News
Southern Command chief: Gaza ruled by anarchy
Illana Curiel
Published: 26.03.11, 14:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
39 Talkbacks for this article
1. In order to come to your senses you need a brain!
tom ,   tel aviv   (03.26.11)
2. Cast Lead II will almost certainly unseat Hamas.
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (03.26.11)
3. The Time Is Long Overdue
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (03.26.11)
Major-General Tal Russo just named his own poison. Hamas either has no control over Gaza and can't stop the rocket fire (which I think is hogwash). Or Hamas is responsible for all the rocket fire. Either way it will only stop with another Cast Lead type action. But this time it must be harder. It may be Iran instigating this to take the eyes off their regional chaos. But you can't worry about that. Give them a chance to get the kids, women, and whatever men want leave. Then anybody left is a combatant, of course then Hamas wouldn't have human shields.
4. why would they want to avoid another cast lead?
(03.26.11)
the first one was one of their bast propaganda tools they ever had. it's still effective to this day.
5. Israel does not finish a job
David ,   On this planet   (03.26.11)
They did not finish in Lebanon and did not finish in Gaza. First the PM travels around the world to get permission from world leaders to defend his country and citizens and waist enough time for the enemy to prepare. By the time they are ready to start the whole world is yelling stop the killing. What happened to the to US as a nation since 1967, the good old days
6. Gaza...Ruled by..Hamas and ISRAEL...
Harvey G ,   Chadds Ford, PA   (03.26.11)
Gaza is Israel's TOY... Israel give Hamas boys the FIRE CRAKCERS and they SHOOT on Order..and sometimes when they feel like it... Hamas is the BEST thing going for BiBi..Look at the TIMING of the FIRIING of the latest Slavos.... The WORLD is getting wise..It will be a matter of time..whnenall this gets EXPOSED...
7. Mej. Gen. Russo ,
Salma ,   Palestine   (03.26.11)
Come to your senses in order to prevent second Goldstone Report !
8. Safe rooms and no 100% defence
Alf Red, Londonistan ,   UK-Israel   (03.26.11)
It seems people in Israel came to consider living under missiles as normal life in "PEACE process". And Govt as well. This is horrible! No country in the world would agree to this slow Auschwitz! WHAT IS GOING ON, PEOPLE? Why you allow these pigmys in Govt to treat you like this?! March on Knesset! There IS a 100% defence against missiles - it is called DESTRUCTION of viper nest in Gaza!
9. Generals should shut up and ACT !
(03.26.11)
10. #7
Seth R ,   Boston, MA   (03.26.11)
Salma - you and your fake "palestinian" brothers/sisters have no pride, no honor. why is that? Just kill as many innocent Jewish people as possible and then when retaliation comes you go crying to the UN. Is this cowardice something that is inherited along with your "refugee" status?
11. #6, I hear there's a sell on tinfoil hats...
(03.26.11)
12. #7; Salma, Why, That report meant little
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (03.26.11)
The Goldstone Report was great PR for the Arabs, but as a factual document it was completely discredited. Now of course all the anti-Israel writer's look to it as gospel, but any objective review found it nothing but baseless propaganda. For instance in the report using Palestinian sources (always a mistake) the report stated and I quote: "PCHR divides the overall 1,417 victims into 926 civilians, 255 police and 236 combatants" Yet Here: "Hamas Interior Minister Fathi Hamad's admission that Hamas and affiliated militias lost 600-700 fighters" The source: Hamad's comments were made in an interview published in the London Arabic daily Al Hayat on Nov. 1, 2010 So even the most basic accusations of the Goldstone report (how many combatants 236 were killed) were less than half in the report, which is false (the number of combatants killed were 600-700 according to the Hamas leader (Yet it was ignored). The rest of the report is no better. So Israel is quite comfortable knowing the UN will lie, no matter what action Israel decides to take. In a way, that frees Israel to do whatever is necessary to protect its citizens.
13. #7 Salma
MOI ,   ICI   (03.26.11)
Look around what is going in all the Arab countries where people are demonstrating for freedom and Democracy....and see what the Dictatorial Leaders do, turn against their people, shooting innoncent demonstrators.....so you really think if Hamas is NOT stopping firing rockets on Israel and israel will attack, and blow the shit out of Hamas, there will be another Goldstone report???? hehehehehe keep on dreaming, the world finally understand that ISRAEL IS NOT THE PROBLEM IN THE MIDDLE EAST BUT YOUR EXTREME LEADERSSSSSSSSSSSSSS, SLEEP TIGHT SALMA IF YOU ARE IN GAZA ;)
14. for gaza, anarchy would be an improvement
mike ,   israel (formerly usa   (03.26.11)
is there anyone in their right mind that would not prefer anarchy to hamas' iron-fisted totalitarian version of islamic apartheid? didn't think so.
15. Salma who do you support in Libya and Syria?
(03.26.11)
16. Salma your are the only arab people who live in democracy !
Daniela   (03.26.11)
don't forget it , I'm sure that one day you all will miss Israel and the freedom you had. you are so blind that you don't see that you are spitting on something that your goverments will never give you, THE HOLY FREEDOM !
17. Soon the retrograde Marxists and BDS/ISM zombies
Stephen in New York   (03.26.11)
Soon the retrograde Marxists and BDS/ISM zombies will have plenty to complain about. I don’t say that with enthusiasm –just appears how events seem to be developing.
18. Why is "Salma" so despised on this board?
Peace Lily   (03.26.11)
19. 18
pini   (03.26.11)
Because she says stupid things. Gaza attacks us and we are supposed to sit on our hands?
20. Bombs from Gaza have phospherous in them...
(03.26.11)
they are endangering civilian population and where is the European left? Sound asleep on opium or something! Let's take advantage of it while they are asleep lets just blast back at Gaza! Time for serious use of the Israeli Strike Force!
21. #18 we don't despise Salma...we are very fond of her...
Irit ,   HaGolan   (03.26.11)
she provides us with much needed balance and comic relief! Truly PL you just need more practice at reading between the lines and you'll see that Salma and the rest of us are engaged in a dialogue which will ultimately bring peace to the region!
22. When Russo & Barak get tired of touring
Claudia ,   Tampa USA   (03.26.11)
damaged villages and towns in Israel maybe they will do more than the tit for tat in Gaza that only gives the EU fuel for hand wringing at Israels larger response. Apparently Hamas and Europeans would rather Israel Commando's slip into Gaza and slit the throats of Muslim children and their parents? Damned if you do, etc., go in & blow up everything Hamas ,Israel receives the same bad press and accusations of dis-appropriate response no matter what defense used. 8 years of turning the other cheek didn't work. Giving up Gaza didn't work. Retake it and clean out Hamas. Rockets were not being shot into Israele cities when the IDF was there. I do still have hope for Russo making tough decisions, Barak is a hopeless leftist & even Galant couldn't convince him to clean out Hamas. Somebody has to begin protecting Israeli's, Netanyahu was elected to do just that yet he is just as tentetive as the left to do what has to be done.
23.  Our goal is to let civilians live normal lives,
Ray ,   US   (03.26.11)
Our goal is to let civilians live normal lives, and this is not exactly normal." SHOULD READ Our goal is to let JEWISH civilians live normal lives, and this is not exactly normal." It's very normal for Gaza civilians to be endure land,sea,air blockade Get a clue Moran
24. Russo's take on Gaza surprised me
Cameron ,   USA   (03.26.11)
Hamas has no firm hand over lesser groups, and is that fractured internally? I've seen no true indicators lately that Hamas wasn't firmly in control of Gaza, and that other groups really do nothing without Hamas first giving a wave of approval.
25. All Prisoners must.
Matt ,   UK   (03.26.11)
The people of Gaza must accept their prison fences and walls so that Israelis can live freely and pretend there is peace.
26. #23, 25
Seth R ,   Boston, MA   (03.26.11)
I see you guys have not grasped the concept of cause and effect.
27. Aye, #21
Cameron ,   USA   (03.26.11)
Salma does indeed have purpose in providing cathartic venting for the true Zionist portion of the audience. Your "reading between the lines" is a somewhat more hazy & optimistic approach to YNET talkbacks though.
28. Organized anarchy?
Joe ,   Canada   (03.26.11)
Hamas had no difficulty in decisevely overcoming the well armed & numerous members of Fatah who tried to remain in power in Gaza. Hamas had also no problem in decimating other rival groups such as Jund Ansar Allah in 2009. How come then, there are still small clans in Gaza which are "apparently" able to operate "independanly" from Hamas? One plausible explanation is that Hamas finds it convenient to use them as proxies in the hope it won't be accused of terrorism, avoid Israeli reprisals & do not endanger the flow of foreign subsides. These small groups provide a cover for Hamas the same way as Hezbollah is used by Iran & Syria. Anarchy is not evident in Gaza. Among the Muslim lands of Africa & the Middle-East , Gaza is one of the few where there is no sign of protests even less of violent revolt against the regime. The Hamas is in control.
29. 'Self Hating' Jews are suburban rich Jews.
jane ,   ttl   (03.27.11)
Most countries have bigger walls at their borders, so with subtraction brainwashing of the young and antisemitism must be the reason. Jordan does not let "Palestinians" become citizens. And yes there are power hungry "self hating" Jews who will always be the worst anti-semites. Catholicism or the Roman Church of Judas learned that trick many centuries ago.
30. maleh haaretz hamas
jane ,   ttl   (03.27.11)
Hamas works like an eastern european mafia with front organazations going through the least nuetral on earth Swiss.
Next talkbacks
Back to article