News
Turkey demands names of soldiers involved in flotilla raid
Ynet
Published: 14.05.11, 11:11
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
108 Talkbacks for this article
31. No names...No way
Christy ,   USA   (05.14.11)
32. Turkey demands?
JGrosman ,   TEXAS   (05.14.11)
I hope Israel learns a lesson from this and from now on sinks any ship that tries to run the blockade.
33. To David, # 17 Karmiel.
josef   (05.14.11)
The reason that El-Al cannot fly over Turkey, that Turkey can fly over our air space, that our supermarkets sell turkish product , is simply because we have quite a few imbeciles in our knesset who don't know what they are doing.
34. #20 - I agree with you....
William ,   Israel   (05.14.11)
No reason to host such racist arrogant leaders in beautiful Israel. I'm for turning Turkish embassy into a Kurdish and Armenian cultural center.
35. Maybe Erdogan has joined Amway
William ,   Israel   (05.14.11)
and he needs a contact list to begin his mail-order business. I hear he personally likes to wear Mary Kay cosmetics but it doesn't come up much in interviews.
36. Just sent a post..Now about Turkey's Erdogan..
James T ,   USA   (05.14.11)
Doesn't it show how this man Erdogan has turned the clock back joining with the ultra Islamists. Be that as it may..HE and his AKP party and the IHH that is considered a terroristic one,should give cause of concern for most liberal thinking people...As far as the flotilla the man's pride cannot forget and like a dog withe a bone will not let it go.. What does that about the man and his followers..Remember this is not the first time that he has verbally insisting Israel to apologize..I hope Israel will tell him to shove off in no uncertain terms..This latest beats the previous ones..Wanting the names of the soldiers..gee ROTFL You dumbite.. Only in your dreams buffoon//
37. Turkey wants .....
nowt   (05.14.11)
Give them what they want BUT ficticious names.
38. Cut ties and move on
john   (05.14.11)
Just cut ties with Turkey and let's start making new allies in the region....the Turkey we once knew is no more.
39. turkey's demand
lothar ,   cork ireland   (05.14.11)
okay folks - Israeli soldiers murder nine civilians in international waters - and all you have to offer is sneers. And then you wonder why most people all over the world are running out of sympathy for 'the chosen people'. It used to be the Palestinians were their own worst enemies. Now the more and more right-wing Israelis are becoming a dangerous liability for Jews everywhere else. Well, may we all get what we deserve....
40. I'VE GOT NAMES
kj   (05.14.11)
it was 6 soldiers: e' a' t' a' s' s'
41. #20 Right on, Dude!
jb ,   Canada   (05.14.11)
Great idea!! And tell Erdogan to take his head out of his ass too!
42. How about...um..NO?!
Yaniv ,   Israel   (05.14.11)
43. what nonsense. tell them to drink the sea
ralph   (05.14.11)
44. lothar you will get what you deserve in Ireland
joe frazier   (05.14.11)
The fertility rate in the EU is 1.38. The minimum fertility rate to maintain a culture is 2.11. With Islamic immigration, and close to double digit fertility rates, Ireland will be an Islamic republic within 50 years.
45. To # 16 eporue , europe
Abu Yussef al Yahudi ,   Bue_Aires_Argentina   (05.14.11)
How dare you to compare the bloody and merciless Nazis with the Naval Forces of Israel ? The Nazis were bloodthirsty beasts, whitout any moral, that murdered more than 25 millions people, among them Jews, Gipsies, POWs of the Allies Army, German dissident civilians , etc.. They commited that atrocious Crimes Against Humanity against unarmed people, using their technological know-how to create the most heinous Death Machinery that the Mankind had known in the whole History. The other way, the Naval Forces of Israel, were enforcing a LEGAL BLOCKADE of an Enemy Entity, defending the lives of her citizens againts and external menace. I ask you again, - How you dare to compare these two diferent entities, the Nazis and the Israeli Naval Force? If you have a valid fact, that allow you to perform this very wrong comparisson, please let's know it. And if you DO NOT HAVE a valid fact to sustain the comparisson, please put a post to apologize to us, all the posters of this Talkback. We are wating for your answer.
46. #16
Jorge ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (05.14.11)
There was not any Jewish provocation in 1939 to the nazi, they wanted to get rid of all of us. The cretaed an Holocaust The turkish goverment indirectly sponsor an invasion to another country and failed and also got a set back in the u n becuase they could not prove any violation to the international law. The entity of ankara wants to take action and revenge to save their honor. This is a big difference between the nazis that wanted to kill everybody and Israel that protected their beaches; so you do not fully understand them. This set back can cost votes to erdogan
47. Turkey
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (05.14.11)
Turkish Megalomania,turkey is a very poor country,but they believe that they still rule the world.
48. Israel arms soldiers with paintball guns
Lee Kaplan ,   Berkeley   (05.14.11)
And these Turkish morons are trying to portray the event as a massacre? Israel ony encourages this nonsense. They even repaired the Mavi Mamara and sent it back for this new flotilla instead of selling it and compensating the victims in Sderot. Sure, and the Turks are the cvictims of the Armenians who attacked them by staarving to death...
49. Give them my name...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (05.14.11)
..so I can tell where to go and how to get there.
50. @16 You don't compare the incidents?
joe ,   st louis usa   (05.14.11)
You just did. Anyway here's the difference in case you don't get it: Israel has a very strict system of internal investigation, and also submitted to an international investigation in this incident. Both investigations found that the soldiers were acting properly and humanely. Turkey on the other hand, is merely trying to defy the will of the world. There is no comparison to Nazis whatsoever, and the Turkish demand is not "understandable" at all.
51. @39: The UN disagrees with you. Sorry.
joe ,   st louis usa   (05.14.11)
52. #38 lothar, put you pint down
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (05.14.11)
You have plenty of time to book passage in the next Flotilla where you can express yiour grouch in person The Marvi was intended to be a ship of peace, it had a bunch of trained riotors that provoked a confrontation You can waddle your way over to the pissoir to relieve yourself after guzzling all that beer BTW-How about revealing all the names of the IRA thugs that bombed Irishmen and English that opposed the IRA, you wouldn't be on the list, you're too much of a blowhard to have taken part in any action
53. #39
Texas2step ,   Dallastx   (05.14.11)
Since when was Ireland,which maintained proper relations with nazi Germany all through WWII ever sympathetic to Jews? And since when are armed men trying to open a supply chain to a group/statelet with genocidal intent "civilians" who are allowed to Did the UK let you trade with your good friend Nazi Germany in the war? I don't think so. And what do you think would have happened to any pro-Nazi "civilians" trying to break the British blockade?
54. names? why not "friend request" on facebook.
brian ,   us   (05.14.11)
Putz
55. #39 - lothar
Maurice ,   Montreal   (05.14.11)
Why don't you worry about the dismal situation in your bankrupt country before sticking your booze stinking nose into Israeli affairs! IDF soldiers murdered no one. They protected themselves against thugs and terrorists. Have you not seen the videos the whole world saw? I guess you prefer to ignore facts to serve your ugly antisemitic agenda.
56. Names are: Moshe, Yossi, Avi, Shlomo, Itzik, Dudu & Co.
(05.14.11)
go to hell, erdogan !
57. Must be election time in Turkey....
Danny   (05.14.11)
Time to manufacture a fake incident...
58. 29 you beter
anton ,   istanbul turkey   (05.14.11)
call me old friend even if its sarcasm :) i know you are speaking out of anger because if you didint you'd know turks helped jews when spinards chased them away ,when nazis killed them i suggest you to watch the documentary made by turks called turkish passport its in cannes film festival this year may be it wll change your flawed opinion about turks i want embassy to be closed cause we cant be friends again its cryristal clear israel wont apologize and turks wont let it go 9 citizens killed so beter we stop here and leave eacthother alone dont you think? lastly i never tried cuban coffe my friend once said its too bitter :) i prefer sweet turkish coffe
59. NOTHING 2 HIDE ,HERE ARE NAMES
LAWRENCE ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (05.14.11)
Elvis ,Michael Jackson , Osama Bin Laden ,Princess Di , Elizabeth Taylor .All of them raided the ill-fated flotilla.
60. IT MUST BE APRIL 1ST! APRIL FOOLS DAY
Tony ,   Brooklyn   (05.14.11)
Anyone can see that Turkey is not a friend to Israel but is becoming a radical Islamic state.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article