News
'No Palestine without Jordan Valley'
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 08.03.11, 22:35
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
76 Talkbacks for this article
61. No compromise, no Palestine state.
Jouko ,   Kuopio   (03.09.11)
It is amazing thing; the Palestinians can or never are willing to make compromises. This thing will ensure that they will never get their own state!!! How foolish are the Palestinian leaders! It is a pity for the Palestinian people!
62. Jordan Valley
Sam M   (03.09.11)
Israel should never relinquish control over the Jordan Valley or for that matter Judea and Samaria. Expelling the Jews from their homeland is deeply rooted in the arab/muslim psyche. It's explicitly spelled out in numerous statements which are on the record, and by no means confined to radical islamists. It's the single issue that unites a majority of arabs and muslims with gaza as the obvious template for what will occur. Anyone who advocates such a stupid act is either committed to the destruction of Israel or just 'hard of thinking'. The more Israel concedes the greater the demand will be to surrender more territory with no doubt Israel's borders 'protected' by a motley crew of third rate European or UN troops who will convenient stand aside when the arabs make their move. It's time to tell Fayyad, his fellow palestinian thugs and the 'international community where to go.
63. no 4 Palestinians
TAHRIR QUDS ALYAHUDI   (03.09.11)
You think the world loves you? They love your money,OIL,investments, etc,. We will stand by our selves with the help of our FATHER in HEAVEN.We do not need HUMAN help. IN G D WE TRUST ONLY
64. No to Mickey Mouse : )
Salma ,   Palestine   (03.09.11)
All settelments in the Palestinian Jordan Valley are Illegal. Your Security is not our responsibility. Ynet censorship , you make me hate Wednesday ; (
65. Spell it out! JORDAN IS EASTERN PALESTINE.PERIOD.
Yaawqove ,   Israel   (03.09.11)
66. Ah, the same ol' Britain!
manicdrummer ,   Madison, WI, USA   (03.09.11)
The Britain that tried to stop European Holocaust refugees from reaching Israel. The same Britain that preferred cheap crude oil from the Arabs over the reestablishment of the Jewish state. Hello? Britain? It's called prophecy. The rebirth of Israel is only the beginning. Trust me, ol' chaps, you're not doing yourselves any favors by meddling with a prophecy of The Almighty. You're arm is too short to box with G-d.
67. #25 Jehudah Ben-Israel 242 & 338 NOT DISCUSSED ENOUGH
Ian ,   Newcastle upon Tyne   (03.09.11)
Jehudah Ben-Israel is right to focus on UNSC res.242 and its repeat in 338.As inconvenient as it is for the PLO,these ARE the legal framework towards the end of the conflict. 1)Palestinian Arabs are not mentioned except in the context of a solution to the refugee problem.That encompasses Jewish refugees from Arab countries,too. 2)They state the concept of peace for territory along with the arrangement of secure borders for all states.This clearly implies border changes. 3)The other major point about this is that they can only refer to States that actually existed in 1967 and 1973 and a Palestinian State did not.When they say that there should be withdrawal from territory,in regards to the West Bank,they mean from Jordanian territory.This was only possible because the resolutions were drafted by the UK,the only UNSC member to recognize Jordan's sovereignty by annexation.As Jordan gave up it's spurious claim,the West Bank is now of undetermined status,occupied by Israel. Certainly in Britain,at one time the supporters of an Palestinian Arab State used to shout about 242 and 338 as support for their cause;they trotted them out loud all the time.But that stopped some time ago.I can only suppose that they finally got around to actually reading the resolutions and didn't like what they saw. I think that Israel's supporters should turn the tables and use 242 and 338 as pillars of THEIR case,loud and often. THREE CHEERS FOR ISRAEL!!!
68. "Palestinian" = Syrian/TransJordanian
SF Bay Area Resident ,   SF Bay Area   (03.09.11)
The "Palestinians" were always Jews and Christians along with Zorastrians. Muslims called themselves Syrians/Arabians, Egyptians, etc. Sorry but that is the real historical facts. You've had generations of propaganda that your hero's #1 minister of propaganda would have approved. How many streets are named after Hitler? How many "Palestinians" are named after him. In the 1950s-1960s Hitler was a very popular name for Muslim boys. However, you need to complain to the illegal Hashemite person called Abdullah and declare you want your own country. That is what WAS agreed to by your leaders and the colonial powers that held the land. Israel is REAL - Mah Fish Falestine!
69. To: No. 4
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.10.11)
In answer to your question, it is not "arrogance," but rather self-assurance. The ersatz "Palestinians" couldn't operate a toffee shop, let alone an actual country. So many competing ideologies; so much infighting -- not to mention the not-so-little problem of your so-called "leadership" ripping you off to the tune of billions of dollars. All those fancy second and third homes in Europe; those lavish offshore bank accounts; Abbas' private Gulfstream jet ... if that is representative of your leadership, I find myself wondering how long your stupidity can stand .... On second thought, don't bother answering. We've had nearly a century to marvel at your incredible shortsightedness and intransigence -- we know exactly how stupid you are. We're not likely to forget, either, because you do seem compelled to keep proving it over and over again.
70. To: No. 50
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.10.11)
No, the United States did not supply arms to Israel until following the Six-Day War -- 1971, to be precise. Israel kicked Arab ass in 1967 using French-manufactured aircraft (Mirage, Mystere and Super-Mystere jets). The tanks were ancient vintage World War II Shermans. Now, of course, we manufacture both our own aircraft and our own tanks, so we can kick Arab ass far harder.
71. To: No. 64
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (03.10.11)
No, they are not. Your presence in the Jordan Valley, on the other hand, is quite illegal. SQUATTERS OUT!
72. #64. What do Mickey Mouse and "Palestine" have in common?
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.11.11)
#64 Salma. You say no to Mickey Mouse. That is ironic. Ask yourself this question: What do Mickey Mouse and "Palestine" have in common? Both are fictional and will always be so.
73. Rise up against deadly Two State Final Solution.
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.11.11)
A recent poll shows that 83% of Likud members oppose the deadly Two State Final Solution. Moreover, it is clearly against Likud's Constitution and the will of the vast majority of Israeli voters. Thus Bibi has no mandate to cede even an inch of our land. It is time for all of Patriotic Israel, which is the vast majority of Israel, to rise up against this abomination.
74. NO PROBLEM
JAZZ ,   UK   (04.12.12)
No problem never Isreal only PALESTINE forever
75. trade it for the arab triangle
zionist forever   (04.29.13)
If we do eventually create a palestinians state then lets do a land swap, we keep the Jordan Valley and we trade the arab triangle killing two birds with one stone. We get the strategic Jordan Valley We also create a situation where thousands of Israeli arabs will now find themselves citizens of the palestinian state because of the border changes and once they become palestinian citizens we can take their Israeli citizenship away reducing the countries arab population. As a sweetener we could offer a good will gesture of giving the palestinian stye free of charge the homes of Tibi and Zouabi then we get rid of some of the garbage.
76. Bibi you got some nice ladies at your side but your married
zionist forever   (04.29.13)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article