Opinion
Death to baby killers
Hagai Segal
Published: 10.06.11, 15:29
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
90 Talkbacks for this article
61. Some things...
LebanonPride ,   Canada   (06.11.11)
First, I do not support the killing (or harming) of children. Now, for those who think these people's hate is from Islam and Hamas, please open your eyes. Your occupation of Palestine, killing of families, removing them from their homes and land are what creates this hate. It has nothing to do with the Quran. What would the death penalty accomplish? Do you think these individuals want to live? And how many Israeli settlers and IDF soldiers would this effect?
62. Better than death
sk ,   USA   (06.11.11)
Take them to a pig farm (yes there are pig farms in Israel). Tie them up and dump them in the pig filth without food and water for days at a stretch.
63. Death Penalty a big Mistake
Sharon Collins ,   Henderson, TX, USA   (06.11.11)
You are right...no medical care and just the minimum of food to eat...death would be too good for this inhuman! Glory to Israel!!
64. Death is too good for him.
noa ,   israel   (06.11.11)
A slow and long confinement at the hand of his enemies . . . that's better.
65. Death to baby killers
nn ,   Norway   (06.11.11)
What is in store for these murderers after death is far worse than what any man can do to them!
66. YES AND YES!! ISRAEL NEEDS TO BE FEARED!!!
jessica ,   Israel/USA   (06.11.11)
an eye for an eye is what these pieces of dirt baby killers will understand!
67. 59 - The arabs stole the land in the 600's AD
split ,   US   (06.11.11)
Are you trying to convince me that Rebe Elyashiv, Rebe Eliyahu, Ben-Gurion, Rabin, Sharon, Olmert, Livni, Netanyahu, Barak, Lieberman, Eban Oren, Wilf , Ayalon, Maron, Rafaeli, Sharansky or Shalit and the rest of the blue eyed nomads are "Semites" and have a roots in that part of the world ? ,...
68. # 67
Jules   (06.11.11)
Yes, the do have the roots in this part of the world. Very strong roots they are. The strongest one is called the IDF. Need a proof ? Recall 1967.
69. To 43 You only read the arab Media, here are some facts
George ,   Shderot Israel   (06.11.11)
Hamas agreed that from the people who died in operatiion Cast Lead 740 were Hamas Fighters. According to all findings including Goldstone report there were only 1250 victims due the War. So that leaves us only 500 civilians killed. Those civilians were NOT MILITARY TARGETS (most of them were used as shields) ISRAEL send thousand of fliers before each bombardments to advice civilinas to leave, more than 300.000 telephones were made for same reason, to evacuate the zone, in many cases Hamas retain civilians as hostages. Most of the civilians killed were used as human shields. It is a pitty children died, but you are distorting the truth just like the arab media. Children were not the target, we are not children killers. This is sometimes the price of stupid wars, but who started sending miusiles to Israel and using civilians as humans shields? Most of Haas leadrs were not fighting to defend Gaza they were hiding in Mosques and Hospitals. They went underground leaving the people abandoned.
70. Death is too good for them.
Gabe Yakmore ,   Canada   (06.11.11)
They should be locked up with violent criminals until they die. Hang them if they manage to survive ten years.
71. A suggestion
olim hadashim ,   tel aviv/israel   (06.11.11)
They shall get life sentence and shall work in the construction of a new city in the Land of Israel called : Kiryat Fogel
72. execution of baby killers
Paul ,   Philadelphia, USA   (06.11.11)
kill this animal and feed his remains to pigs
73. #67
SRObserver ,   Dallas USA   (06.11.11)
I have blue eyes, am Jewish and had my maternal and paternal DNA tested (it is not expensive and only takes two swabs) and both indicated family lines originating from the Middle East (where Israel is) up through Italy and then into Europe. I was told this was typically Jewish. 500,000 Arabs moved into Palestine at the time of the Mandate for the jobs Are they "Palestinian" - everyone says they are.
74. Death is too good for them
gadot ,   israel   (06.11.11)
cut off their hands,so they can't kill again.our friends in arab countries do it,so it is OK according to ISLAM.
75. # 67 split, #73 SRObserver
solomon ,   bklyn   (06.11.11)
#67- Yes they are. Period. 'Roots' are DNA. Jews are all colors, all types. Go to Israel and you'll see them. But only if you open your eyes. #73- You had your DNA tested? Kol ha'kavod! "Family lines originating from the Middle East (where Israel is) up through Italy and then into Europe...... typically Jewish". That is especially interesting. Thanks.
76. Death penalty
Miri ,   Panama   (06.12.11)
No to death penalty, they should be thrown to jail, the key thrown as well, and their menu should be one.. PIG.... they dont want to eat pig, tough luck, thats the menu that hotel serves...!!!
77. #67, 73, 75
Devorah   (06.12.11)
#67 - My eyes are green. Haven't you ever see a very black person with blue eyes? #73 - I had my DNA tested, too, for a National Geographic project, and it showed a similar thing as yours. My DNA goes back to the ME. #75 - Shavua tov.
78. Ahmed,we have the every right to judge them
American Sabrah   (06.12.11)
You have no right to judge their victims.Perhaps wanton murder of defenseless infants is justified in your third world backwards society but it isn't in ours.Its clear that you and your ilk are not interested in peace; you want to see us reduce to pieces instead. So GET THE HELL OUT OF ISRAEL AND GO BACK TO JORDAN!!!
79. Use the Yigal Amir law
Zev ,   Israel   (06.12.11)
Solitary confinement, Life sentence till they die, no chance of pardon or early release.
80. #77 Devorah - Shavua Tov gam lach.
solomon ,   bklyn   (06.12.11)
81. Fallacious propaganda
Canadian Dude ,   Canada   (06.12.11)
"Our enemies read in the newspapers about some 100,000 Israelis who acquired a German passport recently and conclude that the mental and operational conditions are ripe for storming our border fences." Are you kidding? Most of them don't know anything about Israelis holding German passports, and they don't give a crap. They see Netanyahu and his associates on TV all but promising to drive the Arabs out of Israel/West Bank, and *that's* why they storm the borders. "They see on television the waves of protests in favor of releasing hundreds of killers for one soldier and interpret them as a desire to commit suicide." That's very low of you, trying to connect the efforts to free Gilad Shalit with some sort of weakness on Israel's part. If Rambo could have rescued him (alive), it would have already happened.
82. Gee #37: Utter hypocrisy
Canadian Dude ,   Canada   (06.12.11)
The Lehi group was at one time considered a terrorist organization by Israel. Should they have all been executed, as per state laws? What about soldiers convicted of war crimes that led to civilian deaths?
83. death penalty itamar
michael livingston ,   cheltenham pa usa   (06.12.11)
Sorry but I don't think it's a good idea, particularly if they are underage. It will only be used against Israel. It won't bring the victims back.
84. To all who oppose death penalty
Alexander ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (06.12.11)
One does not "lower oneself" to the barbaric level of monstuous killers that show a shocking and blatant disregard for the sanctity of life. Death penalty should be used precisely to punish those who have shed blood and have taken innocent peoples' lives. You can't compare killing a human being in cold blood with demanding justice in the form of death penalty. Besides, placing this killer in an Israeli prison would mean that Israeli tax payers would have to pay taxes for keeping a murderer alive - a murderer with Jewish blood on his hands. The logic that "death doesn't deter fanatical Arabs/Moslems and therefore giving Arab terrorists death penalty won't change a thing" is completely wrong and fallacious. Once liberated from their physical earthy existence they pose no threat no more - no matter if they feared or loved death. The main point is not to deter them but to get rid of them. And the main point is not to deter fanatical terrorists that love death more than life, but precisely to give the terrorists what they want - death. We should not live side by side with genocidal maniacs hellbent on our death and destruction, trying to deter them for a week or two, for a month or two, but to wipe them out completely. There will be no coexistence with genocidal anti-Semitic maniacs and we will liberate them from their earthly existence. For once a terrorist is dead he can't bother us no more. A good terrorist is a dead terrorist. And when I say getting rid of terrorists I don't mean a few single individual terrorists here and there - I mean the entire despotic, tyrannic, anti-Semitic, backward, medieval Arab/Moslem socities need to be uprooted with the same determination that USA, UK, USSR and the Allied Forces showed when they destroyed Nazi Germany - a complete, total and unconditional destruction of Israel's enemies and forcing them to surrender.
85. 3,000,000 taxpayer dollars for 50 years in jail...or capital
Judah ,   Israel   (06.13.11)
punishment. Lets not give these cursed men any barghouti treatemnt: no cells phones, no on line studdies, no friends in jail, no worship, no communal prayers, no conjugal visits, no breeding of future curses. end them now. Justice cries out for justice. capital punishment nees to happen. those that show any compassion to the brazen & proud guilty,, show cruelty to the innocent
86. #82 Canadian dude
solomon ,   bklyn   (06.13.11)
What soldiers have been convicted of war crimes (other than in the media)?
87. The price of Jewish blood
Bless israel. ,   United States   (06.13.11)
how many times have we read of "Jewish infants under the age of two " being murdered by the state? Are we as a people be exterminated due to their hatred, fear and ignorance? NEVER AGAIN!
88. Canadian Dude #82 yes you are a hypocrite
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (06.13.11)
Lehi attacked British government targets. That is not terrorism, if they were attacking civilians as their target like Arabs then they would have been terrorists, but that logic seems to be beyond you ken. Several members were executed by the British. And the organization was outlawed by the Israeli government upon their creation and guess what? Lehi stopped operation. How many of those type organizations have PA outlawed? The answer is zero. As for IDF soldiers - not one has ever been convicted of any war-crimes. Just because a civilian is killed does not prove a war-crime. If it did several thousand Canadian soldiers would be guilty of that crime, yet none have ever faced any such charges. Intent is the reason, but again that logic seems to beyond you knowledge.
89. 36
zionist forever   (06.13.11)
It doesn't matter if this guy is living in Tel Aviv, Itmar or your back yard he had no right to kill these people in their bed. Were those children who he stabbed to death oppressing you in some way, was he fighting them in self defense? He chose to murder that family and he has even said he has no regrets and is proud of what he did. You can't cry occupation to justify terrorism. This guy should hang and then his body dumped at sea.
90. Do not keep them to be graduates on our money!
Daniel ,   Israel   (01.30.12)
And for future exchange.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article