not. Since S-300/400 system is defense only this article makes the best case so far that Lebanon needs a good air defense system like the newer S-300. It would not cause a shift in the regional balance since Israel has thousands of tanks and missiles.
42. #2 Mitchell's aide said the army not the country
Michael ,   Israel   (08.27.10)
Israel makes a distintiction between civilians and soldiers while lebanese like to go into battle with football jerseys and rpgs. While Iran doe not have any distinction between soldier or civilian or a day old baby. So I guess you have been listening to too many repitious Iranian speeches.
43. IDF - Let's Keep The Fond Memories
(08.27.10)
44. correction to post 25
StevieT ,   USA   (08.27.10)
Should have indicated that it was in answer to #2 who claims he's heard it all before about Isreal wanting to obliterate Lebanon. I merely point ot that he is only hearing it from the sweaty fatman and that if not attacked or threarened, peace would rule the day.
45. Lebanon makes us do it
Yaniv ,   Holon,Israel   (08.27.10)
we and u.s want peace but lebanon and syria are double agent
46. wipe the army
raz barr ,   haifa israel   (08.27.10)
read it folks "wipe the army" away, not the people. Maybe they could do the same thing in Iran too?
47. #39
Jane   (08.27.10)
Oh, John, you are such an idiot. You get real. 2006 is not the "standard" by which the present/future should be measured. The day will come when we will finally play by the rules of the region - as in no rules (i.e. not with Western politeness - though I must say the US seems to have quite a bit of collateral damage to answer for)
48. IDF and Mossad
Gregory ,   Montreal, Canada   (08.27.10)
Let us stop this joke about the invincibility of the IDF and its ability to hit the enemy with minimal collateral civilian damage. We saw your 'surgical precision' in the last wars in Lebanon and Gaza. Your soldiers have lost their discipline in the way they treat their prisoners. Mossad fumbled in Dubai. The flotilla raid was another joke. Stop any more adventurism. Let me keep the fond memories of your victories like the Entebbe raid. Do not spoil it.
49.  2. So Israel wants to "wipe Lebanon off the map"
Marc ,   chicago, IL   (08.27.10)
Israel did not say it wants to wipe Lebanon offf the face of the earth, it said it will wipe the SLA out in four hours if it ever attachs Israel again.
50. Lebanon 2006
zionist forever   (08.27.10)
It was undoubtedly a screw up but that was for alot of reasons and all of them the Israeli politicians not because we were up against a superior army. Olmert tied the hands of the IDF because he kept talking about reasonable force and did not say this is war do what must be done. Olmert, Peretz, Livni & Halutz were trying to micromanage the war from their air conditioned offices and were not interested in anything that the officers in Lebanon were saying they needed. The soldiers kept saying we need more infantry but up until the very last days Dan Halutz agreed to give it because he was personally convinced the war could be won with airpower so no need for more infantry. Thanks to years of almost annual cuts in the military budget the IDF was not ready for a full scale war. The armor on the Merkava 2 tanks kept in reserve was not kept updated to counter modern anti tank missiles. The IDF might buy a new tank but they would not spend a little bit extra to buy a system to protect those expensive tanks from anti tank rockets. Reserves were not being called up for training and some of them it was so long since they had been called up they forgot their skills learned. This was all because the army was trying to save money they needed but were not getting because the politicians saw them just as glorified anti terror force which didn't need the same money as an army. If there is 1 thing Barak has done well is he has finally spent a money on upgrading the IDF and reserves are being called up again for training. The IDF have learned from their mistakes what will decide if they win or lose a war in future is the politicians. If the politicians say you guys are the experts and the ones and we will back you we will win it but if they want to micromanage things and say we know best then we will lose. Politicans make or break wars these days for israel not superior enemies.
51. :: How can anyone take Israel seriously anymore?
Matty Groves ,   Fairport   (08.27.10)
"which would completely destroy the Lebanese army's bases, centers and offices within four hours". Such boasting should be put into context as we recall that Israel could not destroy Hizbollah during the last conflict and Israel has never been able to destroy Hamas even though Hamas is a relatively small organization trapped in the Gaza Strip which Israel has full control over. Sure Israel ‘could’ destroy known Lebanese army's bases etc but it will never destroy the will to resist Israel’s mindless aggression nor the ability for Lebanon to rain down thousands of missiles on Israel. Let Israel blow its own trumpet as it will never act upon such bragging without suffering a huge cost.
52. To: No. 31
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (08.27.10)
Please. Israel OWNS your asses, and you know it. That's why you very wisely decided to stay out of every war since 1948. And when Maronite Christians were being slaughtered like cattle in southern Lebanon, who came to their rescue? Do you remember what Beirut was like before Israel sent the terrorists packing? Israel took Sidon and Tyre in no time at all. We can do it again; any time we want. The best thing that the Lebanese -- the REAL Lebanese -- can do for themselves to get rid of Hezbollah. Sooner or later, Iran will push them into doing something stupid against Israel and -- you will disappear. Is that what you want?
53. To: No. 48
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (08.27.10)
Oh, don't worry. Surgical precision is off the table. By the way, how would Canada handle an attempt to run a lawful and internationally-recognized blockade? The Canadian Coast Guard has sunk hapless fishing smacks that happen to stray into Canadian territorial waters and ignore orders to cease and desist, so I think I probably know the answer to that one. Of course, the CCG claims that they are protecting Canadian fisheries, so it is a perfectly normal response. Israel, on the other hand, faces a real terror threat from Hamas. The flotilla raid had to be done. Of course, Israel could have exercised the CCG option and sunk the MARMARA. We've got a far better excuse than "protecting fisheries." That said, how many vessels have attempted to run the blockade recently? It may be a "joke" to you, but Israel's enemies are taking it quite seriously.
54. This article is about what the kind U.S. envoy
Israeli 2   (08.27.10)
told the Lebanese Army. He said: Cool it or Israel will dismantle you within 4 hours. He KNOWS of what he speaks. As for the last war with Lebanon, it was a complete Lebanese humiliation. They cried and begged Israel to stop. Israel drove them back all the way to the Litani while Nasrallah was Sh.....in his pants.
55. Why so long?
Mark ,   NYC USA   (08.27.10)
You should be able to get that down to 2 hrs
56. It seems you have problem understanding what is written
Yossi   (08.27.10)
Israel can wipe out Lebanon army, not Lebanon it self nor the citizens in which Israel don't wanna heart. But you and your alike take something and turn it to something else.. As usual.
57. Israel distroy buildings in and effort to not kill cevilens
yossi   (08.27.10)
Israel could destroy one day all Hamas leaders in one stroke, all it had to do is one bomb on a building and everyone dead, including ceviliens, but Israel did not do that... did any one of your government informed you with this and others alike situation? It's very easy to wipe out Gaza in 2 hours, why Israel did not do that?
58. You too stupid to see the truth
Yossi   (08.27.10)
Israel have a means to distroy Egypt in only one bobm.. it could distroy Syria with no effort at all. Lebanon is no function.. Israel did not use it's massive force since it did not wan't the UN on it's head... But if Lebanon will give her a legit reason such as in the last time, it could and will destroy it's army. Don't forget in 2006 Israel thought of destroying Lebanon main supply roots and army, but at the end, after pressure from US it did not do that.
59. Asad from Beirut
(08.27.10)
I hope you are not Assad from Syria.The Lebanese never kicked the IDF out of Lebanon.Our stupid PM EHUD BARAK who gave the order to the IDF to get out of Lebanon to give chance for PEACE,but unfortunately the Lebanese took it as VICORY.In the coming war with Lebanon,the IDF/IAF will teach you a lesson that you will never forget.This time hopefully your so called BRAVE Hizbollah will not hid with civilians,or mosques,or hospitals.Let them to face the IDF if they are BRAVE
60. # 2
Simcha ,   So.Cal.USA   (08.27.10)
The article never said such a thing ! Just certain areas of offence.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article