News
Sister of Bilin victim dies in anti-fence protest
Yair Altman
Published: 01.01.11, 10:37
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
42 Talkbacks for this article
1. Moshe Dayan quoted April 1969, Ha'aretz
frank ,   usa   (01.01.11)
Jewish villages were built in the place of Arab villages. You do not even know the names of these Arab villages, and I do not blame you because geography books no longer exist. Not only do the books not exist, the Arab villages are not there either. Nahlal arose in the place of Mahlul; Kibbutz Gvat in the place of Jibta; Kibbutz Sarid in the place of Huneifis; and Kefar Yehushua in the place of Tal al-Shuman. There is not a single place built in this country that did not have a former Arab population."
2. good news. we are at war stupid !
(01.01.11)
3. @1 Dayan is dead, Palestine is a live
Palestinian   (01.01.11)
4. This what happens when one plays with fire...!!
JBI   (01.01.11)
5. #1
IZL   (01.01.11)
There is not a place built in this country pre 1948 that had not once housed Jewish populations, just ask Joshua ben nun. Ask Jewish King David. Ask emperor Hadrian. Then again, history books no longer exist along with those purported geo books you speak of.
6. A Very bad beginning of 2011 !
Salma ,   Palestine   (01.01.11)
kill peaceful demonstrators for survival of repressive occupation regime. Shame on you, "Israel"!
7. ...and all these Arab villages used to sit on former Jewish
Bat Zion ,   Central Israel   (01.01.11)
villages and town from the time before the Arab occupation, and preserve their original Hebrew names.
8. I feel sorry for the poor woman and her family.
Bat Zion ,   Central Israel   (01.01.11)
9. Lie down with terror dogs, you may wake up dead.....
Adina Kutnicki ,   Israel   (01.01.11)
Them's the breaks in this war of attrition.So, if the terror supporting activists are going to continually ! harass our sovereignty then they better be prepared for blow back. Tough.Cry me a river.....
10. Frank please...
Giuseppe D. ,   Italy   (01.01.11)
Whoever selected this quote for propoganda cut out Dayan's words: "we purchased the land from Arabs and set up Jewish villages where there had once been Arab villages". Dayan was urging coexistence as the longterm solution to the area's conflict.
11. Brother and sister
Jules   (01.01.11)
Looks like the whole family had nothing better to do than participating in suicidal demonstrations. They didn't have a better idea how to spend their lives; why should that be Israel's problem ?
12. Frank: and Azaria is called in the name of Beit Eliezer...
Ariel   (01.01.11)
and most of arab villages are built on old jewish towns or settlements, and so on...your propaganda does not stand any argument.
13. family deaths #1
jo moor   (01.01.11)
Must be a genetic family weakness. Jungle laws apply out in the wild.= survival of the fittest.
14. #1
jo moor   (01.01.11)
.........and before the peace loving arabs the Jews were there. Great attempts are being made to earase evidence of Jewish presence. It will not work. The poor arabs have a genetic predisposition to succumb to a modern ailment - lying continuously and confabulating inbetween. Maybe 2011 will be different. I wont hold my breath!
15. I am sure she kept calling "from the river to the sea,...
Jehudah   (01.01.11)
...Palestine will be free". Translation: Wipe off the face of earth the nation-state of the Jewish people...!! And if this is the case, why should anyone be surprised a conflict still exists...??!!
16. #3 Palestine is Dead
Dan ,   Titusville, FL   (01.01.11)
Since the days of the Romans Palestine has been dead. Read, if you can, history books that show Jordan as your ancestral home to which the Lord Almighty commands you to return.
17. Violence
Woody ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (01.01.11)
This horrible country has proven that it won't allow the non-violent option. Killing non-violent protesters creates only one other option - May violence once again return to our streets, cafes, and homes until this nation has paid for her crimes. Then we can ask for forgiveness and to be asked in the fold of humanity once again.
18. # 16 the golden calf
jj   (01.01.11)
19. Playing with fire means you get burned!
(01.01.11)
20. Throwing stones on soldiers is a dangerous sport
Israeli   (01.01.11)
Throwing stones on soldiers is a very dangerous sport
21. woody
Linichka ,   Gdynia, Poland   (01.01.11)
Had it indeed been a peaceful demonstration, there would have been no use of tear gas. If you think Israel so "horrible", get off your roost at the Sheinkin Street cafe and go to Gaza.
22. 21 christians killed by muslims in Egypt and no headline !
(01.01.11)
23. Why is this your main headline? WHO CARES?
Avi ,   Tel Aviv   (01.01.11)
24. "Non violent protest" - with stones that kill!!
WHAT A LIE   (01.01.11)
25. publish the name of who shoot.
ivan   (01.01.11)
26. police state
daz ,   uk   (01.01.11)
The Israeli Supreme Court declared this part of the wall illegal but the IDF refuse to comply which means Israel has become more of a police state than a Jewish one.
27. sad and tragic
peter42y ,   lisbon,portugal   (01.01.11)
Very sad and tragic. 2 brothers.., both killed in protests that ,after all, do not claim many victims. Some people, families are really unlucky. I think people should show more respect for the deceased woman.
28. #12
frank ,   usa   (01.01.11)
Justification of an Israeli state by historical right is nonsense.Jews chose to emigrate arab were forced out.The jews can not appeal to a twenty-century-old historical right. I there is no such thing as a historical right. Egypt, arab,rome Mesopotamia, jew Christians, moslom and Turkey all have claim about the same land. jew biblical claim is not valid because most Christians believe they themselves replace the Jews as the New jew
29. #3 Prove it.
(01.01.11)
30. "Non-violent" Protest?!?!?
Ste ,   UK   (01.01.11)
Taken from said article: The Israel Defense Forces said at the time that Palestinians were hurling stones and other objects at security forces and were trying to tear the security fence.
Next talkbacks
Back to article