News
Amos Oz sends book to jailed Barghouti
Zvika Brut
Published: 16.03.11, 15:14
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
72 Talkbacks for this article
1. Bargouti
Nachum Ben Daniel ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (03.16.11)
I hope Oz sent him his new novel... it will bore him to death.
2. Love notes to murderers
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (03.16.11)
There is a certain pathology of people (mostly women) who fall in love with convicted murderers and serial killers and send them love notes in prison. It appears that Amos Oz is one of these types.
3. Shocking!
Gideon Reader ,   USA   (03.16.11)
In what is sure to be roundly condemned by the USA, the UK, the EU, the UN, the Acapellas, the Arab League, the rev.Jerimiah Wright and several (22) frontline confrontation states, and Gideon Levy personally, Amos Oz is providing books (most likely his own) to incarcarated Marwan Boughti. Having tried to read that tepid pap and refusing to suffer it as a replacement for self flagelation, I am SHOCKED that such cruelty is allowed. Oz's books should not even be allowed in GITMO. OK. Maybe GITMO. The horror. The humanity. The, the boredom
4. Amos Oz- Lives in Oz- Haim Oron - Send to Oz
Rich ,   Miami USA   (03.16.11)
Amos Oz, lives in a fantasy land where he writes fantasy. That he is a left winger is no surprise- he never has to deal with reality. For Haim Oron, Meritz MK, he should be sent to Oz- the Oz from the TV Series on HBO. For his support of Barghouti is a rejection of the Israeli legal system- which should not be tolerated by a national leader.
5. Traitor, should be sent to Gaza
hadad ,   U.K london   (03.16.11)
with Gidon Levi and selfl haters.
6. Birds of a feather flock together
Ilan ,   Ariel   (03.16.11)
In the case of Baghrouti and Oz the appropriate bird would be a vulture. In a better world Bagrhouti would be a character of Oz's imagination and desire and not vice versa.
7. what would people say if he dedicated a book to Yigel Amir
zionist forever   (03.16.11)
I would love to know what the reaction would be if Amos Oz wrote a dedication to Yigel Amir in his new book or if Haim Oron went to make regular visits to in jail. I think people would probably be demanding the bookstores not to sell the book and Haim Oron would loose his job as leader of Meretz. You can be in big trouble of you w ant anything to do with an Israeli who murdered a one Israeli but your a hero if your an arab who has murdered five. During his prison time Barghouti has said whilst he has been in jail that while dialogue should be the preferred way of trying to create a palestinian state he has said that armed resistance is legitimate. If this man is a partner for peace why does he see terror as legitimate? If there is any good to come out of this article is we now know to stay well away from anything Amos Oz writes and one more reason not to vote Meretz.
8. oz - the perpetual bullshitter
eddie ,   london UK   (03.16.11)
Before Oslo, Oz was saying it would be easier to break the back of a young palestinian army, than to break the back of a young palestinian stone thrower. So he is now in cahoot with the young tanzim terrorist, who he sees as his partner!
9. The word is "rodef"
sk ,   USA   (03.16.11)
10. oz and self humiliation
alexi   (03.16.11)
oz, burg, olmet, livni all share quarrels with their fathers with them taking positions designed to finally beat their fathers who were builders of the state. And they all uniformly have the blinded peres vision of oslo with rockets and death except they refuse to accept rockets. And olmert who is generally hated in israel did try to educated abbas topeace, sitting, talking, shmoozing over and over again. To no avail, his huge offer was rejected. oz, sternhall, grossman, avineri may be brilliant but all carry the submissive jewish gene who abhors jewish right to defence and places israel in nazi uniforms. witness levy excoriating israel in a dublin speech with PLo flags next to him. Its really had to take. They negate ancient jewish history and make negotiations almost impossible. The palestinians are not a people no matter how many times they say it and the last thing from their minds is setting up a state.,
11. Oz
Michaelpielet ,   Boca, usa   (03.16.11)
Oz should move to gaza where he belongs
12. Many Arabs appreciate Israeli Generals as Generals,
Ali ,   WashingtonDC   (03.16.11)
and for their leadership, even if they're the enemy. Same with Barghouti for some Israelis.
13. hahaha Amos Oz want to be in jail???
ghostq   (03.16.11)
see you soon only means "wait for me" hahaha so much for intelectual. hahahaha
14. Amos
Alex ,   Tel Aviv - Israel   (03.16.11)
You can join him in jail! I don't see any issue for that. Like this, you will have plenty of time to discuss and rebuild the world.
15. The other side
Moshe R ,   New York   (03.16.11)
While I understand the self-defense approach as very intuitive (those that are against you and have done harm to you, kill, and ostracize). But it is proven that the cycle of violence can be stopped at certain times. Violence leads to more violence, and love leads to more love.
16. It makes me sick!
Observer1 ,   Chrangbegbo, Ghana   (03.16.11)
17. The Wizard Called Oz
Sy Dill ,   Providence,RI,USA   (03.16.11)
Amos seems to be living in his own bubble of fiction. He should explain his comments face to face with the relatives and friends of the victims of Bargouti's killings. Where the hell is his moral compass?
18. OZ=Useless idiot
Al   (03.16.11)
19. parteners in Hell
dany Levi ,   London U.K   (03.16.11)
20. oz, would you send him a letter and wish him well if
(03.16.11)
he murdered your family. Have you paid a shiva call to the fogels? do you think their murderer once caught should also be freed? How blind can you be!!!
21. How much Jewish blood should there be on one's hands so as
Jehudah Ben-Israel ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (03.16.11)
to ensure that Oz is convinced that he deals with a mass murderer? How many Jewish children must be murdered so that Oz will realize that Jews also have the very first of all human rights, the right to live? Oz has become a despicable person who, it appears, would do all that he can to receive the Nobel Literary Prize...!!
22. A humanitarian gesture, bravo Amos Oz
Michael ,   California, USA   (03.16.11)
Barghouti is a condemned murderer, but he is a human being. Even people on death row have access to books, information, culture. Prisoners may come to regret what they did after learning of their victims and I am sure Amos Oz's intentions were purely humanitarian. I applaud Amos Oz and think those who hate Amos' gesture are a bizayon.
23. THIS IS A REAL ISRAELI
Ricardo Macher ,   Karnei Shomron IL   (03.16.11)
Oz is a reason of proud for all of us Israelis. A peaceful, talented man that will soon be awarded the Nobel Prize. A decent Israeli that understands the conflict and the reasons for peace. He is the essence of Zionism and all we should thank him for this elegant gesture. Kol ha-Kavod, Oz, you are a real mensh, a person with dignity and love in your heart.
24. What is wrong with the seculars?
Israeli   (03.16.11)
What is happening to the Israeli public? After the mass Russian migration in the past 20 years, the divide between seculars and observant Jews is increasing. I'm seeing more and more Jews vehemently against settlements, boycotts, protests etc. It's sad that Jews cannot have unity.
25. what a retard, let him go sit in jail wiht him also
(03.16.11)
maybe they can hold hands while there....kissy face lefty go live in gaza why dont you
26. Amos Oz , Bravo ! good move : )
Salma ,   Palestine   (03.16.11)
Can I find this book "A Tale of Love and Darkness" in Ramallah Libraries ? I like the title.
27. #3, Gideon, thank you from preventing
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (03.16.11)
me to waste my time on unnecessary books...lol
28. making love to the enemy
eddie ,   london UK   (03.16.11)
this is Oz, who used to criticize the left of making love and not peace with the enemy; now Oz is not only making love to the terrorist, but he is visiting barghouti and is his "punk" in jail.
29. Where will Salma find the book? - #26
Kate ,   London, UK   (03.16.11)
You'll find it sandwiched between the sections on Islamofascism and murdering little children.
30. An evil, depraved action that warrants treason charge.
Chaim ,   Israel   (03.16.11)
There is no limit to the evil depravity of Israeli leftist "intellectuals" like Oz. To make such a gesture to a murderous terrorist, who has the blood of several innocent Jews on his hands, is beyond contemptible. This depraved action warrants treason charges. Israel needs treason laws with teeth and the determination to enforce them vigourously. It is high time betraying Israel carried a high price.
Next talkbacks
Back to article