News
Friedman: Netanyahu doesn't want peace
Ynet
Published: 18.05.11, 11:01
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
78 Talkbacks for this article
31. Friedman offers only wishful thinking
Clear Thinker ,   Haifa   (05.18.11)
Friedman has forgotten that Ehud Olmert made a far-reaching concession when he discussed with Abu Mazen Israel's willingness to accept a defined number of Palestinean refugees into Israel and Abu Mazen rejected that. Tsipi Livni was less forthcoming when she offered Abu Mazen borders for a Palestinian state. Netanyahu faces a different reality than Olmert or Livni. Distroy-Israel Hamas is part of the Palestinian Authority scene, so how can Netanyahu now hold talks with Abu Mazen?
32. That describes ABBAS, not Bibi
Zvi   (05.18.11)
33. How many times does Friedman have to discredit himself
Ehoop ,   UK   (05.18.11)
before the Times gets rid of him? Lousy, careless propaganda masquerading as journalism.
34. Dear Mr. Friedman
R ,   Israel   (05.18.11)
Bibi is trying to keep us out of the sea. It has become clear that there is currently no partner to peace. Abbas has missed every opportunity and Hamas never misses an opportunity to declare that they will never accept an Israeli presence on any part of this land. All this posturing by U.S., European, and other envoys just costs a lot of money and gives journalists what to write about but it has been going on for decades and hasn't brought peace. There is nothing to do except hold out until there will be a Palestinian leadership interested in peace.
35. Honesty
David ,   New York   (05.18.11)
Mr Friedman, I would be enlightened if you could share with me twho are the Palestinians "down the street" who are willing to even listen to Netanyahu. To proceed with achieveing peace, we need to be honest with ourselves and recognize the reality that the Palestinians are not partners in the endeavor
36. #30 Impostors, infestors, inciters and fools
(05.18.11)
So many impostors here #30, #29 are only a few examples. Son't worry - your pathetic attempts at demoralizing anyone here fail - we KNOW what you want and we are easily resisting and rejecting you and your religion. We'll NEVER convert to Islam and we'll NEVER give up our rights to our ancestral lands. Israel will always belong to the Jews, with all your threats, lies, disinformation, terror and wars. ISLAM WILL BE STOPPED AT THE GATES OF ISRAEL - AT ANY COST!
37. WHO CARES WHAT FRIEDMAN THINKS?
(05.18.11)
He is irrelevant, corrupt and despised! Nobody buys NYT anymore - they tried everything - lowering the prices, marketing, licking Muslim ass, joining with the liberals, licking more Muslim ass, creating an iPhone app and offering online subscriptions - EVERYTHING! They are going down just as CNN did and just as MSNBC! "You can fool some of the people for some time, but not all of the people all the time". And the people are waking up, and NYT is being led to the latrine - where it belongs.
38. have you seen what a palestin map look s like
i hope u will read ,   that   (05.18.11)
according to the PLO (not hamas) ???? a littlie hint- it goes from the jorden river to the medditeranian sea. abbas made his 1982 doctorat about why the jewish houlacoste never happend!!! when abbas will stop claiming for the right of return to ako, tveria and zfat then we'll believe you and him. in his op-ed yesterday abbas more than hinted that going to the UN and establishing a palestinian state is only the begining of bringing back to the arabs what's their's. and BTW, he wasn't precising with the other details either... I don't know how it sounds to you tom but maybe netanyahu dares to say what abbas always said without exactly saying????????????
39. #20 And the Irish have had enough of you it seems
Talula ,   Israel   (05.18.11)
I assume it's Chigwell, Essex in the UK - wherever it is, it doesn't allow you to start banging on about my country - particularly when they are burning the Union Jack in Northern Ireland today. What gives you the right to force peace on our country? Did your children die fighting to save our country? were your family sent to the gas chambers, which promoted the birth of this country as a safe haven for Jews? Probably not. So back off and don't stick your nose in where it doesn't concern you, and more so, in a country that you don't even live in. You'd be better off heading for Londonderry with a bucket of water.
40. Thomas Friedman
Sunny Apfelbaum ,   Israel   (05.18.11)
Mr. Friedman should read what an Arab jounalist wrote in the Jerusalem Post on Monday 16th May. The Arabs do not want land they just want the end of teh Jewish State. So please Mr. Friedman who lives in the States and is not surrounded by millions of people who want his demise, think what it would be like if we give more land to our cousins. THINK...they say it loud and clear that this is their land and we should all be in the sea. Please try to imagine living somewhere and you know in no uncertain terms that they want your blood not your money, not your home but your blood. Why don't you preach to the Arabs who stab each other in the back and have no word of honour. Thank you for your concern but please don't preach to Bibi.
41. Friedman lost all respect with his "Hama Rules" fashla
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (05.18.11)
Friedman's arguments would carry more weight if he didn't have the stain on his record of comparing Israel to Haffez Assad of Syria. His infamous column where he accused Israel of using "Hama Rules" showed us that he lost all sense of proportionality in looking at the Middle East. Friedman accused Israel of behaving like Syria, where Assad sent in the troops and killed upwards of 20000 people in the city of Hama, and then bulldozed flat the neighborhoods that were destroyed. There were no repercussion in Hama, of course, because the world didn't (and still doesn't) care when Arab dictators butcher their own people. Friedman says we're the same. I disagree and I accuse Friedman of not only getting it wrong, but being so wrapped up in political correctness that he can't even see a path to take it back and apologize. Friedman got it wrong, and shows us that he continues to get it wrong.
42. The dog barks>
HaifaGuy   (05.18.11)
> but the caravan moves on. Calm, security, economic prosperity (BB) Bark-bark-bark-bark!! (TF)
43. Mind-boggling
john   (05.18.11)
Friedman has been on an anti-Israel tear for the past 2 years now. I'm not sure what he's reading or where he's getting his information from, but he seems to blame Bibi for everything...and Israel along with him. As a journalist who many people read, he must be more objective, factual, and fair.
44. Who needs the enemies when we have Friedman?
Dan ,   USA   (05.18.11)
45. Freedman is a shaw man and an entertainer
Ron LA   (05.18.11)
46. Mr Friedman , a lot of people believe in Netanyahu
etinzon ,   hul   (05.18.11)
Of course , all these people happen to be jewish and live in Israel
47.  the right spelling:piece deal !
Trumpeldor   (05.18.11)
48. Bibi doesnot want peace?
anna ,   Fort Lee NJ. USA   (05.18.11)
Mr Freedman Get you facts streight. Show me an Arab who wants peace with Israel. let him come forward and say so
49. nu. 38
shoshana ,   jerusalem   (05.18.11)
you've got it all right. i hope mr. fridman will read it. and you forggot about mentioning jerusalem and the archological therror near the Temple Mount which no one of his readers ever heard about...
50. Friedman always finds moral equivalence
Michael ,   NY USA   (05.18.11)
in his articles. Biib is 'not serious" and Fatah Hamas deal "needs to be explained to reassure Israeli public".After Abbas'NYT article on the phased destruction of Israel , were in for quite a long chill
51. Let's just keep blaming Israel
Joe ,   Florida, USA   (05.18.11)
"Yep, it's Israel's fault. Yep, it's those crazy Jewish people again, messing it up!" BULLSH**. Any human being on this planet who thinks that the Arabs want PEACE with Israel is totally void of knowledge about this issue. The Arabs have a laser focus on one thing only: Israel's destruction. They will settle for nothing less. They will tell you they want peace. That's TAQUIYYA in action. Imagine Israel giving up more land (this would be like saying "please take everything I own.").....The Arabs will want more and more and more, and will become more aggressive and more frenzied in their approach after seeing that Israel had already given up land. They'd know that violence and terrorism pay off. Arabs don't understand "talks" and "play nice" and "reasoning." They understand violence. Look at what they're teaching their kids in kindergarten........HATE HATE HATE.. Whom to they hate? They hate anything Jewish and anything Israeli and anything American. They hate anything that is not ISLAMIC and ruled under Sharia law. Now imagine a "peace deal" is signed. Who'd really believe the Pally's, after all these years, would say "Gee guys, I now accept Israel as a legitimate country, and these are really cool people"? What? They're going to snap out of it somehow? You know, like a heroin addict wakes up gets bored with heroin? BULL! Like a baby programmed to cry, the Arabs know of no other way than VIOLENCE. How can the Stinians say they want peace when they don't have the mental capacity to UNDERSTAND peace?
52. An Imbasille
Ben ,   USA   (05.18.11)
Absolute Nincompoop
53. TOMAS ... Friedman doesn't want peace
(05.18.11)
TOMAS ... Friedman doesn't want peace
54. T. Friedman
Dr. R. Grynpas ,   Brussels, Belgium   (05.18.11)
This journalist, whose writings represent opinions rather than facts, he's blinded by his cognitive dissonance, as most of this leftist friends.
55. Tom
michael Pielet ,   boca raton, Israel   (05.18.11)
Uncle Tom Friedman is nothing but an old fashioned Israel hating anti-semite. Uncle Tom does not want peace he wants the conflict to continue on so that he can continue with the Times.
56. Yeap time for a true surprise
Danny   (05.18.11)
and tell it the way it is. The Palestinians simply do want to make peace. They are willing to talk and talk but at the end of the day they simply cannot end the conflict.
57. Us Jews
Lia ,   Kiron Israel   (05.18.11)
Why we jews always have what to say when opinion is adverse from what we want to hear?
58. Friedman should have his ears cleaned.
Rebecca ,   Modiin   (05.18.11)
Bibi is not Hamas's Mahmoud al-Zahar
59. perhaps
marcel   (05.18.11)
perhaps bibi is delaying doing anything and does not meet with his royal highness tom friedman's approval of the palestine new york times. Abbas and hamas say problem is 48, zionist project should end, itamar is legitimate. so,what creative ideas do you suggest. One idea not thought is for th eUN to allot a new land for israel that all agree on with 10 trillioin dollars compensation and for israel to move as far away from the arabs as humanly possible. Then the arabs can choke on jerusalem and sunnis can kill shias, and christians and live happily ever after starting wars and asking the Un for handouts.
60. Leftist Friedman is blinded by facts.
Claudia ,   Tampa USA   (05.18.11)
This cretin has no credibility whatsoever to the vast majority of Americans. Those in NYC and the NE are pecularily infested with a brainwashing that allows them to ignore the root of the problem in Israel, and the ME generally ..Islam. Just like with Hitler in WWII the Progressives seem to think appeasement and rational thinking will be enough to reason with Islamic factions and countries. Perhaps they should be aware of the Koran and Sharia & determine how they want to live themselves under such a terrible system of rule. Of course they don't believe any of this will apply to them as they are all Ivy League scholars and apart of an elite class the Muslims will bow to. HA! This kind of thinking is what lead to Oslo, and the murderous return of Arafat from the exile he so richly deserved. No terrorist is bad enough for the Elites not to believe they can reason with. They are the most arrogant idiots on Earth and Friedman is one of their spokesmen that only gets published because he is also Jewish & that alone makes him credible to them. Friedman obviously gets paid by the word, regardless of how nonsensical those words are.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article