News
Did Palestinians lie about protestor's death?
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 04.01.11, 00:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
59 Talkbacks for this article
31. an autopsy has to be performed...
eporue ,   europe   (01.04.11)
...cause of death "tear gas" isnt acceptable... there is, besides compensation claims etc, a public interest, to have it determined for sure.
32. The Arabs, for decades, have tried to produce heroes at the
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (01.04.11)
expense of the Jews, this case being only the latest fabrication in the long list of fabrications, the material from which they then stitch together their "narrative" and some, e.g. B.H.Obama, actually acquire them and live by them...!!
33. there needs to be a story brought to the west about all the
rachel ,   usa   (01.04.11)
lies.......
34. Mission Accomplished...
Hakim ,   Palestine   (01.04.11)
35. Pollack
R ,   Israel   (01.04.11)
1) Mr. Pollack, don't let the facts confuse you. 2) The family has a lot to gain in both status and poosibly stippends if the death is attributed to the IDF's actions as opposed to a medical condition that the deceased may have had.
36. Crap ! why now ?! why Jawaher?!
Salma ,   Palestine   (01.04.11)
It's time to Stop using deadly tear gas, It's time to respect other people's minds.
37. only palis use their dead to make political
ghostq   (01.04.11)
statment, it revolting make your stomach turn, abusing Israel like that now every canser patience in the WB from now on will have to do flip flop to get aid, it won't come from Israel since this might rerun as unjustify law suit, palis used to get money even when they don't deserve like the olive that were never cut to cover poor crop year and this yet another example of them trying to manipulate the system cause they know for sure they will get money and sympathy, with this type of behavior none can make peace.
38. to salma, tear gaz can only cause tears
ghostq   (01.04.11)
like peper spray, it is safe unless someone hit by the can.
39. It's really all about money and honour.
JO   (01.04.11)
stipends for martyrs, or being able to sue the IDF/Israel. I can imagine if she was dying with cancer and would leave penniless, such a "death" by IDF/Israel, would be more glorious and would help her family, not to mention aid the "cause" Lying would only be a means to an end. For me, it is a shame and a dis- honor but anything can be made legitimate if you clothe it in the mantle of honor for the "cause". Personal conscience goes out the window. A sad low but not an unusual event. Sadly truth goes out the window and that is why this will never end.
40. #36 Another pathetic Pallywood story
Cynthia ,   USA   (01.04.11)
Palestinian reports indicate this woman was not present at the protest which explains why no photo of her. Cameras and video equipment are readily available at these protests along with slingshots and rocks. They said she wasn't feeling well and started to vomit. She was taken to the hospital and died. This became a golden Pallywood opportunity with her mother wailing about her martyrdom. I
41. Salma, other people's minds say "Palestine" is fake
(01.04.11)
42. Palestinian protestor and IDF.
DT ,   TA Israel   (01.04.11)
Most likely the IDF had nothing to do with it .The Palestinians shot the protestor, blame the IDF and get world anti Israel publicity because they have the global media on their side
43. Tear gas is not deadly
Carsten Schmidt ,   Germany   (01.04.11)
Tear gas is not a deadly weapon, and it is used all over the world for crowd control, in Germany, in US, in Iran, everywhere. It can only directly cause death when used in high concentration in a closed room. In rare cases it can cause severe health complications when people have certain health conditions such as allergies. If you have such a conditions you don't go to violent demonstrations where tear gas may be used. The use of tear gas was obviously ligitimate in this case and the cries about 'war crimes' are more than ridiculous. CS [sic!], Germany
44. Propaganda
Barbara ,   Haifa Israel   (01.04.11)
Same old, same old. Pali lies as usual.
45. put it in another way, what type of eyewitness do you prefer
observer   (01.04.11)
46. Palestinianism is a big lie- arabs came turn of century for
jae ,   lynn us   (01.04.11)
JOBS. the vast majority. even their surnames tell you this...saying they are from egypt syria libya arabia iraq lebanon etc
47. #21, the protesters film it
Danny   (01.04.11)
and so far not a single one has shown this woman being treated for tear gas let alone dying from it.
48. #24 because the IDF unlike the Palestinians
Danny   (01.04.11)
get crucified if they make the tiniest mistake. Tear gas killing someone in an open field? Pretty damn unlikely.
49. #25, who cares about facts keep with the narrative
Danny   (01.04.11)
50. how can medical report contain puzzling DETAILS
observer   (01.04.11)
for the burial was undertaken via an accelerated procedure, and no post-mortem was performed. Why other demonstrators inhaled gas and didn't die. Well!, when medications combined with the tear gas and the skunk bombs it can kill. what about the plenty proofs and eyewitnesses of her presence there. Ask yourself do you really believe the IDF version?
51. you believe the IDF, you disbelieve Palestinian medical repo
observer   (01.04.11)
52. #25 Cynic
Madeleine ,   Israel   (01.04.11)
The fact that you talk of Israelis as "they" points to the fact that you don't live here. So what do you know about the situation here other than what you read and see in the media? On the other hand, Pali lies have been exposed time and time again; they just keep making it up as they go along. As for colonial settlement, go read your history. don't know where in the world you live, but America is nothing more than a former British colony built on land stolen from the "indigenous" antive Americans. Only then there was no media to expose american war crimes. Same can be said for Europe in the past.
53. #33 Stories to the West
Madeleine ,   Israel   (01.04.11)
Rachel, Israel tells the West time and again about Palestinian lies and exposes them but learnign the truth is not on the West's agenda as long as it is hell bent on appeasing its Moslem population. also, Israel tries to tell the truth whereas the Palestinians tell lie after lie and let's face it, when you are making it up, you can say whatever you like. the West is only too ready to believe it.
54. #36 Salma in Fakeland
Madeleine ,   Israel   (01.04.11)
How abou you just stop shooting at us and trying to kill us. You palis lay down your arms and there will be peace tomorrow. We stop defending ourselves and it will herald our demise. Nice try.
55. In Israel we have Freedom of Speech not Freedom to lie!
David ,   Karmiel, Israel   (01.04.11)
It is time that the "lefties" were called to task for maliciously lying. Many Israelis don't agree with the "Occupation" and particularly the "illegal" settlements. However, every time an Israeli or, for that matter, a Jew lies to further the hatred of Israel they should be brought up on criminal charges for Treason or crimes against the Jewish people. What these "lefties" don't seem to understand is that if Israel should cease to exist, as their "friends" so eagerly desire, they will stabbed in the back by those very same "friends". It should be noted that NONE of these left wingers have chosen to go and live in Palestine. I wonder why.
56. Nedd an instant Martyr?please contact Haniyeh
josef   (01.04.11)
or Abbas. It can be arranged with the click of a camera. All work is guaranty by a team of experts. Yonathan Pollack, how much do you get paid for your contribution to demonised islamic news?. How do you know that the " error " was caused by a doctor's ONE DIGIT misplaced or miswritten? You're sure it was not TWO DIGITS ? What is the doctor's name?. Please tell us, facts only and not arabian fantasies as your norm. Let's not forget that " faux martyr " is their specialty, with France 2 and the BBC always confirming as a matter of policy $$$$. And the STUPID world , brainwashed as usual, ready to acknowledge what this rotten islamic sect is telling, without any proof, with Satan's blessings. To Salma # 36 ; How can you respect other islamics minds, when it's all empty, full of sh...t instead.
57. Palestinean Drama Academy.
tejas ,   India   (01.04.11)
Palestinean people should start drama academy. It will become more popular than Hollywood.
58. Problem
John ,   Herzliya, Israel   (01.04.11)
I have no problem in identifying of Palestinian lies. The problem is that the world believes them 100%. Why? What will you do to change that fact?
59. #51 non - observer
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.05.11)
There is no need to believe or disbelive anyone All that's requires is they t perform an autopsy with impartial REAL observers that can see what's going on and verify the results
Previous talkbacks
Back to article