Opinion
Arabs scared of the truth
Nizar Amer
Published: 03.12.11, 10:06
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
57 Talkbacks for this article
31. #26: Everything you wrote is a filthy lie
Korem ,   NYC   (12.04.11)
I did my research, you haven't. First of all, try telling all the white people of the US that they are Jewish and let's see how they react. Second, genetic tests have proved that the modern European Jew is more connected to Middle Eastern Jews, each other, and even African Jews more than any of the host populations they resided in (like European whites). As a group, Jews are most similar to Palestinians and other Middle Eastern people. Everything you said is a filthy lie to justify your blind hatred of Jews, but if you actually did the research you tell others to do, you'd realize your arguments stand on nothing.
32. SALMA TRY AND BE HONEST WITH YOURSELF
zionist forever   (12.04.11)
Salma Your reply only goes to justify the claims made in the article. True the Jewish fighters were not angels and some arabs were expelled by them but the fact is that most arabs left without ever seeing a Jewish fighter. Some left on the advice of the invading arab armies thinking they were going to be coming home in a couple of weeks after the Jews were all dead and then they could share in the spoils of war. Others left out of free choice again planning to come back when the war was over as was the custom at the time in small arab communities. The problem is things didn't go to plan and the arabs lost the war they started after they refused partition. If your going to be HONEST with yourself Salma do you really think if the roles had been reversed and the arabs won the war they would have welcomed the Jews back with open arms? The arabs & Jews in Palestine had been fighting each other for a long tiime and the arabs had even been trying to keep Jews out of Palestine through pressure on the British. We were not best buddies before the war and we wouldn't have liked each other anymore afterwards if the arabs had won it. The Jews were the enemy of the arabs and the arabs were the enemies of the Jews and there was no peace process in the works. Stop living in denial Salma the arabs are their own worst enemy and always have been you just blame all your problems on Israel because its easier to use Israel as a scapegoat than it is to look at yourself and say I screwed up.
33. "No such thing as Palestinian people"
Beth Goodtree ,   NYC, USA   (12.04.11)
"THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS THE PALESTINIAN PEOPLE. IT IS JUST AN ARAB TACTIC FOR THE DESTRUCTION OF ISRAEL!" Zahir Muhsein, Palestinian General in a 1977 interview with the Dutch newspaper Trouw. Also, historically, the Arab "Palestian' people didn't even exist as a group before the early 1960s. It was a complete fabrication by Yasser Arafat and his cohorts. You will never read any reference to them in either textbooks or newspapers before the early to mid-1960s. However, before that time, Jews were frequently referred to as Palestinians. Meanwhile, a written history of the Jews, supported by thousands (if not millions) of archeological finds and written documents including both the Old and New Testaments proves the fact that Jews have been the indigenous people going back thousands of years. A prime example is Jesus Christ, who was a Jew living in Palestine over 2000 years ago. To believe the blatant lie that the Arabs are the aboriginal people of Palestine is to deny Christ and the Christian Bible. The people who falsely call themselves 'Palestinian' in a vain attempt to steal not just land but history are actually Jordanians whose own country doesn't want to let them back in. Why? Because they have always been known to be troublemakers and the Hashemite (Saudi) king of Jordan knows that if he lets them back in to their aboriginal country, they'll kick him out -- or worse -- the second they return. All of the above is easily verifiable fact.
34. Eric: settlements are not the problem
Kyle ,   Southpark, CO, USA   (12.04.11)
Israel removed every last settlement in Gaza, how well did that work out?
35. @26 ROFL
Hakim ,   Egypt   (12.04.11)
Ahmad, read what you posted! you sound like a fool. Ihope people don't judge the inteligence of all egyptian based on you ignorant statements. The pilgrims who came to america were puritans(christians), as any 10 year old child could tell you. People like Ahmad beleive America name the Turkey after Turkey to insult Muslims. Please please please Ahmad read a book other than the Quran. COPTIC PRIDE and UMMAT Yizraeeli Khaya oh btw Ahmad El-Haus Tizzi
36. #26 which planet do you live on
Vered ,   Canada   (12.04.11)
Now the Jews are to blame for conquering America? Then all Americans should be Jewish. Why not blame the Jews for the great depression, sept 11, the last recession. Oh sorry been done already. All I want to know is what are you smoking in Egypt. Must make you hallucinate! share some with Salma and Steve.
37. To #26, Ahmad
American ,   Los Angeles, CA   (12.04.11)
"You just can't make something the truth and it is not, plain and simple" The colonizers of America were Puritans who separated from the Church of England to settle on Plymouth Rock, Massachusetts. They most certainly were NOT Jews. Jews came en masse with all the other European immigrants between 1880 and 1930 when America's population grew exponentially. As for Jewish connection to the middle east, it's been well documented for thousands of years. The Jews in Europe existed there as part of the diaspora as they fled one country to another after getting kicked out of Israel. Who do YOU think built Jerusalem?
38. 26 is joking
Kevin ,   Joburg   (12.04.11)
The whole islamic religion is based on the validity of the jewish story just like christianity. You like to wipe out our history to deligitimise israel but look at your religion, it hasn't made any progress for the last 800 years! Mohammed learned everything he knew from jews. You need to be thanking us! We were labeled semitic by the europeans hundreds of years ago and now we in our land the arabs label us european.
39. There will NEVER be peace
Shira   (12.04.11)
As long as the arabs have a tribal, patriarchial, Mysogenstic mentality. People who kill their women in the name of " honor", rape young girls ( oh, sorry "wives" ) and beat the crap out of them and cover them in the name of submittion... People who treat women worse then they would an animal... These people are not capable of peace! They are EVIL !!!
40. Your writings confirm the article...
@9 Salma ,   Caesarea   (12.04.11)
41. Islam a Threat to World peace
Tom , ,   Lagos,Nigeria   (12.04.11)
The sooner the west and the civilize world realize it the better, the world must resist radical islam and pressure islamic governments to abandon and suppress or reform radical islam.
42. Radical Islam the New Nazis
Tom , ,   Lagos,Nigeria   (12.04.11)
Radical islamic are the new nazis, the want to force the whole world to obey thier ideas,
43. Re #26 - Thank you Hakim (#36)
Clear Thinker ,   Haifa, Israel   (12.04.11)
44. A hopefully less angry comment... :)
rindd ,   us   (12.04.11)
My advice: Take to the time to research in detail and see that both sides have committed rights and wrongs, while some things were simply out of their hands and some issues have escalated to such complex points that the current generation now faces huge challenges and obstacles. Many of the talkback-ers on this site seem to be trying the choose "the right side" ("right" as in morally right, NOT as in right-wing) while it would be more productive to support a realistic solution, no matter who you sympathize with more. For example: You may not like settlements - - but most Israelis aren't settlers. You can be against settlements without hating Israelis or assuming they're all unreasonable (or worse). Don't get stuck in the past trying to pick sides while the Israeli and Palestinian people are long past that point and are even divided amongst themselves. Don't fall into a Hollywood hero vs villain mentality, although it can be tempting. Some politicians and reporters get stuck in this mode, especially foreign ones, and it's not particularly helpful.....
45. Great article, make it into a youtube speech...
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (12.04.11)
...and translate into all major languages please.
46. You are the blind racist
Sam ,   Boca raton fl USA   (12.04.11)
Israel did no such thing the British left willingly and when Israel declared independence every single sorounding country invaded them the Palestinians lest willingly because they were told by the Arab country's to leave and after the Arab states exterminate Israel they can just move back in get educated don't just spew your hate
47. Brown nosing will not do.
Avi ,   NYC, USA   (12.05.11)
Mr. Amer may be promoted in the Israeli Foreign Service because of this slavish article. But can he buy a house in a "Jews only" village? Can he join a kibbutz?
48. Author is delusional
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (12.05.11)
The only reason that Fatah is not launching rockets at our civilians is because we won't let them. Not because they have any great difference in ideology between them, Hamas or the Nazis.
49. AWESOME POINTS #38
Nick Sporek ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (12.05.11)
50. Steve/Salma Read Mark Twain
Sharona ,   JerusalemIsrael   (12.05.11)
Innocents Abroad-The land of Israel was barren and desolate when he arrived here in 1867. And he was no Jew lover. The Turkish census in 1861 showed 45,000 Jews, 8000 Christians and 8000 Muslims in Jerusalem. Get your facts straight. More than 50% of Israel's population fled from Arab lands not Europe. There were more Jewish than Arab refugees in 1948 and aftermath. Arabs were told to flee by other Arabs!!
51. Watch Pat Condell's "Great Palestinian Lie" & latest entry
Eduardo Larriva ,   NYC,USA   (12.05.11)
His latest entry/commentary on that online video service that everyone uses that rhymes with "blue - boob" is amazing, considering it is coming from a brit who NOW sees the truth! It is called "Useful idiots for Palestine"
52. BIG ISRAEL only way to save Islam from Islamists.
Jerry ,   The Netherlands   (12.05.11)
53. T9 and 5#
Ruben Jacobi ,   UK   (12.05.11)
Israel did.nt do a very good job of throwing the Arabs out,there are still 1.5 million left living in a democracy of which the majority would,nt be to happy in giving up their Israeli citizenship.My people solvedthe problem of what to do with the800000 thrown out of the Arab land with one small suitcase. Your mainly uneducated people should follow our examples of love an compassion instead your hatred and bitterness.
54. To Ahmad #26#
Ruben Jacobi ,   UK   (12.05.11)
You obviously are very fond of Fairy Tales.I can recommend very strongly you read the works of Hans Christian Anderson,much nicer than the ones you have been reading.
55. # 9 the Would-be-lady herself!
Moragh   (12.05.11)
then may I suggest, your haughtyness to pack up and return to your "burning waterless sands".
56. Ahmad #26
D. Dagan ,   Savannah. GA   (12.06.11)
come and visit, the "persecuted" Israeli Arabs and Druze. You will surely chage your mind. They are FAR better off than 95% of Egyptians, or "Palestinian Arabs" and probably other citizen of other arab Countries.
57. questions of reality
alef ,   montreal,canada   (12.13.11)
Salma, it is time you did some serious historical research.Jews did not expel 700000 arabs{who incidently were not identified as palestinians,nor did they have any distinctive culture to differentiate them from other muslims/arabs.Most left encouraged by invading Arab armies with the promise to kill all the Jews. Arabs in Palestine hoped to benefit from this "Hollocust". What an "human instinct"!Secondly, the so-called Palestinian, creation of the Arab mind, never ruled themselves,and still perceived themselves as part of Greater Syria.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article