News
Ariel Sharon to go home
Ynet
Published: 22.09.10, 08:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. In the case of Sharon,
Salma ,   Palestine   (09.22.10)
It's just fate,without any help ;)
2. Salma
Frank P ,   Jerusalem   (09.22.10)
Your comment shows the lack of empathy and regard for the 'other' that your entire people exemplify. The Jewish people would care for you if you were sick or injured even though you hate us; would your people do the same for us? I think not.
3. I am sorry for his suffering...
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (09.22.10)
4. Well said, Frank.
Linichka ,   Gdynia, Poland   (09.22.10)
I have great respect for Mr. Sharon, am sorry he is not well and conscious and leading Israel today. Your snide remark was unnecessary, Salma.
5. Frank -Salma's comment was with a tear
Michal ,   Tel Aviv   (09.22.10)
You are apparently a fanatic. There was nothing in Salma's talkback EXCEPT sympathy and pity for the situation Sharon is in. I hope you re-read it and learn to stop seeing things through your hate-tinged glasses.
6. Michael
Ben   (09.22.10)
You sound like a hate filled, knee jerk fanatic. Salma's comment contained a wink, and she is a well reknowned provocative troll on this site. Take off your Pali blinkers.
7. Michal and Salma
Hertzel ,   Tveria   (09.22.10)
Michal I think you are wrong, it was a cold and sarcastic comment.
8. #1 your talkbacks always remind me why we still have no peac
Mike ,   Oxford UK   (09.22.10)
#5 you are delusional. It's nice that you want to see the best in people, but I suggest that you re-read Salma's comments. As always they are full of hate.
9. You're the one should re-read, Michal
Linichka ,   Gdynia, Poland   (09.22.10)
If Salma's message was "with a tear", why the little smirking smiley?
10. Sharon
judith ,   IL   (09.22.10)
Why is Sharon's family allowing this "living" death to continue? Kindness dictates that Sharon be allowed to die peacefully.
11. Its time to let him die
zionist forever   (09.22.10)
Sharon is a brain dead and if it wasn't for the fact we are artificially keeping him alive his organs would shut down and he would die physically as well. Lets bury him and allow him to be remembered for the patriot who served his country many times which despite his mistakes he was.
12. Not fit for printing...
tom ,   tel aviv   (09.22.10)
Why is it un-PC to wish someone other than "good things"??! It certainly is false/unhuman. We love but we also retain quite a capability to hate: that's how She made us..! In that vein I wish Mr.Sharon a long nightmares-filled sleep in his ranch, for the stab in the back of our nation. Also (even more so) for making me more cynical towards the so called democratic -voting process. As a result I shall vote no more ! Not that it makes any bloody difference in this country. Maybe I vwas naive& young once ?
13. Ariel Sharon
john   (09.22.10)
Ariel Sharon is one of the greatest if not "THE" greatest generals the 20th century has produced.
14. Hey Guys,
Salma ,   Palestine   (09.22.10)
George W. Bush can help you understand my intention in TB #1, #6 Ben Wink was to tell you that our memories are not BAD ;)
15. Sharon is still suffering because the govt has not paid up
Shalom   (09.22.10)
the compensation they owe for his foolish expulsion of 10,000 Jews from their homes who were left homeless and without a livelihood.
16. Let's keep him alive as long as it takes
Zico   (09.22.10)
What's the big deal in keeping him alive? He's a symbol of what Israel and its people are all about. Jews all around the world should be proud of.
17. Mastermind of expulsion is a big black mrk on sharon
Norman   (09.22.10)
18. What a Bad/Inhumane Finish!
Bill ,   USA   (09.22.10)
...But this is a man of a lot of innocent blood on his hands. Sabra and Shatila massacre, killing and burying Egyptian POWs, killing innocent bystanders with his "targeted assassinations," etc. Is this bad finish a form of justice to his victims. I think so.
19. Frank No 2: Sharon - The Butcher of Sabra and Shatila
Kim ,   Australia   (09.22.10)
Frank, where was the care and empathy the 3000 Palestinians murdered in Sabra and Shatila? The Israeli Kahan Commission found Ariel Sharon "indirectly responsible" for the 1982 mass murder of Palestinian men, women and children, which were carried out by Israel's Phalangist allies - who had been trained and funded by Israel. Israeli troops lit the camps so the massacre could be carried out and they stop Palestinians from exiting the camp. The Israeli high command had a panoramic view of the two camps for 3 days and were well aware of what was happening there. So tell me, where was the care for the sick and inured, where was the regard for the '[other' and the empathy you demand of Salma and the Palestinians. The Butcher of Sabra and Shatila had none, so is it any wonder Salm has little for him.
20. Nobody is allowed to give Israel land away.
John ,   UK   (09.22.10)
It is all written, any person who takes the land away from the Jewish people will be doomed!
21. I agree with Salma
Avi ,   NYC, NY   (09.22.10)
I served in the IDF during the 1982 war in Lebanon and saw first hand the fruits of Sharon's, and Israel's, hate towards humanity. I fully agree with Salma. I also do not have empathy towards monsters like Sharon. As to Frank's comment (#2): Does he think that all war criminals deserve empathy? Also Nazi war criminals? Or is his empathy reserved only for Jewish war criminals?
22. Michal #5
Jane   (09.22.10)
Salma's comment was with a wink, not a tear, lefty girl
23. How much does it cost to the taxpayers ?
Michel ,   Jerusalem   (09.22.10)
And there is no money for other patients ..
24. #1 Sharon's coma is medical
Cynthia ,   USA   (09.22.10)
Your leaders are in a self-induced coma to make sure nothing changes. You Salma, are at the mercy of people (Fatah & Hamas) who have marched backward for decades.
25. 23 Michel, Jerusalem: How much would it have cost to rebuild
Rivkah   (09.22.10)
Tel Aviv if the rockets from Lebanon had hit there in 2006 which they were capable of doing but by the mercy of Yahweh did not. The ELS Bible codes say, "HaShem loves A(riel) Sharon." That love is an umbrella of protection for Tel Aviv that is now being lost so that Beersheva is protected by Yahweh's love for Sharon. I have felt at times the prayers of Ariel Sharon for Israel and that is his occupation and job, now. The spirit never sleeps and he prays for the people. To you, that is not worth his medical care costs because you don't know Yahweh or you would love who Yahweh loves. How many people are mentioned by name in the ELS Torah codes or the surface text of the Bible and then have a phrase that Yahweh loves them? Not many. Yahweh loves many people, but a few are so loved that that is designated in the Bible or the ELS Torah codes.
26. Typical Response from Oz..They say ignorance is bliss ,,But!
Ross ,   USA   (09.23.10)
but you madam take the biscuit for sure.It was not Sharon who butchered the people of sabra And Shatila you ignorant stupid woman but it was the PHALANGISTS who carried out the murders.And with good reason for they made the life of the Lebanese Christians HELL. Anywhere Muslim, Arabs are,they cause murder and mayham.As it is still happening NOW.. Hey woman wake up,THEY KILL EACH OTHER MERCILESLY .It is their modus operandi and modus vivendi Just Islamofascism permeating all over the world like CANCER... Having read your whole convoluted and wrong post methinks you must have been present during the incident to write such a damned stupid post. FULL OF BULLSHIT. Suggest you read from a reliable source on the real episode before jumping to conclusions erroneously. As for that salma who puts her address as palestine ---IF IT WASN'T SO SAD IT WOULD BE LAUGHABLE.No such country was/is arab palis as yet..and never WILL BE. LET ME EDUCATE YOU ..there is NO "P" in the arabic alphabet to begin with,plus the WHOLE OF ISRAEL IS JEWISH And the arabs are the Squatters in the land of Jews lsrael. The so-called pals NEVER EXISTED nor are they now OR EVER TO BE SO.
27. Sharon
JE ,   USA   (09.23.10)
While I am very sad for the family having to go through this, I'm wondering if anyone has given a thought to what Ariel Sharon would want? What would Arial Sharon chose to do if he could make his own decision? Would he want to be kept alive by artificial means year after year laying in a hospital bed? Is it perhaps selfish of the family to keep him alive in this state? Is this state only benefiting the family because they can not bear the loss? Mr. Sharon is already gone. Wouldn't it be better to let him go and rest in peace? There may be things that God has planned for him to do that are being hindered by this artificial life support. It's time to let him go. We know now that he will never wake up and we also know that death is not the end of human existence. Ask yourself family, if you were brain dead, would you want to be kept alive by artificial means? There is not much dignity in that...please let him go in peace.
Back to article