News
2 rockets fired from Gaza
Ilana Curiel
Published: 04.08.11, 06:41
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
64 Talkbacks for this article
61. again your Jerusalem nonsense observer??
IlanaB   (08.05.11)
We have done this before-why dont you learn: To clear things up: The Tanach is the Hebrew Bible. It contains the Torah BUT ALSO: Nevi'im, and Ketuvim(tulmud,midrash gemarim etc). The Torah covers the creation of the earth and the first humans, the Great Flood and the covenant with the gentiles, the enslavement of and Exodus from the Hebrews in Egypt, giving of the Torah (Written and Oral), renewal of Covenant given to Avraham, festivals established, wandering through the desert, the Tabernacle Ark, Priestly duties, and the death of Moshe Rabbenu. The Nevi'im (נביאים) covers the time period from the death of Moshe Rabbenu through the Babylonian exile (ca.1200BCE-587BCE) and contains 19 books. The Ketuvim (כתובם) covers the period after the return from the Babylonian exile (6th century BCE) and contains 12 books. Now about Jerusalem: Jerusalem is mentioned many HUNDREDS of times in the Jewish Bible. As for the Chumash (Five Books of Moses), it is true that the word "Jerusalem" does not appear there. Most simply, this is because it was not yet called Jerusalem. Under Jebusite rule and earlier, Jerusalem was divided into two cities, the western part called Jeru (Yere) and the eastern part called Salem (Shalem). Both of these names do appear in the Five Books: "And Malki-Tzedek, King of Shalem" (Genesis 14:18). "And Abraham called that place...Yere" (Genesis 21:14). Around the time of Joshua's conquest, the Amorites consolidated the two halves of the city, and they combined the two names: Jeru-salem. From this point on in history, our Bible refers to Jerusalem countless times. Furthermore, the Chumash refers 19 times to "the place that G-d will choose" as the center for Jewish life and religion (e.g. Deuteronomy 12:11, 14, etc.) The Prophets Shmuel and Gad finally reveal to King David that this chosen place is Jerusalem and the Temple Mount. So here's another reason Jerusalem isn't mentioned explicitly in the Chumash as the holy city: It hadn't yet been revealed as such. Maimonides, writing around 800 years ago, offers three reasons that the Chumash does not reveal the identity of the holy city: If the nations had learned that this place would express the highest Jewish ideals, they would have united in an effort to occupy and prevent the Jews from ever controlling it. (Sound familiar?) If they had known of Jerusalem's spiritual stature, they may have tried to take advantage of its spiritual nature by making it into a center of idol worship. Each of the twelve tribes would have desired to have Jerusalem in their borders, and this would lead to disunity. Once the Jews had conquered and divided the land, the above ceased to be considerations. So, in conclusion, Jerusalem played a prominent part in Jewish history and writings more than two thousand years before Islam's rise and the writing of the Koran, which makes no mention of Jerusalem. Now if you read all of this, you should no longer have to put your foot in your mouth.
62. #61 for once agree with your logic
observer ,   Egypt   (08.05.11)
You said "Jerusalem played a prominent part in Jewish history and writings more than two thousand years before Islam's rise." So, older Judaism takes precedence over recent Islam, just like older theft of the land by Muslims takes precedence over recent theft by Jews.
63. you call that logic?
IlanaB   (08.05.11)
no go buddy
64. oh I forgot
IlanaB   (08.05.11)
good try at changing the subject at hand/ point proved-let it rest now
Previous talkbacks
Back to article