News
Egyptian opposition figure: Revise Israel peace treaty
Roee Nahmias
Published: 13.02.11, 22:20
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
71 Talkbacks for this article
61. #4
eli ,   Yerushalayim   (02.14.11)
So if you think, that all our neighbors only want war and not peace, why to hell we shall speak one more word about peace and returning land? But I guess you're right and we should stop the show now. It's only a wasting of time and at the end your people can not accept a nonmuslim neighbor. Oooooopssss!
62. #7 - Withdraw from Territories Occupied in Recent Conflict
Doug ,   Rochester, USA   (02.14.11)
means what it says. There is a simple litmus test. Was the West Bank occupied by the IDF in the recent conflict? Yes, so the IDF must withdraw. Same with E.Jerusalem, same with Golan Heights UNSC 242 also says "the inadmissibility of the acquisition of territory by war". Was the W Bank acquired by war? Yes, so Israeli acquisition is inadmissable.
63. #62
eli ,   Yerushalayim   (02.14.11)
First of all we're speaking about Egypt right now and they got, what they want. (They didn't want Gaza.) ... and did the Jordanian army conquer the so called "west bank" an Jerusalem by war in 1948? Yes.
64. #62 huh?
Israel Israeli ,   Tel Aviv   (02.14.11)
You make no sense. The Jews are the indigenous people of Judea and Samaria and therefore have the right to hold these territories. What relevance does the fact that Israel liberated these territories from an illegal Arab occupation in a defensive war have?
65. You Said indienous people ha?
Sam ,   Hebron, Palestine   (02.14.11)
Dream on buddy, rabbi's victim. we will wait and see who illegel. just watch your back and don't flee.
66. wake up
Megahed ,   Egypt   (02.14.11)
to the ashoole David i see you left commen and you say Return the Sinai first and then we can talk! ... well for me i wanna tell you something the end of world is coming soon ashoole and soon you will not see ur country on earth even on map believe me if i were you i put a shoese on my mouth an not talking Mr rabbit ok..live egypt forever
67. accepted globally
observer   (02.14.11)
Der Spiegel, 5 November 1973: "General Yitzhak Rabin had announced that his country had military plans for all eventualities, including the occupation of the North Pole. But it seems that the sweeping Egyptian onslaught at midday on 6 October had not been included among Israeli 'eventualities'. For this oversight, they paid a heavy price."
68. A deal is a deal
Anadelfos ,   Athens Greece   (02.14.11)
The borders of countries are lines drawn after agreements and the ones who signed them have to honour their signatures. In case they don't,the pandora's box opens and nobody knows what comes out of it. I would suggest our arab friends, to focus on the improvement of their living level, through peace and abandon the animosity with Israel. People of Israel deserve the same rigth to exist and live in peace, as people of Egypt. This nonsense hostility has to stop for ever.
69. #57 NON-OBSERVER
BEN JABO ,   ISR AEL   (02.15.11)
Every Army has contingency plans, some plans work out, and some don’t They’re attempting to think about various possibilities The USA got caught unprepared at Pearl Harbor, Israel paid a heavy price for the Yom Kippur War, Egypt paid an even heavier one; they had to beg the UN for a ceasefire so they could salvage what remained of the army That's the nature of war, but what the hell would you know, all you do is type about things you've never seen or experienced, from behind the safety of your computer The problem that all armies havein common is that don’t have a genius like you doing the planning for them
70. #62 Doug - How convenient
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (02.15.11)
to quote the UN with it suits your point of view and to ignore the fact that those areas were secured because the Arabs, in violation of that UN you love to cite, just happened to have launched their attacks from those very same areas, while totally ignoring that the UN Partition Plan called for two states, a plan that the Arabs rejected when they attacked Israel in 1948, 1956, 1967 & 1973 It's not up to you to tell Israeli to withdraw; firstly you don't have the authority, nor is your home and family in danger of being attacked again
71. No. 31
fredi ,   Carmiel Israel   (05.26.11)
could you be more specific, which treaties is Israel violating, which laws of war it breaks,which human it violates? or perhaps you mean the treaties with Gaza?
Previous talkbacks
Back to article