Jewish Scene
Top rabbis: IDF conversions endorse gentiles as Jews
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 13.10.10, 07:40
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
92 Talkbacks for this article
61. to 60 , can't this non jew you adore not answer
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.14.10)
himself ? yeshu is the same guy as your ribi . netzarim talmid ? with a goyish "teacher" ! better to call him a baptist missionary .
62. 60 , and paqid is not Jewish !
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.14.10)
So what if he was born Jewish ? his followers are NOT Jews , not important how they call him .
63. Talula 59 . Some people need religion !
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.14.10)
otherwise how would they behave ? You don't need it , you live a correct life , don't steal , murder , deceive others . But for some ......[ and even with religion , some ......]
64. #6,that's how we know you are still a gentile
Ephraim   (10.14.10)
because you dare talk about daat torah disparagingly. You DID NOT accept Torah SheBeChtav, and Torah SheBaalPel in your heart, you just wanted to feel "Israeli Jewish" whatever that means.You probably don't keep any mitzvot of the Torah at all.
65. to59 talula helene thomas tongue
THE MIRROR   (10.14.10)
Your look too?
66. to 58 greene
Sookie ,   Bon Temps, Louisiana   (10.14.10)
very nicely said...i couldn't agree more!
67. 62 It is wrong to call an honest man a liar.
Eliyahu Konn ,   Powell, OH   (10.14.10)
Your big thing is being born Jewish so why do you say, "So what if he was born Jewish?" You say evil things about the students of a man you don't know a thing about except what Xtians tell you. He never was a Xtian. Upstanding Jewish men and women that knew him weren't Xtians either. You keep perpetuating the lie about him and about those who want to set the story straight. Sooner or later every honest student of world and Jewish history who puts forth the effort will come to this conclusion. Eliyahu Konn Netzarim talmid www.netzarim.co.il Restoring the name of a Torah observant Jewish man.
68. 63 Asked and answered Charles
Talula ,   Israel   (10.14.10)
That's what I'm saying. I don't need to believe in anyone but myself. I know what is right and what is wrong, I know how good it feels to help others, I know how good it feels to see my children grow into truly amazing people who love their country, I know how good it feels to work and pay my own way in life. And all without the help of some man-made fable. Why? because I have self-confidence and I'm a strong person. Weak people don't have the spine to get up in the morning and go their own way in life without consulting a rabbi, for everything or consulting a book to see what to do next. Pityful. It's not religion that makes a person who they are. It's the essence of the soul.
69. 65 Cracked mirror
Talula ,   Israel   (10.14.10)
What's the matter, can't you string together a full sentence? If you are too thick to understand that you don't need to be religious to be a decent person, I can't help you. How you can even compare me to Helen Thomas is beyond me. Get a life!!!
70. 58 The UN agreed to give Israel to us
(10.14.10)
71. Just look at the picture of Rabbi Shalom Elyashiv
Talula ,   Israel   (10.14.10)
He looks like something from Fiddler on the Roof. I bet that man has never had a good laugh in his entire life. No vitality there whatsoever - his only purpose in life is to weed out the seculars and non Jews and rip them apart. What a sad old Git.
72. To66 Thank you Sookie
Greene ,   Israel   (10.14.10)
73. Ephraim #64
Ex-Orthodox Jew ,   Israel   (10.15.10)
Yeah, to say something against Halachic cast system and blatant racism disqualifies you as a Jew... God is much greater than any man-made boundaries claimed to be divine. There's one basic difference between you and the Orthodox convert #6: this guy is a mensch, you're not.
74. I am a convert
Aussi Yehudi ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (10.15.10)
I am an orthodox convert. I was converted in Sydney Australia by the Sydney Bet Din. I have met many Orthodox Rabbis who are kind, gentle, loving and fully accepting of sincere converts. I have also met some hateful racist rabbis but they are the minority. The Rabbis that I admire the most are those in the Chabad movement. We converts, no matter how sincere, know what it feels like to be discriminated against by racist bigoted Jews. I have been hurt several times by people whom I considered to be close friends. But I have also experienced unbelievable warmth and friendship.
75. 74 Please tell me WHY you converted
Talula ,   Israel   (10.15.10)
and how your life is different from what it was before, I really need to understand this. Thank you
76. 67 , a honest man ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.15.10)
who had a heading " ministry of absorption" on his website ? Who told people that he received blessings from the Chief Rabbi while it was a polite formula from the chief Rabbi's secretary ? Is this a honest man for you ? I know of two cases where people , born Jewish , betrayed other Jews during WWII , and by acting so send them to their death .
77. No talkbacker more dishonest than 76!
(10.15.10)
78. To54Charles
ORA ,   Jerusalem   (10.15.10)
You talked like a "chef".Charles.I am impressed.Shabat Shalom.
79. 77 , worthless barking from worthless bipede
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.15.10)
80. The list of names in the article...
seadog1946 ,   Shooters Island, NJ   (10.15.10)
Elyashiv, Shteinman, Karelitz and Auerbach... don't sound very Lithuanian.
81. 80 , you're ignorant about Jewish names
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.16.10)
82. To69Mirror in reparation
ORA ,   jerusalem   (10.16.10)
You did not answer by insults,as ordinary people do ,this shows you are of a higher level.I take back the insult and hope you forgive me.You have a nice style ,you could use it for better,than stereotypes like your last sentence#59.Hate incitement is the beginning of all the horrible and big wars along the centuries.That is not what you want. Again sorry,but your last sentence sound to me,the same as you would feel,if after having read a newspaper i would say:the secular are criminals,rapists,drugaddictsetc...I would never write that,because i know there are outstanding secular people.May be you don t know that there are also fine religious people,because it is not an interesting subject for newspapers.Have you heard of Rabbi Grossman who helped a lot secular children from the street;Rabbi Levin who visited on a regular basis secular prisoners;Ezer vezion Yad Sarah Zaka etc.We are greater if we look for good sides in people.Have a lovely weak. ORA
83. To 78 "ora" . Changed your name to Ora ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.16.10)
84. To83CharlesYes Ora isa penname
ORA ,   Jerusalem   (10.16.10)
85. To 84 , as was your precedent ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.16.10)
86. Talula I'm not 74 but you ask a very serious question...
(10.16.10)
why do you want to know?
87. To85Charles
ORA ,   Jerusalem   (10.16.10)
Questions are never indiscrete. Answers sometimes are. Receipt of my kitchen.
88. To Ora , 87 TRY # 2
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.17.10)
The way you write , your style and ideas make me Think [ again! ] at a person who wrote : goodbye Charles , some days ago . You can't hide your person .
89. #11
ORTHODOX CONVERT NO2   (10.19.10)
You have NO IDEA how much you sre right... People from less preferred countries of former soviet block are being thrown logs under their feet... And I am talking of people who HAVE Jewish origins (in at least 1/4th) they themselves are even circumsized and decided to come back to jewish roots, keeping kosher and wearing kippah... Just because they come less preferred countries. But people from Western Europe, US (rich countries) are not even checked for their sincerity. All because such Lithuanian/Marroccan-super-duper-orthodox rabbis...
90. #30 Mikey
David ,   America   (10.19.10)
These men are in military service. They may die defending Eretz Israel. Have you considered that they may wish to die Jews?
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article