News
'Heinous act against Jewish worshipers'
Attila Somfalvi
Published: 24.04.11, 21:12
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
88 Talkbacks for this article
31. another cowardly act by the PA mongrels
GLENN ,   YUCAIPA,USA   (04.25.11)
the settlers have rights to roam free and worship anywhere on their native land in sameria,judea,west bank,or the whole land of israel.israel has been jewish soil since the time of abraham and king david
32. what sane governemnt put Jewish lives in Arab hands?!
all arabs terrorists   (04.25.11)
33. #9 looking at things the wrong way is dangerous
justifying evil?   (04.25.11)
these policemen new that as alwasy these peaceful people wanted to pray. it is people like you who through supporting and justifying every criminal acts that Arabs and Palestinians and Moslems do endanger the world. Arabs are killing each other everywhere in the world becuase they only belive in getting what they belive is theirs through violence. They believe (believe) Israel belongs to them, therefore they think is is ok to murder Jews. They belives for the last 1400 years that Jews and other people were aminals like pigs and monkeys and desreve to be killed. its why they killed many non-Moslems and enslaved so many blacks that even today are considered as slaves in different arab countries. Arabs in Libya who support Libyan Ghazafi belvieve He has the right to kill 6000 people just in a few days in order to stay in power and these Arabs help him kill 6000 people. Arabs who are against Ghazafi also belive the same and will start killing theier opponents as soon as they take over the country. all over Arab world groups of Fascist Moslem Arabs are rising against the ruling group of Fascist Arab Moslems and in this fight Leftists in Europe and U.S are siding with the one which is not in power, supporting them to take over their countries and get their fair share in ruliing with dictatorship over the other groups! I wish people like you as the rest of the world would just call evil what it is instead of justifying it. Maybe if you had to live in an Arab neighborhood and having to deal with a sick murderus backward culture you would not justify such evil
34. If Palestinians had pulled up road block and refused to stop
Leon   (04.25.11)
Then the IDF would have blown them All away and let not one escape being killed. Bibi and Barak would have lauded the vigilant IDF and given comendations - you know this is true and if you are an Israeli Jew you probably think that this is just how it should be - am I wrong?
35. to#1 THe difference wirth yr examnple is that the Hassidim..
Ari ,   Romania-Israel   (04.25.11)
were not armed thay just came to pray. In yr example the palestinians would have comed armed. Breslave Hasidim were well known to the PA police because they are allways arround. It's a lie they were throwing stones to the Police. What would you say if everytime those youngster in the Silvan neighborhood throw stones the Jewish police men would shoot them with live amunition? In that case the Jewish policemen will be murders and the whole world will be hollowring. But because its a jew then it's justified the shooting for traspassing right.? You cant hide your antisemitism and hate. Besides Hassidim are not Settlers they are ultraorthodox Jewish Groups that go to pray to wholy sites like the Tomb of Joseph, The Cave of the Machpela,the Western Wall, Rachel's tomb etc
36. #3 A suspicious car will be asked to stop for inspection
Ari ,   Romania-Israel   (04.25.11)
The wouldn't shoot first and ask second.
37. 11. Yr mouth is like a gutter. You cant sit in Brooklyn
Ari ,   Rumania-Israel   (04.25.11)
and critisize the PM. What you want to enter Nablus and start a spary of bullets. You are frankly retarded. We are not in the Wild West amazing as it is even in these cases there is a rule of law
38. Possessed?
Robert ,   Brisbane Australia   (04.25.11)
"He looks demon-posessed in that picture!" That's because he is.
39. to#9
Jennie ,   ISrael/US   (04.25.11)
You talking about coordination of actions as if we are dealing with a people or a nation, with whom we have a normal relationship. Coordianation of actions? Are you kidding ? When did Israel coordinate any actions with their sworn enemies ? Those boys were armed with their prayer books and tfilins...And I am sure, we don't know all the details: permit or not..But they didn't need to be shot by lethal bullets ! That is unforgivable. And what is frightening the most, is the posts of Israelis and Jews, that justifying the point blank attempt to murder our boys...Shame on You and all other defenders of pali police...
40. Where is the Irgun when you need it?
sk ,   USA   (04.25.11)
41. No, you moron
Mike caton ,   USA   (04.25.11)
No , Netanyahu, you moron, kowtower to Obama and the UN. It is NOT the Pals who must react with a "heavy hand",'it is the IDF that must react with a heavy hand. When will you ever understand, imbecile, coward Netanyahu?
42. To the moron Netanyahu
Mike caton ,   USA   (04.25.11)
And one more thing,Coward Netanyahu, kowtower to Obama: "He who is kind to the cruel, is cruel to the kind."
43. Thats it Bibi? What if it was your son?
BJL ,   usa   (04.25.11)
Your bible scholar son probably would like to go there. What if G-d forbid it was him that was killed? Would you just urge the PA to deal with it? The PA is supposed to make ALL Jewish sites available. They dont.
44. Sarah
Sonya   (04.25.11)
I do not know where in Israel you live if at all, but you should ask Arab permission to use bus station in Jerusalem, leave alone the bus itself. Without permission it is too dangerous as poor Christian woman murdered by Arab bomb at the bus stop found out recently. Of course, according to anti-Semites and Jewish leftist-idiots, she deserved it. Or are only Jews deserve to be murdered? Right now more Christians are murdered by Muslims all over the world. Probably they simply running out of Jews to murder.
45. PA can murder Jews over 3 months old.
BBub ,   USA usa   (04.25.11)
Yep, as they Jewish family slept the entire family was killed by the religion of peace. They SLICED AN INFANTS THROAT. But the PA didn't mean anything by it. Just a misunderstanding, so forget about it.
46. Bibi asks P.A. terrorists to punish fellow terrorists!
Chaim ,   Israel   (04.25.11)
Bibi asking P.A. terrorists to punish their fellow terrorists for murdering Jews is the height of absurdity. Murdering Jews is what the P.A. is all about. That's what P.A. TV glorifies every single day. It's what P.A. media and schools glorify every single day. I can't believe Bibi is that dumb. The only motive he could possibly have for this absurd request is to justify pretending the P.A. are peace partners. And not the blood thirsty Jew hating terrorists they really are. Disgusting!!!!
47. #18. Exactly. Judea and Samaria must be completely liberated
Chaim ,   Israel   (04.25.11)
#18. It is absurd to allow genocidal enemies of Jews to frreely target Jews in our sole tiny Homeland. The terrorists are able to operate freely because of the lunatic concessions Bibi and other criminally negligent politicians made, to our enemies, in aid of the phony "peace process". Judea and Samaria belong to Israel by every right. We must liberate them completely.
48. Yes - hypocritical
J Brenner ,   Seattle, US   (04.25.11)
No secret - the Israeli police shooting and killing unarmed Palestinians for decades. Now one of their own has been killed, watch the retaliation times ten.
49. His life ended for praying at one of our holiest sites
Sue ,   Los Angeles   (04.25.11)
Livnat was killed simply for being a Jew who prayed at one of Judaism's most holy sites during Passover. It would not have happened if the Palestinian Muslims did not restrict Jews' access to Joseph's Tomb. Remember Livnat and his young children the next time there is a demand for the Jews to "share" Jerusalem, our holy city, with the Muslims. Livnat and his fellow Breslovers (a sect that dances in the streets and spreads joy to passersby) had finished praying and were driving back home when they were shot at. This young father was no threat to anyone.
50. Pathetic propaganda...
Me   (04.25.11)
What a ridiculous propaganda: the worshipers in question where there without any authorization and REFUSED TO STOP when asked by the Palestinian security officer: they were fired upon because of their sole behavior. Cry me a river and repeat your litany of dishonest propaganda Bibi, call it a "terrorist act" if that can please your ignorant minions, then the next time Israeli security shot a Palestinian at a border crossing we will call it a terrorist attack too. Pathetic.
51. The facts
Me   (04.25.11)
"Preliminary reports suggest that Palestinian security officials fired warning shots in an attempt to stop the car after observing what they called "suspicious activity." They said the group — including about 15 people in three cars — ignored calls to stop and tried to evade roadblocks. According to some Palestinian reports, the settlers were armed." (source: latimes) Shot because of their own behavior, again : cry us a river BIbi.
52. Double standards
Christian ,   Sweden   (04.25.11)
Not without reason Israel complains about being judged by double standards in the international political scene. But in this case it looks like you practice it yourselves. According to the Jerusalem Post the visitors to Joseph's tomb stoned the Palestinian police and tried to force a road block manned by PA police in a Palestinian security area. If that is the case the shrill pitch in most takbacks here is astonishing to say the least.
53. Israeli Terrorist killed at PA Checkpoint
Max   (04.25.11)
What's the problem with the Israelis? The IDF murders Palestinian civilians on a routine basis, whether they're innocent farmers, fishermen or whatever. But when an Israeli religious fundamentalist is gunned down while trying to run a PA checkpoint, then that's terrorism - Israeli hypocrisy at its best.
54. 3. Put a sock in it, Bibi Johnboy (04.24.11)
Daniel ,   USA   (04.25.11)
Bibi ROCKS! Good work Bibi...Hang the Palestinian perpetrators!
55. Above the Law ?
jo   (04.25.11)
Plenty of stupid Jews who think that think that they can do as they please when tragedy strikes, accusing everybody else. All they had to do was to notify the authorities. They obviously chose to confide in hashem and the hell with the IDF. There is a price to be paid for disturbing hashem.---- Next phase, heinous act ? Bull sh...t rhetorics as usual.
56. #53 Max
solomon ,   bklyn   (04.25.11)
"The IDF murders Palestinian civilians on a routine basis, whether they're innocent farmers, fishermen or whatever." Congratulations! This is one of This Month's Most Ridiculous Statements. Just because you want something to be so, does not make it so. Maybe you have some proof? No? I didn't think so.
57. They Also Disrespect the Palestinians (Philistines)
Nicole Czarnecki ,   B'HaGalut   (04.25.11)
Stereotyping the Philistines, not giving them Philista (Pleshet) in Yehuda as a district within Medinat Yisra'el as it was in Ha'Yamim Yehoshua ben Nun, and taking Yossi Harel's lead instead of remembering how good Avimelekh was to Yitzchak and that we are no better than the goyim (cf. D'varim 7:7-9, 9:4-21) started this whole mess.
58. #43 - good question: why does bibis son not go there...
eporue ,   europe   (04.25.11)
(without permit, armed, and ignoring warning shots and trying to break roadblocks...) lol...
59. If Joseph's Tomb isn't defensible, make it defensible!
Scott ,   USA   (04.25.11)
Clear a few hundred meters around the place. Put up a new building over the tomb, say twenty stories high, and made out of concrete and steel. Let them burn that one down. And give the bill to the PA for failing to live up to their promises.
60. # 53
Birdi ,   Israel   (04.25.11)
'The IDF murders Palestinian civilians on a routine basis..." LOL, you are sprouting pure garbage. In actual fact, your talkback is slanderous. Either get your facts straight or dont bother to post here, as you are making a fool of yourself with your fabrications.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article