News  Magazine
The medical war on Israel
Giulio Meotti
Published: 25.11.11, 23:57
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
59 Talkbacks for this article
31. History of hurt pride: Israel didn't beg for help
5th generation ,   Israel   (11.26.11)
from NGOs at the beginning, so we missed getting on their sympathy radar. Terrorists always demand handouts, so they will forever be the poster children.
32. # 3
Birdi ,   Israel   (11.26.11)
The word is defamation not difemation!!
33. BOLLOCKS TO THE RED CROSS
URBAN POET ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (11.26.11)
And the horses they rode in on .Curse them.
34. RED CROSS
CHARLIE ,   BOSTON   (11.26.11)
You conveniently forget that the leader of the American Red Cross who recently died fought tooth and nail to get Israel admitted in the ICRC. The bias was at the highest level. I personally saw Arab women coming to Shaarey Tzedek hospital in Jerusalem, but of course you see better than I do from NY,NY.
35. Dan hype&rubbish without substantiation. Typical sloganeer !
PETER SM ,   MELBOURNE   (11.26.11)
Care to explain why help for Africa is so much less than for Arabs ? Why Israelis saving Arab lives is not newsworthy?
36. Dan #20 truthful article
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (11.26.11)
'fails to mention is the hundreds of Palestinian women who had to deliver their babies at checkpoints some of whom died there' because it is an Arab lie. The total number is ZERO. 'the army protecting settlers while they are torturing palestininan children' Another lie - you must be some sort of racist to repeat these lies. 'he Israeli prisons's master schemes of torture that is hard to prove' The same 'Red Cross' you are defending states the exact opposite. 'the prisoners' deprivation of basic medical care' That is why they get BETTER medical care than American civilians right? Yes the list goes on forever from anti-Semites inventing their stupid lies. The 'Palestinians' have a LOWER child birth death rate than the UNITED STATES OF AMERICAN thanks to Israeli medical care. They also have a LONGER LIFE SPAN than AMERICANS again thanks to our care. Perhaps America should learn from us because you are far behind us in medical care even for our non-citizen Jordanian colonists.
37. to Dan at #20
Arn ,   Yehud, Israel   (11.26.11)
You are too kind to the Zionists. Not hundreds but thousands - perhaps tens of thousands - of Palestinian women are forced to give birth at checkpoints. That's the only true purpose of the checkpoints. And hundreds possibly thousands of our holy virgins died there. You write about "the Israeli prisons's master schemes of torture that is hard to prove", So true. Recall the hero Kuntar who was released from an Israeli prison 100 pounds heavier than when he was caught. They force fed him steak and meat pie in the hope of eventually using his liver as a pate. Trust only Hamas for your info. Would they lie to you?
38. Dan #20 proves a sucker born every minute
Brian Cohen ,   Judean Peoples Front   (11.26.11)
Hundreds of Pal women who delivered at checkpoints? Hundreds? Wow, Danny boy, I'd love to see you pull up the facts to prove that big Palestinian propaganda lie. The IDF torturing Pal children? Wow, you must have years of documentation and thousands of cases. And deprivation of basic medical care in Israeli prisons? Let's see, Danny boy, those same prisons that give these murdering scumbags university degrees at my tax expense? The only expectation we have is that Palestinian propaganda suckers in those unable to do their own research - and you prove their point. The ICRC is indeed a racist organization that for decades barred Israel's national rescue service from full membership, because it was controlled by racist Christian and Islamic organizations. B&B were right, Dan. You're just another sucker for Pal propaganda.
39. Cross is not christian, any more than star is haredi
James ,   Netherlands   (11.26.11)
The cross does not mean its representatives are dedicated christians, any more than the star implies that the MDA represents orthodox Jews. Moreover, anyone should distinguish between A. Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churces, which are often hostile to Jews; and B. protestant and evangelical churches, who are often friendly to Jews, except if they have renounced the authority of the Bible and have become liberal and leftist.
40. how much
bill ,   uk   (11.26.11)
does meotti get paid to write this drivel
41. It's true...but it doesn't matter....
GR ,   London   (11.26.11)
Good for Israel for treating all medical cases - and shame on the Red Cross for its bias.... ....but ultimately,....it doesn't matter what they say. Israel should keep doing the right thing no matter what....let the ignorant talk and talk, we'll get on with saving lives....one day the truth will come out. Take care all....
42. So why let hostile "medical" NGOs into Israel.
Chaim ,   Israel   (11.26.11)
First step is to identify the enemy. Clearly so called medical NGOs like the Red Cross are our enemies. The next step is to treat them like the enemies they are. So why let them into Israel?
43. ICRCRC
Jake in Jerusalem ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (11.26.11)
The official name of the Red Cross is and has been the International Committee of the Red Cross and Red Crescent. The Israeli Red Star of David was denied membership in the ICRCRC for decades because the ICRCRC wouldn't allow "religious symbols" - unless, obviously, they were a cross or crescent. I have for decades refused to donate to the Red Cross (and let's call it what it is: the ICRCRC) for their officially antisemitic policies. They haven't really changed...
44. #30 - Daoud
Jake in Jerusalem ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (11.26.11)
Stick with the facts, please. If you have a complaint about something factual, be specific. Otherwise, you are just spouting more "Palestinian" propaganda... which is what the article was about in the first place!!!
45. Desse A Verdade #22 not World War 2
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (11.26.11)
But nearly 2,000 years of genocide. From the Crusaders - to Spain, etc. Christianity has murdered millions and millions of Jews, stolen their property which to this day is still being held by the Pope. You want us to forgive you - then start by stopping your continual attacks, and support of terrorism against us and return our property.
46. Can you be specific?
Cobi ,   Ashkelon, Israel   (11.26.11)
Which are facts, propaganda, falacies and nonesense? Write an intelligent rebuttal if you have access to this data.
47. Israeli healthcare
Joe   (11.26.11)
Medecins sans frontieres, the red cross, Amnesty int'l, human rights watch,represent the scum of health care. Shame on the Israeli Govt for not throwing this garbage out of the country.
48. Steve benassi. USA
Walt K ,   Sherbrooke, Canada   (11.26.11)
Find me one death camp in Israel ; show me a work camp ; and I would give you right, but you are comparing apples with bananas.
49. Praise God!
Diane ,   USA   (11.26.11)
The world has much to be thankful for, including the compassion Israel shows for her enemies. The world is blind as evil permeates this world, but I will praise God for Israel!
50. Red Cross Does Not Deserve Donations
Linda Richards ,   Colorado Springs, US   (11.27.11)
This is just one of the myriad reasons I do not and will not donate one cent to the Red Cross. They could feed millions of needy people with their CEO's annual salary. Add that to their anti-semitism and dishonesty. There are many charitable organizations that are more deserving of our hard-earned money.
51. charge anti-israel organizations fees
david ,   new york   (11.27.11)
a non-governmental organization organization that does not recognize israel with jerusalem as its capital should be charged a "usage" fee for operating in israel or the west bank. perhaps 100K per year for every employee. the money should go to victims of terror.
52. #25 - Jews didn't try to exterminate Germans
William ,   Israel   (11.27.11)
but "Palestinians" did try to exterminate Jews, and state it as their goal to this day. "Palestinians" fire rockets into civilian centers, the ICRC themselves admitted "Palestinians" have committed war crimes, and the UN admits now the Gaza blockade is perfectly legal.... yet, the "Palestinian" Red Crescent is a full-member of the ICRC. Please explain that...neutrality?
53. Red Cross
Marilyn ,   USA   (11.27.11)
Actually I think that people overthink things such as an emblem. It's more like the swiss flag with the colors reversed. However the founder of the red cross was a Swiss Christian who saw a war and reacted to it.
54. The Cross
Thomas ,   Los Angeles, USA   (11.27.11)
To think that anybody would attempt to liken the image of the cross to that of a swastika is beyond comprehension. To add insult to injury, you assert the evil perpetrated on the Jews by Nazi's is equivalent to Christian treatment of the Jews, which I'm sure you contend are one in the same. The reality is the Nazi's were not acting on Christian beliefs or doctrine. They were not Christian's, they were terrorists who murdered innocent people...Christian's and Jews alike. Christian's around the world support Israel and let's not forget the USA's role in Israel's history May 14, 1948.
55. Medicins du Monde, Medicins sans Frontiers, ICRC, .....
chantalle.ezer ,   Frankfurt Germany   (11.27.11)
MDM, MSF are the organisations with the most obvious anti-Jewish and anti-Israel agendas. They claim that violence is solely executed from Jewish settlers. They also insist that Jewish medical staff is only treating/helping Jews. MDM is funded by the French government. ICRC was, is and will always be anti-Israel and anti-Jewish. C.Ezer
56. Origin of red cross
Marilyn ,   USA   (11.27.11)
Going back to the origin of the red cross, this would have been horrifying for him to see the after effects of the war. During the war, people slayed and wounded each other without mercy in a massively bloody fashion. And it was said that the horses were much more compassionate than the people involved because they tried not to step on the wounded victims. Not even the leaders had control of the war anymore, it had developed a life of it's own, as wars always do. So after coming accross this massively bloody scene, he helped the victims. He was able to organize the townspeople and he put up money and convinced the people that it didn't matter who was on what side, because all are brothers. He continued on with the general idea. In later life though, he kind of was shunned and poverty stricken as often happens. With the nobel peace prize it was somewhat controversial because people were unsure of the idea of cleaning up after a war instead of leaving it in it's natural state, because they were worried that war might be more attractive that way. So it was divided between him and a man named Passy, a pacifist.
57. Red Cross & Red Crescent antisemitism
watsa46 ,   NY, US   (12.11.11)
It is easy to find out who subsidize these infamous organizations.
58. Red Cross & Red Crescent, MDA
watsa46n ,   NY, US   (12.11.11)
The good Jews of the world have work to do till eternity. The world is full of bad people. Tikkun olam all over.
59. Red Cross sucks
Hilda ,   USA   (01.07.12)
The Red Cross was not even good to the US servicemen in WW2. My dad served in the US Navy and used to tell us that The Red Cross always charged the men for even a cup of coffee so they used to go to the Salvation Army which welvcomed them with open arms and treted them like the heroes they were. My dad and we after him do not donate anything to the Red Cross even though they do good at times. Even when they are praised for helping folks who lost everything in fires they get reimbursed by the Welfare Depts. I know b ecause I as the caseworker for the Dept. was often the one who had to write out the request for reimbursement.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article