News
Senior Republican against US aid to Palestinians
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 12.11.10, 09:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
89 Talkbacks for this article
31. Not surprising
Andrew ,   USA   (11.12.10)
Ileana Ros-Lehtinen has JEWISH roots and also represents a very large JEWISH district of South Florida. She constantly votes against anything having to do with the Palestinian authority. The only funding she would support giving the Palestinians is funding to load them onto box cars and ship them out to Jordan. Thats where she stands.
32. CUT OFF ALL AIDE!
David ,   USA   (11.12.10)
I agree, we should CUT OFF ALL AIDE to the Palestinians. It only serves to subsidize ISRAEL's occupation of the lands. Israel should be the one that is responsible for the welfare of the Palestinian people they occupy. They should foot the bill instead of countries like America and the EU who artificially prop up a completely non-viable Palestinian economy that wouldn't exist otherwise due to the restrictions of living under occupation. My dream is for the West to cut off all aid, the Palestinian economy to fall apart, the Palestinian Authority to dissolve, and then forcing Israel to deal with the ensuing chaos. That is exactly what would happen without all this aid...so please keep on cheering Ros-Lethtinen.
33. aid to the palestinians
a ash ,   tel aviv   (11.12.10)
thank gd somebody is willing to stand up to their scams -and make them do the right thing
34. I am ashamed this woman is still in Congress
Mikesailor ,   Miami, FL   (11.12.10)
In Miami, we have a curious disconnect not unlike Israel. Ros-Lehtinen exemplifies this curious cogntive disconnect. In fact, her entire career rests on demogoguery. For years, the Cuban exile population voted on one basis: "Cuba si, Castro no." It didn't, and to some extent still doesn't matter, what happens domestically as long as you could continually show anti-Castro fervor in sufficient quantity. All attempts at ameliorating the situation between Cuba and the US have been held hostage to this insanity. She hasn't stopped there however. She has also been at the forefront of pandering to the worst excesses of zionism in order to maintain her campaign contributions from the wealthy Jewish population in the area. Every issue is demagogued as black and white in her Manichean pronouncements, with no regard to the damage it causes. She should be a Likudnik. Now, after the PA recognized Israel, she wants more blood. She whines about the unfairness that the Palestinaians would dare to complain about the occupation. She is truly a hypocrite of the first order. Meanwhile, Castro has announced that he, to bring some sort of fiscal sanity to his country, which has been embargoed for the past sixty years by the US, is going to lay off 500,000 Cubans from their government jobs. This may be the precursor of a new boatlift of destitute Cubans which would dwarf the Mariel boatlift of the 1980's.Yet does Ros-Lehtinen speak of that? Of course not. The new governor-elect of Florida speaks of an Arizona- type immigration law whereby "illegal' immigrants could be thrown in jail by the state. Does she speak on that subject? Of course not because Cubans have their own 'Law of Return', i.e the Cuban Adjustment Act of 1966 giving immediate legal resident status to all Cubans who manage to reach US soil. Does she advocate the termination of such special status? Never. For these are her future constituents. Perhaps people do get the government they deserve. Holding up this pathetic excuse of a pandering politician as an exemplar of any sort of 'Statesman' is truly insane.
35. To 34 , Maybe people in Miami are ashamed
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (11.12.10)
that you vegetate amongst them ?
36. Sprotje 24 . Look at this example
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (11.12.10)
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3971791,00.html
37. #7 Split - You must be wrong about her parents
David Israel ,   New York, USA   (11.12.10)
I am a Turkish Jew and have a pretty good knowledge about the genealogy of Turkish Sephardi. Ileana's father Enrique Emilio Ros y Perez was not Jewish and from the name it is very unlikely that his parents were Turkish Jews. His Wife Amanda Adato might be a Turkish Jew but but my family was very close to the Adato's of Istanbul (The famous Lawyer Adato was my grandfather's partner in his law practice and a close family friend) while the Adato family in Izmir also were my personal close friends since my childhood in 1950ies. None had family ties in Cuba. If you have concrete information about Mr. Ros' Jewish family ties please explain otherwise I must say that all of your claims are unfounded heresy.
38. not 60, not 90 billion a year of hard earned taxpayers money
observer   (11.12.10)
Israel is NOT getting 4 billion of our tax dollars per year. Go look it up, you will have to search very hard. They are only reporting US Tax dollars given as military aid to Israel that is written down on paper, and even that is a lie. Israel just got 15 billion last year, so the media is lieing even about the actual amount of money that is written down on paper. The fact is that when you consider all the Military, economic, Housing, Infrastructure, and all other aids given to Israel, and adding to it the additional money and resources that are given to Israel "under the table", you will notice that Israel is getting at least more than 90 billion dollars of US tax dollars per year. Now add to it the Holocaust extortion money that they get from Germany and other European countries. Also consider that the US went to war with Iraq and has spent more than one trillion dollars in that war, which was all done for the benefit of Israel.
39. Arafat was worth over 1.3 billion; how is that? sex with
Jae ,   Lynn US   (11.12.10)
male prostitues and small boys and dies of aids. yea we know who give our money to...LOL. Jordan is Palestine, there is your solution on so man levels: 78% of palestine mandate land is in Jordan! 80% of Jordans population is "Palestinian" The prince is "Palestinian" and will be the heir to the throne; a "Palestinian King ruling a territory that is 80% of the palestine mandate with a population that is 80% palestinian....or a continued impasse because no israeli government ewishes to be 8 miles wide. That is suicide surrounded by enemies.
40. It's about time!
Pino ,   Toronto   (11.12.10)
Makes perfect sense to me. It's about time someone realized what's happening in the PA. There's no reason to reward them for their lack of discipline.
41. #7. split: the Jew hater unless is leftist
Thomas ,   Dixieland USA   (11.12.10)
Do you have problem with Soros and other leftist Jew's Jewish roots? Are you bashing the Obamabot Jews too? Why not?. Republicans won and you Islamofascist acolyte lost. My condolences.
42. One of our best in Congress
RayS ,   USA   (11.12.10)
This lady is always strong on sensible US foreign policy,, excellent on US defense structure, veterans, Israel, Latin America, you name it. She is a First Class USA Patriot..We are fortunate to have her in Congress.
43. Observer 38 . Your sources please .
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (11.12.10)
for those 'numbers" ! but most likely they are your own invention .
44. i want to have her baby
david ,   new york   (11.12.10)
finally, we've got some good people back in washington. there is nothing like a republican cuban american - they know what its all about!
45. to # 34 : We are ashamed of you
reality check ,   maimi   (11.12.10)
i live in her district and i vote for her and donate money to her .. i would rather have her on my side than a million jerks like you .. i read your post and it tells me that you are a blithering idiot who must live in an alternative universe to the one in Miami where sane people reside. I take from your post that you are nothing more thant another anti semite who thinks Israel is always bad and the terror loving palestinians are victims. they are but of their own stupidity. anyway, your post is a joke full of hypothetical statemensts from which you draw your pre determined conclusions ... but then again that how haters operate ...
46. "observer's" aid numbers are pure rubbish
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (11.12.10)
He claims Israel just got 15 billion last year" and later that the true number is "90 billion dollars" last year. Rubbish. Since 1979 as part of the Camp David accords, Israel has been receiving about $3 (THREE) billion per year, while Egypt has received about $2.2 billion. It was a mix of military and economic aid but is today strictly military, of which roughly 75% must be spent on US goods. Even adding special add-ons to support joint projects like the Arrow defense system, it has yet to top $4 billion - EVER. The US has *never* had to cover loan guarantees, as all the loans have been paid in full. And let's not forget that when one adds US aid to Lebanon, Jordan, and the Palestinians, the total exceeds what goes to Israel. One more thing. What Israel does FOR the US in the region means the US doesn't have to do it themselves. Just think about how much the US spends on their bases in Germany, Turkey and South Korea. Each one costs the US far more than it gives to Israel.
47. Cantor and Ros-Lehtinen in 2012
David ,   Hartford USA   (11.12.10)
Dream ticket for America! (or maybe Ros-Lehtinen and Cantor!) And why would Obama so easily throw 150 mil towards Abbas, who still supports the destruction of Israel, (even if he plays nice to Obama?) Has Obama ever said, "Mr. Abbas, STOP every anti-Israel TV program, REMOVE every school textbook that doesn't show Israel properly (or at all), DON'T EVER show a map of 'Palestine' as replacing Israel." No, he hasn't. Because he's either a COWARD or he wants to run for Caliph when the 'few misguided' hijackers of the 'great, worldwide religion of Islam' take over the western world in the next 15 years.
48. 37 - You must be wrong about her parents
split ,   US   (11.12.10)
We're talking about her paternal grandparents - Ileana is a "closet" Jew. To get a foot in her district's political door she identified herself as an Episcopalian. She's hiding the fact that she has Jewish roots and doesn't give a crap about US or her countryman interest. She would sell her mother to be re-elected. Jewish votes and money make it possible to stay in Congress. Peace !!! ,...
49. she is right
Ahmad ,   nablus   (11.12.10)
After all israel had fullfilled its committment to open the roiads off road blocks, release all abductees (11 thousands of them) stop (actually dismantling) colnies, just last week, they announced the "dismanltement" of 3000 housing units, target killing it is now in the past. So, why give thosse dirty Palis the money, to "incite hatred against the poor jews" no, no and more no...I agree with you moron
50. # 41 - split: the Jew hater unless is leftist
split ,   US   (11.12.10)
Nope, dude , I'm a Libertarian, fisco conservative, against foreign aid, any aid except for an emergency needs, I'm against the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan , tax deductible donations to foreign countries especially to those that can afford an occupation - Spare me that "you hate me" crap if you don't intent to complement me.
51. #7 splitt US
james ,   uk   (11.12.10)
why didn't Hon. Hussein Obama, your first American Muslim president resurrect the bill? Bush didn't do it but Obama can!!.
52. To: No. 7 - THIRD ATTEMPT
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.12.10)
Congresswoman Ros-Lehtinen is an Episcopalian, and she is of Cuban extraction. In fact, she was born in Havana, Cuba, as were her parents, grandparents and great-grandparents. She represents a district in Florida which is 95% Latino. If she votes consistently in a pro-Israel fashion, it is because she is smart and has not been swayed or deluded by "Palestinian" spin. Guess what? She represents the predominant view in Congress. Eat your terrorist heart out.
53. To: No. 48
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.12.10)
The Congresswoman is a devout, church-going Episcopalian. Her Spanish heritage in Cuba stretches back to the 1700s, which is to say long before her paternal grandparents were a twinkle in anyone's eye. Not a Turk in sight; not a Jew in sight. Think up a better story next time.
54. To: No. 50
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (11.12.10)
Well, that certainly would explain the virulent Jew-hatred. Before Lyndon LaRouche re-invented himself as a "Libertarian," he was chief aide-de-camp to George Lincoln Rockwell, of American Nazi Party fame. Busted, Split. Now, no one will ever take you seriously! (Not that we have until now, actually ....). But this time, we won't be able to contain ourselves from rolling on the floor, laughing at your posts.
55. #48 Enjoy watching you squirm
Cynthia ,   USA   (11.12.10)
About time the Palestinians were held accountable. And this has nothing to do with her religious orientation. Get used to it because there is more to come.
56. About time
Alexander ,   NJ, USA/Israel   (11.13.10)
Good to see people in office getting tough on the Arabs. Don't give them an exit excuse, they are desperately looking for one. The Arabs will do anything and say everything not to have peace with a Jewish State.
57. #48 _ I am also talking about her paternal ancestors
David Israel ,   New York, USA   (11.13.10)
Enrique Emilio Ros y Perez is not a name related to any Turkish Sephardi as far as my genealogical knowledge is concerned. I am an open minded person. If you have any concrete information to links her to any Turkish Jew please let us know. Until then your post is just heresy and no merit at all. I am waiting for your proof.
58. To: No. 7 - THIRD ATTEMPT
split ,   US   (11.13.10)
Before you say anythinkg in regard of this case would you please give us some hasbara crap in respond of the previous one ??? ,... http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3981705,00.html Thanks ,...
59. 52 - as were her parents, grandparents and great-grandparen
split ,   US   (11.13.10)
Get a life, woman - Project Vote Smart lists Ros-Lehtinen as Episcopalian.[1] Ros-Lehtinen's maternal grandparents were Sephardic Jews from Turkey who had been active in Cuba's Jewish community.[28] Her mother later converted to Catholicism.[28] ,... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ileana_Ros-Lehtine Have nice day and get some sleep,...
60. points of counter aid
observer   (11.13.10)
1- No funds released until all settlement construction is halted in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. 2- No funds released until Israel opens up Gaza. 3- No funds released until the Administration fully investigates Israel's possible violations of the US Arms Export Control Act in the recent attack on Gaza – including the preliminary evidence in the Goldstone Report. 4- No funds released until Israel has withdrawn all military checkpoints, barriers, troops, walls/fences, military zones and installations from the West Bank (the pre June 5, 1967 borders).
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article