News
Itamar massacre solved; 2 arrested
Hanan Greenberg
Published: 17.04.11, 12:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
88 Talkbacks for this article
61. How many is needed?
Dany ,   Raanana, Israel   (04.17.11)
How many is needed? One? A dosen? A hundred? What number of theie alleged "killed beloved ones", by the logic of your question, would justify what they did? Does such number even exist? If your answer is yes - if you think that there's ANYTHING in the world that can justify the murder of people in their sleep and killing a 4 mounth old baby because she's jewish - than you're not any better than them. I hope you are, though...
62. to#57
Victor ,   Haifa   (04.17.11)
Gunshots (gun-shot) also mean "chaotic, irregular, etc...."
63. #58; seadog, Has It Backwards, Again
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (04.17.11)
First where did I ever use the word "outrage"? I certainly don't need someone as foolish as you to define me. I simply call it as I see it but I do perfer people not put words in my mouth, I can speak for myself. I suppose the "outrage" is yours. Second, your self description as an "Amurkin", is one thing we do agree on, although you don't fulfill all qualifications. Third I noticed you love the term "Hasbara", by the context of your usage, I take it, you mean that what is said is false, or propaganda. Yet you provide no proof of that, typical of the anti-Israel writer. It's the one word response to stifle legitimate debate. When you don't have any counter argument, then people do as you just did. Move on to the personal attack, and cheap attempts to stifle debate, but as usual, without any proof. Proof of this is simple, you changed the debate, didn't you. Now we moved from the silly Ghetto and bar room brawls as comparisons, to alleged War Crimes by the USA. Save the back pedaling, you lost.
64. Hatred
mihaelpielet ,   Boca,usa   (04.17.11)
These vicious murderers have no remorse, because like the German nazi's and their collaborators the murder of Jews including little children is a meritorious goal.
65. Step 2
Pedro ,   Brazil   (04.17.11)
Now is time to close them in prision and give education, phone calls, Islam study, health care, and some fun to spend in their free 24 hour routine they will have until the next prisioner exchange..
66. #63 - Georgia cracker...
seadog1946 ,   ArthurKill, NJ   (04.17.11)
instead of being either a rootless-cosmopolitan/economic-migrant lurking in Georgia, you should make aliya. You sir, are obviously either a paid or self-appointed Israeli propogandist. Go home.
67. #26 - Actions speak louder than Words
Hinda ,   SF Bay Area   (04.17.11)
Why have Arab countries kicked out these "A-Rabs?" They have no soul, no love, nothing - they are raised in hate. They had a future if they wanted it but had refused it. MAH FISH FALESTINE!!!!
68. #57 Muslim Love - Non-Existent
Hinda ,   SF Bay Area   (04.17.11)
Interesting that GAZA has to feed Egypt via the tunnels as GAZA is poor and starving. Another lie. Who's using the propaganda machine? How's it going in Egypt - unemployment is huge, stores are empty, etc. unless you are related to the Muslim Brotherhood - then you may eat. Like in GAZA. What size is your bomb belt?
69. To#35
Fabio ,   Argentina   (04.17.11)
I agree with jorge, and remeber the 50% of spaniards blodd is JEW!!!
70. they'll be out in 5 years
david ,   new york   (04.17.11)
just like that other murder that was just released to lebanon (and got a hero's welcome)
71. Reality check
P   (04.17.11)
They will have 3 meals a day and live the rest lives in comfort of prison....or until they are swaped(like that guy in Lebanon) or released under a new peace deal.
72. #66; seadog, THANKS, PROOF POSITIVE
Mark from Georgia ,   USA   (04.17.11)
As we can see, seadog cannot handle a legitimate debate, as he devolves deeper into the personal attack. Proof Positive of the emptiness of his false arguments. Calm down seadog, there are medications you can take to settle down, and looks like you need them, quickly.
73. Palestinians
william ,   Canada   (04.17.11)
patience is a good thing,now its time for Arab Nomads calling themselves Palestinians to leave.//
74. To #40 Lina
Adva ,   IL   (04.17.11)
Peace cannot be made with these savages!
75. RELEASE THESE 2 PALESTINIANS AT ONCE!!!!!
Joe   (04.17.11)
ISRAEL RELEASE THESE 2 PALESTINIANS AT ONCE!!! STOP WASTING THE STATES MONEY, STOP WASTING ISRAELI TAX PAYERS DOLLARS, STOP RISKING OUR SOLDIERS LIVES IN CARRYING OUT OPERATIONS SUCH AS THESE TO ARREST THESE PEOPLE!!!! DUE TO THE FACT THAT NOW OUR SOLDIERS AND CITIZENS WILL BE KIDNAPPED AND THE TERRORISTS WILL DEMAND THAT THESE TWO PALESTINIANS WILL BE RELEASED, AND THEY 'WILL' BE RELEASED AS EASY AS 1, 2, 3, IF, HAMAS HASNT ALREADY ADDED THEM 'TODAY' TO THEIR PRISONER-LIST IN EXCHANGE FOR SHALIT!!!! SO STOP ARRESTING PEOPLE UNTIL U INSTALL A DEATH PENALTY SYSTEM!!!!
76. Yet again, solid proof that the like of Ma'an news are liars
Faruq   (04.17.11)
77. #72 - The IDF recruiter will meet you at
seadog1946 ,   ArthurKill, NY   (04.17.11)
the Ben Gurion aerodrome and speed you through the enlistment process. I'm sure that you'll more than enjoy West Bank checkpoint duty... at the end of your tour, you can even claim to be an IDF combat "vet".
78. Who are the Cowboys and Indians in this thing, eh?
Chris ,   Dallas, USA   (04.17.11)
Many folks of both Jewish and Arab descent have reminded us Americans of the realities of the "Indian Wars" in our own nation, from the Pilgrims to Wounded Knee to Willie Boy to the American Indian Movement and so on. There could be stories of cruelty, barbarism, collective punishment, reservations, corruption, etc. that could curl a normal person's hair. There were very tough creatures on all sides of the conflicts. And, yes, America had Manifest Destiny with God on our side writ large. It still goes on today, even under Obama. The Holy Land is in many ways a microcosm of all that, and in some ways more complex on various levels. Who are the Cowboys and Indians in this modern era in the Middle East and how do you resolve all the hostilities? There is no way anyone of sound mind can condone the behavior of these young men. They remind us all of the monstrousness of humans throughout history. They show us all that even in our modern era we have the capacity for unspeakable evil. Still, collective punishment can breed more of this insanity. May you all find your way through the darkness.
79. Sympathising with frustration is one thing. But sympathise
with murder?!   (04.17.11)
80. Peace should start with education!!!
Amir ,   Israel   (04.17.11)
Read comment number 13 please. How can you make peace with those who rase little children for hate and murder? The first thing to do, before start dealing with Palestinians about peace is "Stop educating your children to hate jews and to admire killers or there will be no talks and all. Go to Israeli schools and you will find pictures of doves with olive leaves. Go to Palestinian school and you will find pictures of guns and "Shahaids" .You cannot make peace with a nation who rase their new generation for an endless circle of hate and violance until they will change their attitude.
81. #72 - debate???
seadog1946 ,   ArthurKill, NY   (04.17.11)
You sir, do not engage in debate... you sit safely in the USA and solemnly explain/justify the actions and minimize the greed of a foreign country. You engage in disseminating Israeli hasbara and propoganda.
82. Funny, they Don't Look Thai
Thomas ,   US   (04.17.11)
I guess that was another Arab lie.
83. The best answer to these terrorists :
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv/israel   (04.17.11)
Build Itamar to a full fledged city !
84. What kind of society spawns teens who slit a baby's throat?
Serge ,   Montreal, Canada   (04.18.11)
There is a very deep problem here. Palestinians had better stop wallowing in the blame game, and start addressing it.
85. #34 ARE YOU INSANE???!!!
Jewish Warrior   (04.18.11)
Israel has certain red lines that it will absolutely not cross during prisoner exchanges. It is willing to give up small fish and a few big fish based on the severety of their actions, but not cases like this. As Prime Minister Netanyahu says: "Israel is willing to pay a heavy price, but not any price", for Shalit's freedom.
86. @#37
Sarah ,   California, USA   (04.18.11)
Thank you. Speaking for Israel, we appreciate when people are able to open their eyes and look beyond the media.
87. New Strategy
Demo Demetrius ,   Canada   (04.18.11)
Set an example and carpet bomb Awarta. Israel is damn if they do, damn if they don't. Obama, the UN and most of Europe constantly undermine Israeli security,so it's time to stand up for your own survival.
88. what should israel do with these thugs
Mark ,   usa   (04.19.11)
They should be tried and then released to gaza, where two more terrorists will not change the balance of evil hate mongers. However fully document the stark contrast of their acts to the warm welcome hamas affords them, now that is fighting the propaganda and everytime hamas opens its mouth, rerun the heroes welcome and shame them with it. Two more islamist sitting jail, siliently stewing for their crimes brings no justice, if anything they become posterboys for islamist. Sending them to gaza can make them pay for their terror actions when every time hamas has something to say, the back story is a replay of hamas welcoming convicted terrorist with warm arms. Ok, its not the real world, so send them to saudi arabia with the full dockit of their trail and conviction and ask for islamic justice. Put the onus on islam to carry out justice, let the world see it for what it is, finally a responce to the true meaning of double crossed swords, kinda reverses the get ya coming both ways. Either the islamic courts have to up hold islamic justice or reveal their hypocrisy.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article