Opinion
Abbas’ huge land grab
Dan Calic
Published: 03.11.11, 12:32
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
67 Talkbacks for this article
61. Rabin: No Palestinian State
Linda Rivera ,   New York, USA   (11.05.11)
Background: Rabin's Forgotten Program - No Palestinian State, No Settlement Freeze, Gush Katif as Model, Israeli control of borders * No return to '67 borders [Dr. Aaron Lerner - IMRA 4 November 2011: Once again the Ministry of Foreign Affairs has decided not to include the late Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin's last major policy address among the material it provided in a special page to mark the anniversary of his assassination.
62. #59 Michael, Guarantee just like they
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (11.05.11)
Did when the guaranteed free passage to Israeli ships through the Straits of Tiran & Suez Canal UN packed and left just as soon as Nasser told them to beat it Or the UN monitoring the Lebanon-Israel border, using Pakistani troops, Who allowed Arafat's thugs to place their people & weapons in the midst of Pakistani positions Or after the last war with Lebanon, When the UN was supposed to monitor the flow & prohibit the importation of weapons into Lebanon, Where Hezbollah now has more rockets than it had before the last war Nothing quite like blind faith, it only proves you seen see your nose in front of you
63. ''ISRAEL''
SJOERD RUURD VDV ,   MULTIVERSE   (11.05.11)
UNFORTUNATELY THERE HAS BEEN SINCE 1948 ALSO AN ''ISRAELI'' LAND GRAP AT THE COST OF THE PEOPLE WHO ALREADY LIVED THERE.
64. 63 - SJOERD RUURD VDV
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (11.06.11)
Was and is that Jews lived here 2400 years before the Arabs infiltrated Jews had Kingdoms, a Captial City, and coinage they minted for themselves, Arabs had none of these and still don't One more fact, there is no mention of Palestine or Jerusalem in the Koran, this only proves the infiltrators claim is only of a recent vintage
65. TO NR. 64
SJOERD RUURD VDV ,   MULTIVERSE   (11.06.11)
IN THAT CASE I STAY AT THAT OPINION. THOSE PEOPLE ALSO LIVED THERE FROM THE BEGINNING.
66. BIASED
Ghita ,   Richmond, USA   (11.09.11)
This is very one sided. The fact that you haven't even mentioned that the reason that the Palestinian people didn't accept resolution 181 back in 1947 was because it was already there land. Why should they have to all suddenly have to share a land with complete nonnatives from Europe? It's like Russians coming to a certain part of the US and saying that we have been persecuted against so now we are planning on settling in Washington DC, would the US just step back and agree OF COURSE NOT. There are many parts of your article that are either unfounded or don't even consider the side that Israel is in the wrong. Plenty of Palestinians have had to relocate due to the establishment of an Israeli state but yet you have not mentioned a single thing about that. What about the fact that millions are living in impoverished refugee camps which Israeli government isn't allowing outside supplies of food and medicine to come in. BIASED TO THE EXTREME
67. reply to Ghita
Article author   (11.11.11)
I'm afraid not a single statement in your post is correct. The amount of confirmable evidence to refute your incorrect statements is overwhelming. I would invite you to search my name on the YNET web site and read additional material of mine they have been kind enough to publish, but it appears you aren't the type of person who allows facts to get in the way of your anti-Israel agenda. This is quite typical of Israel's enemies. Apparently a single Jewish state with 20% Arab population and Arab elected officials in the Knesset is unfair to the existing 22 Arab states. Please identify one Arab state which has even 1% Jewish population or elected Jewish representatives in their government.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article