News
Israeli traveler humiliated in Germany, Canada
Boaz Fyler
Published: 31.03.11, 18:41
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
87 Talkbacks for this article
31. please forgive
George ,   Germany   (03.31.11)
Please note, that there are people in Germany loving Israel and her citizens really. And unfortunately there are others, that don't. Hopefully you will meet the German Israel-lovers soon, too. And I apologize for all mistreatment, you endured here in Frankfurt. But it is reality, that media are not friendly to Israel at all. So people with the only misinformation over the media may behave as they are told.
32. #3; Doug, How many planes have...
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (03.31.11)
Jewish terrorists hijacked? Zero! So stop the whining yourself. The fact is here in the USA we should do the same. To my knowledge I've never heard of a 70 year old white woman with gray hair hijacking a plane. I'm all for profiling passengers who fly, again tell me how many Israeli passenger jets have hijacked? Again, Zero! So they must be something right in Israel; to have avoided that all these years? Guess what that is? Profiling. Get a brain and stop whining like a little girlie man.
33. glad to hear
reinhard ,   berlin. deutchland   (03.31.11)
as a german i am glad to hear they scrutinize any jew trying to enter,makes us safer,who knows what mossad will try after merkel spanked bibi. this country is too civilized for jews anyway
34. #6 Re: Canadian Jew
Steve ,   U.K   (03.31.11)
Canada is not "your" beautiful country, "Israel" is.
35. racism
nicole ,   paris , france   (03.31.11)
no doubt , these same countries are accusing Israel of racism ;Mr. Damka we love you and support you ! ;fight to obtain reparation
36. IF your card is a fake
Rahel   (03.31.11)
you are dead wrong- IF your ID is a fake- any country can refuse you entry- Israel is doing exactly the same the Arab and Palestinian travelers. - Make sure this kind of treatment does not happen to you in Israel by your own 'brothers'- .
37. A Canadian's Perspective
Michael ,   Eilat, Israel   (03.31.11)
The officers involved in this case will lie through their teeth and try to discredit the victim. Canada's authorities are notorious for covering each others' butts in these situation and will drag things out through false statements for years, at the expense of the Canadian taxpayers and the victim's dignity. Be thorough, record everything and make a detailed statement of everything that occurred while still fresh in your mind an never give up. Add a couple of million dollars for every year they refuse to come clean with your case, and demand that criminal charges be filed against the officers involved. Do not cut them any break as they will take any advantage they can to destroy your life if they can. I've seen this happen many times in my life growing up in Canada to friends, family, neighbours. Google "Susan Nellis" for one clear example of the systematic abuse of authority common in Canada.
38. Doug , Rochester, USA
Andrew ,   Dubai   (03.31.11)
You say ''Israel Does this to Arab Travelers on a Daily Basis But when a single Israeli Jew gets the same treatment its whine, whine, whine,''. Israeli only treats terrorist suspects in this manner, as does every other country in the world, the US included. Kindly explain on what basis this person was suspected of being a terrorist?
39. Yohannes Damka
Toby ,   South Africa   (03.31.11)
Whether they copensate you or not, if I was in your shoes I will go again to see the falls. I will travel the same route. Shalom
40. good point
horst ,   sw   (03.31.11)
Indeed Germany needs to be on guard. Merkel spanked Bibi so hard it now seems he is in virtual hiding.. only can be interviewed via YouTube
41. I feel sorry for Mr Damka, but...
Mikey ,   SomeWhere OverHere   (03.31.11)
The German customs people who initially had suspicions about him and "warned" the Canadians about him were definitely ignorant and rude, but they were actually working according to legitimate anti-terrorist profiling, at least at the outset. If they had better training, they might have been aware that some Israeli Jews can be black. That seems to be what raised their initial suspicions that he was using a false passport. As Mr Damka himself said, unfortunately not too many Ethiopian Israelis have the financial wherewithal for much leisure travel abroad and the German airport security rarely sees many Ethiopian Israelis, that this excuses the refusal to allow him to contact the Israeli consulate to clear up the matter. As for the "certain criteria" to enter Canada, I wonder if that was a reference to how much funds a foreign traveler has. Canada, like many Western countries (including Israel), is concerned about people staying and working illegally (in addition to terrorism). Therefore, it's common to ask questions about travelers' finances, ask how much is in a bank account,etc. and even to demand proof, and if a traveler can't give satisfactory answers, to deny entry. I'm not saying that this justifies Mr Damka's treatment or refusing to let him call the consulate, but it may explain a lot.
42. Number 33
Yaniv ,   Israel   (03.31.11)
You are a racist b.....
43. Israeli traveler humiliated in Germany, Canada
Blessing Bearer ,   Ulm/Germany   (03.31.11)
Mr. Damka! I do apologize for the bad behavior of that Germans! May Israels God bless you and your future!
44. Germany passport control
aphoto ,   North Carolina USA   (03.31.11)
I have been going to germany since 1999 about 3 times a year from the USA. My passport is U.S. and says Born in Israel. Never once a problem. I am indeed white and kinda look more german that many germans, but still.. And that's in both FRA and MUC
45. Yohannes, I'm sorry this happened to you
Gobbo   (03.31.11)
Canada is very peaceful and tolerant. I'm surprised and saddened that you had such a terrible time trying to visit. Some of the people who work in airport security are sociopathic and definitely not representative of most Canadians, so don't give up hope. After what you went through, you deserve an all-expenses-paid trip anywhere you want to go!
46. No surprise here
world traveler ,   US/Jerusalem   (03.31.11)
I was once heckled in the Lufthansa Business Class Lounge at the airport by "fellow" travelers for wearing a yamaka. I suppose the airport staff also have the maturity of a four-year-old.
47. Proofreading my own comment in #41
Mikey ,   SomeWHere OverHere   (03.31.11)
I dropped the word "not", and it should read : "German airport security rarely sees many Ethiopian Israelis, NOT that this excuses the refusal to allow him to contact the Israeli consulate to clear up the matter. "
48. # 33
aphoto ,   North Carolina USA   (03.31.11)
Reihnard, you should then be very very happy that your country is being over taken completely by the muslims- I wish you the best with that one- just wait, it only gets better and better. Fool
49. 3..That is a LIE.
(03.31.11)
50. Not surprising
Fluffi ,   Germany   (03.31.11)
as most Germans think that every Israeli is Ashkenazim and the average boarder guard most likely doesn't know that there are Israelis of Ethiopian origin. In this case I believe it's a very thin line between racism and legitimate suspicion. However, nobody of course should be humiliated and these incidents happen far too often. Maybe airport interrogations should generally be recorded on film so that passengers have evidence when being mistreated to get compensation.
51. #42, calling a spade a spade
Fluffi ,   Germany   (03.31.11)
He's a RACIST BASTARD! - I agree
52. Wouldn't have happened in the US??
Max Maier ,   Germany   (03.31.11)
I feel sorry for Mr. Damka. If there was really no reason for the authorities to pick on him then he certainly received a very raw deal. He should get an apology and some sort of compensation. He isn't answerable for thuggish behaviour of security at Ben Gurion and thuggish behaviour at one airport doesn't justify thuggish behaviour at a different airport.. There were many reports on travelers being harassed at Ben Gurion airport lately and many talkbackers certainly seemed to be less enraged about that. As to those who claim that this wouldn't happen in the US they are apparently smoking some strong weed.
53. Ze evil Germans, ja?
Lukas ,   Berlin   (03.31.11)
This is a great example of a subjective report presented as fact. Whatever seems to have happened to Mr. Damka must have been for a reason. How many Jews and Israelis do you think fly from Frankfurt every day? How many black people fly into Canada every day? Mr Damka jumps to all kinds of wild conclusions - as regretable as it might be if really there was no reason for his treatment. It was certainly not because he was Jewish and/or black. As for a Frankfurt investigator allegedly shouting "Juden, Juden" I assume Mr Damka himself is the only witness for that. Certainly a great detail to spice up the story though...
54. Israeli security prevents hijacking. What does this do?
Scott ,   USA   (03.31.11)
They could have checked his passport with the embassy, they didn't.
55. #33
k ,   US   (03.31.11)
I only hope there is revenge one day
56. Dear Mr Damka, join me on a trip to Germany and Canada
Roy ,   TLV   (03.31.11)
I must say, I had only good experience in both counties, Canada and Germany. If you have the guts, join me on a trip (I'm frequently going to both countries). I don't know the background why this happened, but lets test it: Drop me an email to "damka.case@gmail.com" and we'll report afterward both back to ynet. If there is any problem, I guaranty you I'll personally kick peoples' a$$. The only thing I can't promise, kicking a$$ for procedures at Ben-Gurion airport.
57. The german policewoman said: "Juden? Ugh!"
(03.31.11)
58. #33 Strange German
(03.31.11)
Strange German you are, when you can't even spell the name if your own country... in your own language.... Are you really a German?
59. Germen will allways be Germen
hadad ,   london u.k   (03.31.11)
60. #33, reinhard...come to Bayerisch Gmain
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (03.31.11)
and you will receive a spanking of your own...
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article