News
'Quartet may recognize Palestinian state'
Ynet
Published: 19.04.11, 09:56
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
120 Talkbacks for this article
31. injustice cannot be imposed on israel
jason ,   israel   (04.19.11)
let it be stated loud and clear: 4 wars lost by the arabs attacking the emerging jewish state, wars to the teeth, to hope for its destruction, led to lost territory by the arab states. territory including judea and samaria, the heart of historical, biblical israel and the land that today hundreds of thousands of citizens call their homes. we should never accept a 23rd(!) arab state imposed on the small Land of ours and one that negates the rights of jews to live in their own land, according to stated open objectives of the PA!!!! it is a major injustice in line with the historical injustices jews have faced throughout history. NEVER AGAIN. arabs who live as a minority in the jewish state have more rights and higher standard of living than just about anywhere in the world, they know it and the world will soon know it and accept it whether they like it or not.
32. calm down...
seadog1946 ,   ArthurKill, NJ   (04.19.11)
"Secretary of State Hillary Clinton hinted last week that the international community may apply pressure on both sides..." the keyword in the above quote is... may
33. They want to create more war in the name of peace
Frank ,   Canada   (04.19.11)
What a bunch of hypocrite. The root cause of this war is not related to borders.
34. #13, when was israel "forced"
Danny   (04.19.11)
and when did "Palestine" exist?
35. Don't hit the panic button
Rachel ,   US   (04.19.11)
Listen to me! The 2012 election campaign has already started. Obama not to mention Congress is going to allow an unilateral Palestinian state.
36. #24, by "nations" you mean the dictator-dominated UN?
Danny   (04.19.11)
I fail to see how you cannot be proud of the fact that people like Burma, North Korea, Sudan, Iran and Syria have an issue with Israel and her approach to human rights.
37. The "Quartet" can recognize...
Eli F. ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (04.19.11)
Disneyland, Oz, Graceland and the Magic Kingdom, but that DOESNT make it a reality!!! THEY should move to Fantasy Island!!
38. Only Israel is ALWAYS Pressured
Marcel ,   Florida   (04.19.11)
I wonder how much more abuse Israel will take before they stop playing the part of the doormat of the world ? The game has always been rigged against the Jews and they did not have the sense to quit playing it long ago. They even re-elected a serial lap dog who revealed his loyalties long ago by gifting Hebron to the Cliphate jihadists in the late 90's.
39. If they do, they will be responsible for the last world war
EST ,   Miami USA   (04.19.11)
40. Understanding the LA Times
Ron ,   OC, US   (04.19.11)
The newspaper itself is all but a failed business. Thatb being said, Israel can not nor will go back to 1967 borders, and what about Gaza. They are a hamas state not a PA state. Israel isn't going to take in so called refugees from 1948. I am as interested in the Quartet peace plan as much as the Israeli plan. The PA doesn't live in raelity.
41. Where is Sarah??
Muayyad ,   Palestine   (04.19.11)
I miss her retarded comments. I guess the 'ersatz' Palestinians have out-witted her and stripped her of all credibility. Not that she had any, she is a bitter hateful women.
42. #36 Danny
Michael ,   Haifa   (04.19.11)
My reference was to the nations of the Quartet and not to the countries you mentioned...It was my fault for not having expressed myself more clearly
43. they can call the land whatever they want
meir kohan ,   eastJerusalem Israel   (04.19.11)
all that matters in the reality on the ground... who controls the land controls the reality... thank hashem its us beni mikra
44. Injustice cannot be imposed....
Jones ,   Bahrain   (04.19.11)
#31: Injustice cannot be imposed on the Jews as it is by the Jews on the Palestinians. I believe that is what you wanted to say.
45. Muayyad 41
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast., USA   (04.19.11)
I miss her too. The Palestinian hasn't been born that could impeach her credibility. Compared to her they all look "retarded" (your choice of words).
46. to #41 - you can say that again
Mike ,   Minneapolis, USA   (04.19.11)
When all you have is hate, you may as well hang it up. The killing will never end.
47. Let them recognize it. Israel never will.
USA   (04.19.11)
Recognizing a Palestinian state on paper, does not make it a state. As to the quartet, UN or whoever let them recognize it. If a terror state must come into being, let them force it into being and pay the price for it, not Israel. If they want to drink from Jerusalem's cup of poison and fill themsleves, let them drink and pass out from it.
48. George Soros Gang
William Sachel ,   USA   (04.19.11)
I see the Anti Israel George Soros Gang is back on the talkbacks or maybe it;s the EU and US government contractors
49. Time for Israeli Deterrance
John Cone ,   USA   (04.19.11)
Time for Israel to start threatening the Quartet with consequences such as annexing Area C and B . Israel needs to create and make public a policy of Mutual Assured Destruction against any country that threatens her economic or physical existence as a Jewish state just as the US did against the Russians in the Cold War. It worked then it can work now.
50. Blah blah- cheap talk: US Congress and
John ,   US   (04.19.11)
Pres Obama have already firmly declared US will not accept pal state unless the parties negotiate terms. The UN does not create a nation; it only accepts members. UN Gen Assembly did NOT create Israel. Israel created itself and other nations recognized that fact. EU will not resolve the issues; it flounders in Libya without US.Pals deluded they can do nothing and get a state even as hamas & Fatah battle each other.
51. Quartet AntiSemites/Crusaders
Brod ,   USA   (04.19.11)
The AntiSemites Quartet is ganging up as AntiSemite Crusaders. Judeo-Christian America opposes the Quartent AntiSemites. Israel should get Congress and Judeo-Christian America to say NO to the dark forces. What they are doing is pushing for a major War in the region. Peace cannot be imposed by external forces. Their fictional 1967 crap cannot be pushed into Israel's throat. Israel liberated its historic homeland of Judea and Samaria from the belligerents and aggressors-Arab Islamist-Jihadists in the War of 1967. Israel must defend and protect its liberated homeland from the Quartet Crusaders-AntiSemites and Islamist-Jihadists belligerents, aggressors and usurpers. Israel should tell the Quartet to go to Hell. The first thing for Israel to do is to kick Tony Blair-Papist AntiSemite out of Jerusalem that is fomenting the dark forces to undermine Israel.
52. To # 38 Marcel
Rachel ,   US   (04.19.11)
Unfortunately, Bibi is yellow. If Yaalon were in charge I would be a lot more confident. But I fear Bibi's capitulation more than the Quartet.
53. #41, You are not worthy of her attention...
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (04.19.11)
Mr. Ersatz Palestinian...
54. Quartet Stupitity
Ralph Levy ,   USA   (04.19.11)
First International Law said Israel had a right to the West Bank and Israel next International Law was changed to allow Israel to have secure and recognize borders then International Law was changed again so Israel can only have the 1967 borders what next no Israel. International Law is a Joke Fight Back against the Quartet No More Concessions.
55. Jewish Settlements are legal
Ralph Levy ,   USA   (04.19.11)
Any predetermination by a outside power of the situation on Israel and the West Bank is illegal by international law. Eugene Rostow Under Secretary of state author of UN resolution 242 wrote in 1991 that Israel and Jews had a right to settle the West Bank, and that the British Mandate cannot be rescended. He also said that Israel was not required to go back to the 67 borders.
56. Recognition
max ,   washington dc   (04.19.11)
The Quartet would do better to promote real negotiations since the US will not endorse a unilaterally declared palestininian state. Abbas wants the Quarteet to endorse his demands which will never happen since Israel would most likely unilaterally annex Judea and Samaria.
57. If they do it will be on instructions of Obama
David Turner ,   Richmond, USA   (04.19.11)
58. The Quartet may recognize a PA state
GLENN ,   YUCAIPA,USA   (04.19.11)
it has been jewish land since Avraham and King David.NO PA STATE!!!
59. Israel (supposedly Palestine)
Missy   (04.19.11)
All I can say to that is: Bibi had better be very sure.... 1000% positive before he hands over G-d's land to those arab murderers. Take my Word for it, there's a terrible end coming to those arabs and that includes the many, many of them sitting in Israeli prisons. They will be lucky and so will Bibi if they ever again see the light of day. CAREFUL bibi what decision you may make. It will make or break you!
60. Suicide
mike caton ,   USA   (04.19.11)
The Wes and Obama are in fact asking Israel to commit suicide by accepting the 1967 borders. With such a border, the main runways at Ben-Gurion airport would be only approx 6 miles away from the militarized Pal state , and the main population centers of Tel-. _Aviv and suburbs, only 12 to 15 miles away,all within east reach of even rudimentary rockets, not to speak of more advanced rockets supplled by Iran . This would cripple the Jewish state.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article