Jewish Scene
Neturei Karta protest Holocaust Day
Ynet
Published: 03.05.11, 15:16
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
49 Talkbacks for this article
31. Just like those crazy baptists
Josh   (05.04.11)
Take a little piece of the truth twist it and use it to pour salt on wounds. It reminds me of Wetsboro although I must admit Torah curses do say a vile nation will be promoted over the sinners. Certainly their protests are not really based on Torah but neither is the state of Israel. Seems like one big sinking boat of foolishness.
32. Well written Anna +
Mina ,   Haifa   (05.04.11)
They do all of the above and more while surviving in Israel. To my opinion, they have also long ago crossed the fine line between opposing Zionism and acting against Israel and Jews who hold different views. One way for me to mentally cope with their hostile and un-safe conduct, is to stop considering them to be Jews, as no real Jews should act this way against other Jewish people.
33. Sorry: they should be banned from Israel NOW
EZ ,   USA   (05.04.11)
If I saw these loonies on a street near my house or city, myself and a slew of other religious Jews would disrupt the "protest" by every means possible. It would be a major smack down and they'd never openly spread such anti-semitism in our area again. It is the "Karta" who are NOT JEWS, they are oppositional to everything that IS Jewish. They must be Amalak in funny clothes. Expel and forbid them from Israel. Sorry, it's not free speech...its pure evil. Yes, Natura Karta is evil through and through.
34. Being Benei Horin
Michael ,   California, USA   (05.04.11)
There is a lingering guilt in every Jew, no matter how secular, toward the Jewish religion and religious Jews. After all, they lingered in this world for 3500 years, survived discriminations, pogroms, the Inquisition, the Shoa. Tolerance of them today is a payback for what they went through. Neturei Karta exploits this tolerance, they allow themselves to be arrogant and abusive of all the Israelis who still consider Jewish religion as part of identifying the Jewish people. In reality, since Israel came to independence in 1948, religion came to play a secondary role to an Israeli citizen, a minor role to a liberated person who is free from all the past guilts. People who are Benei Horin, can turn our back on Jewish religion; it is a relic, no longer necessary. To assert Israelis as Benei Horin, it is vitally important to show with determination where Neturei Karta belongs, since they are an insignificant minority. The Israeli government should move on it without delays. Defining them as terrorists by the Knesset will be an important first step.
35. I dont get it
tsip ,   usa   (05.05.11)
why dont they just move back to their hometowns in Europe. No one said they had to be in Israel
36. @34
Sasha ,   US   (05.05.11)
Move, but where?
37. Neturei Karta out of order
Zuri ,   Sydney, Australia   (05.05.11)
why are these people are considered Citizens of the state of Israel? If they despise the right of Israel to exist as a state,, let them migrate from here to Iran, or perhaps far away. This ideology is by no mean an excuse to burn Israeli flag- it is one thing they maybe do not do national service like any other Israeli citizen, but burning the flag and painting swastikas on our Magen David is simply an act of treason.
38. Aren't these, 'our' traitors, sitting shiva for ben laden?
(05.05.11)
they should be. machsom witches could visit them
39. 33
birdi ,   israel   (05.05.11)
agreed ez.
40. someone who lives in your house...
Greg ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (05.05.11)
...eats your food, which you payed for...and then says, "your house should be burned down!" 1. how are these people allowed to live here? 2. why do they take benefits from a state/gov't which they think should not exist to begin with? if you don't think the State of Israel should exist, then stand up for what you believe in and stop taking our taxes. If not, then sit down and shut up. I say this as a religious-zionist. :)
41. beyond disgusting
Miriam ,   NY USA   (05.05.11)
These ppl are disgusting. I am embarrassed that we are apart of the same nation.
42. Greg , 40 . As far as known to me
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (05.05.11)
they don't take money from the state .
43. 34 Michael
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (05.05.11)
Are you giving those Natura Karta boys as an excuse,to turn Israel s back to religion? Secular way of life "seems" to you nicer,but what will keep Jews together, as ONE people? Roses smell better than cabbage.Can you therefore conclude,that roses make better soup?
44. How many members of NK lost people in the Holocaust?
zionist forever   (05.06.11)
I imagine that at least some of them lost relatives or know people who lost relatives during the war. On the day we remember and mourn for those dead these disgusting individuals who call themselves Jews choose to paint a swastika on the Israeli flag at the moment the sirens ring. I have more respect for Hamas than those people who call themselves jews but ally themselves with the people that kill jews and protest on the day we remember murdered jews. They all love the palestinians so much then lets give them all a one way ticket to Hamastan.
45. we look at the nk today b
amw ,   jerusalem   (08.30.11)
we look at the nk today but how many jews could have been saved but the jewish agency refused to recue them. a cow in israel is more important than a jew is the us. perfidy was a book about such things. we see today thatisrael is good but the state did everything totake judism from the morcos and yemites,
46. Yes I am a very strong supportive Zionist
Aaron ,   LA, US   (08.31.11)
but you guys are ridiculous. I use to think that Israel should send them to live in Gaza as well. The only problem is they are still Jews. One of the many things Chabad has taught me is that no matter about political views, drug addictions, you name it, a Jew is still a Jew and no matter what they will always be a Jew.
47. Neturei Karta .. Out of Medinat ISRAEL....
Texan   (08.31.11)
They are a bunch of terrorist Send them to Gaza or to Iran they welcome theme with the gas chambers ...AM YISRAEL CHAI !! G-D Bless our IDF and the Nation of ISRAEL ....
48. HARADI,S
DANNY TAWIL ,   ENGLAND   (04.26.12)
IM GLAD I WASENT THERE WHEN THEY PUT A SWASTIKA ON THE ISRAELI FLAG AND BURNNT IT. I DEFINETLY WOULD HAVE HURT ONE OF THEM, PERHAPS TWO MY SIZE PUT THEM IN THE ARMY DONT LIKE IT, DEPORT THEM TO GAZA OR PUT THEM IN PRISON. LONG TERM. TREASON.
49. Remeber that it's a radical and tiny minority of maniacs
(04.08.13)
which put shame over an entire state, but mostly on themselves only.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article