News
Israel suspends tax transfer to PA
Elior Levy
Published: 01.05.11, 13:59
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
64 Talkbacks for this article
31. So the Palestinians dont want Israel to "meddle"
Jewish Warrior   (05.01.11)
I think they should have made that clear when Israel was giving them billions in the first place. Besides, how is withholding your own money "meddling"?
32. # 29 it's our money ...
NadMan ,   Palestine   (05.01.11)
it's revenues from taxes israel collect on the products come to palestine, and israel have to transfer them to the palestinian authorities. ^^
33. #1 - actually, didn't Hamas CANCEL Oslo accords
William ,   Israel   (05.01.11)
and all other agreements with Israel when they took power in 2007?
34. #4 - there was a time when Hamas-Fatah was not split
William ,   Israel   (05.01.11)
and your ilk were still violent, still broke agreements you made, and still targeted innocent civilians in an effort to destroy Israel. The "Palestinian" govt tomorrow and yesterday are exactly the same - only the names have changed. By the way, it was Israel and many other donors who left you with a working entity (Gaza) with an economy set to take off, with built-in industrial zones and an advanced greenhouse with a built-in customer base. You destroyed it all!!! Had you taken this opportunity and showed the world how successful you are by yourselves: 1) you'd already have a State, and 2) there'd be no need for the majority of "Palestinians" to be State employees which is essentially a bribe for loyalty - seen in every other despotic Arab regime. Tell Hamas to stop making war with Israel and go build a factory. Both sides would benefit.
35. Way past due
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (05.01.11)
We should not suspend transfer, but add the money to the Defense budget since these terrorist attacks cost us so much to stop. Next US Congress must end their funding. Then we must stop employing anybody in the PA. That will take away 90% of the terrorist income. Then we can get nasty, like closing Gaza from our side of everything. Let Egypt supply it.
36. #15 - Intl Law says Pallys shouldn't even have a State
William ,   Israel   (05.01.11)
Under Intl Law, the case for Israel's claim on Gaza and WB are very strong, mostly based on land ownership, past Intl declarations awarding the land to Jews, and the subsequent illegal annexation the land by Arabs, ethnic cleansing of Jews, and flooding it with Arab immigrants between 1949-1967 - all violations of the Geneva Convention. Under Intl Law, "Palestinians" are not refugees past the current generation of the conflict - that drops your numbers from 5mm to only 500,000. Under Intl Law, neither the West Bank or Gaza are occupied. What you claim as "Intl Law" is really just the musings of the Court of Public Opinion - long on rhetoric, short on facts.
37. #20 - Terrorists and Leftists have the same MO
William ,   Israel   (05.01.11)
Cite Intl Law when its in their favor, ignore it when it's not.
38. #22 - You're in the ME...a non-political govt??
William ,   Israel   (05.01.11)
Stop being so naive. You're part of the "Palestinians" - you've seen the chaos and corruption that decades of PLO, PA, Fatah, Hamas rule have brought you, but you still believe they are honest? Right now - you have no govt, you're not even a legitimate State or people, and under the agreement, your side broke Oslo many times which means its dead. Not to mention, Hamas, whom you say won't affect the govt, has already stated they demand the annulment of agreements with Israel and refuse to accept a 2-State solution - also a cancellation of Oslo. So, right now - "Palestine" is only in your dreams, which seem to include the destruction of a sovereign State and genocide or expulsion of 6 million people to get there. Get rid of the fantasy, and you might have a chance in the future to be sovereign.
39. Too soon for this move, plays wells in Israel, not worldwide
Bloodyscot ,   Dallas, Texas   (05.01.11)
The timing of this was very bad but will be very popular move inside Israel. Israel should have waited at least until after the signing of the agreement, instead of using it to try and stop the signing. Hamas' charter will soon be no more since they will be under a newly modified PLO charter that will be carefully worded.
40. You will leave
E.D MHD ,   Gaza   (05.01.11)
At the end you will leave and we will stay it is a fact , and it is the begining of your end .
41. This proves one thing
Joseph   (05.01.11)
Israel has no right to use tax collections that rightfully belong to the Palestinians as a weapon. It just proves one thing, Israel cannot be relied upon and any future Palestinian State must not include any dependence on Israel for anything. It must have complete and total independence.
42. We will leave?
Howard Immanuelson ,   US   (05.01.11)
Haha -- Jews have a history on this land dating back thousands of years before the first Muslim walked the earth. If you want to play a waiting game you're hugely outclassed.
43. #32 Game Change
Cynthia ,   USA   (05.01.11)
Israel is withholding the funds because "palestinian authorities" are part of a terrorist organization. The US is also planning to drop your funding and the EU and UN must also follow suit. The tax money is from work performed by Palestinians in Israel, The laborers were paid but the tax money funds PA jobs. This is what brought Erekat out of his chair.
44. Missiles fired by Hamas/PA against israeli children
Marcelo ,   World   (05.01.11)
After this unity, palestinian authority will be the ones who fire missiles against israeli children for nothing, intended only to kill and try to destroy Israel. The rest is pure HIPOCRISY.
45. Zionist highway robbery, as usual...
(05.01.11)
46. #5 money paid in advance for electricity is EU's, NOT PA's
observer ,   Egypt   (05.01.11)
next bill will be paid to Egypt.
47. thats pocket change the PA don't need
zionist forever   (05.01.11)
They scrounge so much from the world every year they really don't need $88 million in tax money. Obama in his first year already gave the palestinians nearly $1 billion extra as a bonus that Congress had not already budgeted for and thats just an American bonus. Over the past two years the world has donated around $7 billion cash in hand to the palestinians. That doesn't even include the money thats donated to fund specific projects. Israel should keep the $88 million and use it to cover the costs of all the defense projects it has had to invest millions in to protect from the palestinians.
48. End all assistance to "Palestinians" permanently.
Chaim ,   Israel   (05.01.11)
Israel's lunatic policy of assisting those who dream of mass murdering us makes fictional Chelm seem like a land of geniuses. We send "Palestinians' money, food, electricity and assistance of every type. They send us back rockets, bombs and terrrorists. That's some deal! End all assistance to "Palestinians" permanently. Enough financing our would be genocidal murderers.
49. haven't recognized Fatah-Hamas reconciliation cost that much
observer ,   Egypt   (05.01.11)
of course for Israel!
50. 5
zionist forever   (05.01.11)
I have always wondered why we never handed responsibility for the palestinian electricity over to Egypt decades ago. Begin should have made it part of the treaty with Egypt.... if Egypt wouldn't take the Gaza dump off our hands the least they could do is take over responsibility for the electricity. Providing them with power cost israeli taxpayers millions. We have electricity needs and if we can't generate enough with the resources we have then the only solution is to build more power stations and the cost for which are past onto Israelis through higher bills. Stop supplying five million palestinians and we will need fewer power stations.
51. claims of damage, death must be laid against these funds
ralph   (05.01.11)
52. How About Using the Money to Pay for IRON DOME?
meir elazar   (05.02.11)
I don't know how much the R&D cost to develop IRON DOME or the manufacturing costs but I hear each missile cost $70,000. This should come directly out of the PA funds. If FATAH rejoins with HAMAS after all that HAMAS has done to FATAH and Israel then they deserve to forfeit the money and help pay to counter the GAZA terrorists.
53. transfers...
toronto ,   TORONTO CANADA   (05.02.11)
all the destruction to ALL physical property, be it residential, commercial, industrial, agricultural & personal, be generously compensated, to those that have suffered, the grief.... all claims.. NO -TIME-LIMIT...paid to all those victims, of Arab barbarity,,, Personal injury,MUST, be so generously pensioned.. depending on the severity of their injury....ALL funds, coming, from the transfer payments..!! let all the arabs know that they are responsible, for their butality & barbaric acts... the sooner this policy is inacted the sooner we all can work for a better & secure future... .. 'AM YISROEL CHAI'...
54. E.D. MHD / 40
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (05.02.11)
You can talk the talk but you can't walk the walk. In other words, you will never be able to put your money where your mouth is.
55. The big bad wolf is also tracking you down to the vaults
Ypip ,   Canada   (05.02.11)
56. to Nour 15
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (05.02.11)
Yes Nour, take a pause and study international law.What's the matter with you "Pallies"-why do you always show your ignorance.Don't you realize that educated Arabs also read your comments.
57. #41 Joseph
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.02.11)
Be frank, would you give the neighbor that hates your guts, money so that he can buy a gun to kill you with ?
58. #39 Bloodyscot, Bloody fool
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.02.11)
Both of the Charters/Covenants call for the destruction of Israel So far there's been no recent mention of modifying either of them Last time we discussed this song and dance was at Oslo, when Arafat agreed to, in writing, to remove that clause from the PLO Charter I have a newsflash for you, it's still there PLO will be the tail, Hamas will be the dog, PLO will wiggle it's tail when Hamas tells it to, if not, more blood will flow in the Arab streets
59. #Annex if you dare what you going to do????
Texan   (05.02.11)
Nour Israel should cut all ties West Bank and Gaza . You and Salma and the palestian people , can develop their on means for obtaining water energy resources for you need to exist.They should develop they own industry , they do not need to rely on Israel medical help water and food ,Live Israel alone .. You have peace with hamas Oslo died no more peace talks ...Good luck you journey ...
60. Now, deduct cost of Iron dome interceptions
Tahl   (05.02.11)
As well as accrued damages to property from the grads and kassams, and damages to Israeli victims who were hurt. You shoot at us, you pay.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article