News
European diplomats: Israeli democracy in danger
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 12.01.11, 19:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
81 Talkbacks for this article
61. Is anyone really surprised?
DM   (01.13.11)
The modern European notion of "democracy" is doing nothing while a hostile, repressive culture takes over their streets, in the name of not "offending" minorities. That's not the true spirit of democracy, and I hope Israel doesn't go that way too.
62. I have one proposal for you
Jarda ,   Czech Republic   (01.13.11)
Let beggin a boycott of EU. Don't do any business with them. Withdraw from UEFA etc. The world is big enough and you can do business for example with your neighbours. And Hapoel can play AFC Champions League.
63. Its an enquiry about funding, what's the problem with that?
Scott ,   Australia   (01.13.11)
Yes, after considering what's proposed and reading through the various comments - its very difficult to see just why the EU would think that such an enquiry would be a problem - or anti-democratic? Most reasonable people would say that transparency is vital in a democracy. I definitely feel the EU has something to hide.
64. Knesset Sub-Committee on Un-Israeli Activities?
Yitzhak S ,   Hannaton, Israel   (01.13.11)
The proposed legislation in the Knesset echoes a dark chapter in US history, the period of McCarthyism when the lives of many innocent Americans were destroyed by often unproven allegations made against them that they belonged to the Communist Party and were taking directions from the Soviets. American democracy was nearly undermined as a result of this witch hunt. Transparency is one thing, a witch hunt against specific groups is quite another. If Knesset passes this legislation, then ALL NGOs operating in Israel, including such groups as Ateret Cohanim, should come under the same scrutiny. Finally, if some NGOs are suspected of receiving funding from terrorist organizations, then this is a criminal matter for the police, not for politicians with an axe to grind.
65. I don't see y political orgs should refuse
ghostq   (01.13.11)
those inquieries, after all the public got a full right where of his money goes and who really suppot orgs that got no electoral power, org that might disturb any democratic voting, if an org got no electoral power and wasn't vote for not get funds from the people he got no right of existance in democratic regim, and I think left or right doesn't matter they all should represent transparency of money transions other wise they might be involved in tax fraud.
66. to #39 wrong, Israelites as state existed
ghostq   (01.13.11)
twice before the modern age, the 1948 is natural continum of what was going on 2000 years ago.
67. The concern of European Diplomats.
Steven ,   Rockville, USA   (01.13.11)
It is time that the unknown European diplomats should be concerned with the demise of their own democracy. In Europe nobody can make a statement or a cartoon, without the danger of being eliminated. If that what they prefer, let them have it,
68. The european reaction just confirms
michael   (01.13.11)
Israelis thinking regarding the NGOs. The Europeans explotation of another Democrayic country is the only danger to all Democracyies. The united states has alot of disclosure rules regarding Charities. But if Israel would implement similar disclosures it would endanger her Democracy. What kind of nonsense is that?! The europeans once again are showing their true intent and its disturbing and ugly. But then again over thousand years of entrenched anti semittism can't be undone in 60 years no matter how altruistic they proclaim themselves to be.
69. They are RIGHT!
an Israeli   (01.13.11)
Israel is indeed going through a very dangerous process. The percentage of extremist, rligious right wing population in Israel is on the rise (due to the high birthrate of the right wing religious population), combine that with the fascist soviet style of new immigrant like Liberman - and you get a crazy, non-democratic country. The Israelis whose grand parents built the country cannot believe the dangerous change that's happening in Israel.
70. #47, Israel imports more than it exports to the EU
Danny   (01.13.11)
and I will happily bet the "European diplomats" are from the UK, Ireland, France, Spain and Belgium.
71. european democracies are in danger
Trumpeldor   (01.13.11)
and everybody knows why ....
72. 'European influence in danger'
bunch of ,   megalomaniacs   (01.13.11)
73. #39 how did Europe establish and maintain Israel?
Danny   (01.13.11)
74. to 44 pr
(01.13.11)
the answer is --perfect resiever - but not a perfect donnation .. sir evry one is free to do whatever in his money so corruption is to use public money or to steal or not b honest this is in life but god has its judgment i think hell asks more and more of all of the money owner becouse there are many poors has no food has no medicin but no one aware of these weak groups
75. europe;s hypocricy
benadam ,   Liverpool UK   (01.13.11)
What is it with these so called democrocies anyway, poking thier noses into Israel's affiairs. Tell them pee off is what I say. Europe now is full of socilist governmnets anyway, harbouring all kinds of lies and violent intentions. One peice of the Bible always comes to mind though when I read these intrusive bullies shoutuing thier non-sense. 'those you will meddle in Israel's affairs will be cut to pieces' and also 'Jerusalem will become a brudensome stone to the nations', it seems these to ancient prophecies have come to pass because every country that meddles and bullies Israel falls dramatically into terrible social, economic problems. Take the case of the USA and Obama (bin Laden) he has stopped supporting and gone against Israel. Take a lok at his country now. I know and can see that disaster awaits any nation that attacks Israel. Long Live Israel. God Bless Israel!
76. Democracy
tom dee ,   Savannah ga USA   (01.13.11)
Israel goal is to remove the majority and expel the majority from the nation. It has laws which gives special status to the minority and it abuses those of the wrong religion. One only has to look at how an arab is treating when making formal request for a building permit and how a jew is treated. I do not believe Isreal has ever issued a building permit to an arab. Some Democracy. What the real problem is the world is looking at what is going on and they relize the truth. Call it what you want Israel is not a democracy for all.
77. it is eu democratic future which is in more danger and for
ralph   (01.13.11)
whose future i fear.
78. BS
Norman ,   Florida   (01.13.11)
If European diplomats see somewhere mistrust of their countries, they are right : Israelis have many reasons to distrust them, their financing of hateful leftist anti-Israeli propaganda is just one of them. Don't worry about Israeli democrac y. Worry about the dependency of your own countries on Arab oil, markets, about your fear of Islamist terror . Stop that BS about "worrying for the Israeli democracy. Just say the real truth or shut up.
79. European Diplomats are worried, why hiding something?
Naomi K. Syken ,   Wilmington, DE. USA   (01.13.11)
Why are they so concerned and worried UNLESS they have something they want to hide? Whether it is the LEFT or the RIGHT investigations shouldn't matter if everything is on the up and up and there is nothing that anyone wants to hide-correct..... Maybe they are afraid of exactly what will be found and exposed.
80. To #62.
Steven ,   Rockville, USA   (01.13.11)
The ironic tone of your talk-back indicates that you are a proud citizen of EU. May I remind you that the good citizens of Europe let down Czechoslovakia by allowing the occupation of the country by Hitler. Those that do not learn from history, they will repeat their mistake. That said, when it will be needed, the good citizens of Europe will let down without any hesitation the proud EU citizens of the Czech Republic.
81. Europeans should look at themselves
Martin ,   USA   (01.29.11)
Israel is a very democratic society unlike the European nations who ignore anti semitism in their own countries. Why are they funding some of those anti Israel or any other groups in Israel anyway?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article