News
Hamas: Let's discuss 1948 lines
Elior Levy
Published: 23.05.11, 14:43
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
100 Talkbacks for this article
91. The fight
Ayman ,   Florida   (05.24.11)
It was the Arabs who turned 'tail' and left in 1948..First the elites at the end of 1947 and then the middle class...They had 'no fight ' in them relying on the arab armies to 'liberate' the land murder the jewish inhabitants and steal their possesions.. Jews lost 1%..6000 in the 1948 war. Let's face facts...How many countries do the Palestinians need...? JORDAN is Palestine...70% of Jordanians are Palestinians...This is their country...NOT ISRAEL...!!!!!!!!!!!!
92. 1948 Lines
Mark ,   USA   (05.24.11)
I have an idea: Stop this "land for peace" folly once and for all and offer citizenship to jews worldwide, wherever we may reside, the only caveat being some sort of national or financial charge to this type of citizen. I am sure that a few million jews will jump at this, putting the demographic issue to rest once and for all. Then annex Judea and Samaria, and offer compensation to those who do not wish to declare their allegiance to the Jewish State of Israel. Done deal.
93. #68 - Hamas is not supported as they claim
William ,   Israel   (05.24.11)
In a poll among Gazans in 2010, Hamas received only a 28% approval rating even though Haniyeh kept insisting all of Gaza is behind them. In a rally on their anniversary, reports of threats by Hamas to withhold UNWRA benefits caused many to attend these events. Hamas' support, like the "Palestinian" narrative, remains a farce.
94. The only Historical Palestine is in Syria
William ,   Israel   (05.24.11)
it's a province from the time of the Romans (and the source of the name they gave to Israel after ethnically cleansing Jews). And I'm all for allowing "Palestinians" especially Zahar the Egyptian to gain a State there....in Historical Palestine.
95. #81 - and that got you offended?
William ,   Israel   (05.24.11)
The number of Arab States mis-mentioned?? You really have a lot of time on your hands, don't you? Too bad that some schmuck calling for "justice for all world" is too busy in front of the Internet rather than volunteering time to help his/her community. Selfish bastard.
96. #47 Why do you say "Israelis"
John ,   Alaska   (05.24.11)
Amir, you said ... " I'm sure most 'Israelis' will leave..." Why "Israelis" instead of Israelis? Are you saying that the only way one can refer to the citizens of Israel is ironically? If so that is very offensive. If not, what did you mean?
97. hamas -look who's got chutzpa
alexx ,   usa   (05.24.11)
complementing Sarah B's eloquent writing, I would like to assure Zahar and any of his co-murderers of innocent civillians that we who have fought and WON the 1967 six-day war against hoards of "peace-loving-Arabs" will never again return to borders that cannot be defended. We might reconsider that as soon as USA returns California, Arizona and N.M. to Mexico, and Hawaii is returned to its natives,etc.
98. he's trying to goad obama.... pffffft
roxanne ,   haifa, israel   (05.24.11)
99. to nr. 95.
justice for all ,   world/planet earth   (05.25.11)
your reaction says more about yourself than about me. insulting somebody is always a sign of weakness and that you lack of good arguments. first learn how to communicate well and in a decent way before your next talkback. nobody takes your hateful insults. if you do not believe me/agree with me, try before you die. you surely have a lot to learn! success!
100. to nr. 88.
justice for all ,   world/planet earth   (05.25.11)
thanks to your nice reaction, but do not worry about my intellect. there is absolutley nothing wrong with it. at first look at your own "intellect" before judging other people! improve the world but begin with yourself! what you do not want to happen to yourself, also do not do that to another person! this was some free advice. hope you can use it. i do not want to repeat myself always like you do with your same mantras over and over again! if you have any complaints about me, write to the editorship of ynetnews.com and leave me alone. otherwise you know about my promise to you which i made earlier. DO NOT MESS WITH ME! am i now clear (enough) to you at last? by the way insulting, offending and using abusive language is always a sign of weakness and a lack to good and decent arguments. success with my free and well-meant advice to you!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article