Opinion
End of Arab Christianity
Giulio Meotti
Published: 05.01.12, 11:21
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
121 Talkbacks for this article
61. #43 daoud
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.06.12)
I am happy you do not feel persecuted. But read about what is happening in Gaza, Egypt, Lebanon, etc. If you want the truth you must look for it, as your 'truth' is local only. Also, ask your Christian friends. Don't assume you know what they are thinking.
62. #1 michael, #7 elias, #14 abdullah
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.06.12)
Sad to see how tightly you close your eyes in order not to see the truth. Look at the numbers; they don't lie. The war IS about religion, mostly Islam. It is the true fomentor of violence, hatred and chaos. A shame #7 that you can't see who your real enemies are. And I have never heard anyone (except #1) state it is 'politics'. Open your eyes.
63. #58. What? I never claimed to and I stand for Israel as well
(01.06.12)
So I'm not sure what you're talking about.
64. #58. What? I never claimed to and I also stand for Israel...
Henry from New York ,   USA   (01.06.12)
So I am not sure what you are talking about. Are you taking offense to my comment at 52? It's a perfectly logical argument to respond to someone saying there is no God. I never said I don't believe in God though, as I do.
65. #56 You are hardly the voice of Christians in the Mid East
Tahl   (01.06.12)
So many distortions and lies in your posts, I don't even know where to begin, although Sarah at #54 summed it up nicely. To find the truth about Muslim treatment of Christians in the Middle East, you can look up the lectures of Brigitte Gabriel, a Christian Maronite from Lebanon, on youtube.
66. Islam and Justice?
Lenya ,   Melbourne   (01.06.12)
Please dont make me laugh.....Muslim and Justice together produce vile vomit. Islam equals: Injustice for females Injustice for males Injustice for education Injustice for civilization Injustice for children Injustice for every good thing on this planet.
67. Come Again?
Lenya ,   Melbourne, Australia   (01.06.12)
Every Lebanese leader that was Christian was assassinated by Muslims. COME AGAIN?
68. #3
Vivian Clayborn ,   Copenhagen   (01.06.12)
Have you forgotten "Palestinian" Christian's terrorism against Israel, PFLP
69. #7 aliyas
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.06.12)
Where have you been, Muslim's are killing Christian's while they're praying in Church, try paying attention to the media It is high time that you realized, in the Muslim view you are a mere "Dhimmi", a person of a far lesser value You may dress like a Muslim, speak the same language, the difference is that you have one god they have another who reviles you and hates your very guts You have another delusion, there is no Palestine,,never has been The land you called Palestine was ruled by Romans, Otttoman Turks & British,never by any so-called Palestinian's
70. #14 Yup!
Edwin ,   Canada   (01.06.12)
You are right. I have sampled that religious freedom in Saudi Arabia. Yup, justice reigns supreme alright.
71. Ah!, the good old days of jesus,gone forever
Paul   (01.06.12)
While christians are being slaughtered like sheeps, the Pope. wrapped in gold head to toe, is parading around the world.Modern christianity at his best.
72. What are you talking about, #12?
Jasmin ,   Haifa   (01.06.12)
Who invaded Iraq? Surely not Israel. The US *did* invade Iraq, but you must be aware that this is an Israeli news outlet. Please explain what you mean.
73. Obada #51
Abie Dee ,   New York, US   (01.06.12)
You talk nonsense...these 'attempts to cleanse Israel of anybody other than Jews" is failing miserably...the Arab population and other minorities is increasing NOT decreasing. Israel is either doing a really bad job at it or you are just full of crap...personally, i think it's the latter. I believe it was a Palestinian leader who recently said that Jews would not be welcome in Palestine. If you had a brain you'd realize immediately who the real racists are.
74. #56
Rachel   (01.06.12)
You talk about George Habash and Naytef Hawarth like their your heroes. The former was the founder of the PFLP who was responsible for airline hijackings of the late 60s, and the Achille Lauro ship Hijacking where an elderly wheelchair bound American Jew was brutally murdered and thrown overboard,as well as many other horrific terrorist attacks. The latter was responsible for the Maalot school shooting,where a family of 5,and 25 innocent schoolchildren where gunned down in coldblood. Real Christians are not full of hate, and certainly do not support murder of innocents,but it sounds like you do.
75. #65 Tahl
PalestinianChristian   (01.06.12)
On the contrary, my words represent the view of the majority of Christians in the Mid East. Brigitte Gabriel is in the tiny minority, the same minority that Meotti is probably getting his garbage from.
76. To ALL PALESTINIAN CHRISTIANS
Netanya ,   Netanya   (01.06.12)
Seems that you all are lacking knowledge, when the Muslims are faced with all the deaths in the name of Islam, they talk about how the Christians are worse, due to the Crusades. It is irrelevant that the Crusades only occurred after Islam had captured over 2/3rds of christian Europe. The Muslims are clear that they believe all of this land to be Muslim territory, Cordoba is their own land (or so they say) and they plan to take it all back. They will not welcome Christians,so open your eyes to the truth! History was written prior to this article and cannot be rewritten in this ynet comments section. Most Middle East countries have already changed churches to mosques or destroyed them! This is just fact!
77. #19
Jonathan ,   MN/US   (01.06.12)
the same could be said of any religion
78. This Article is True
Jessi ,   Salmiya, Kuwait   (01.06.12)
This is yet another article written about the persecution of Christians & the threat of their "instinction" in the Middle East that I have read. I first heard of this in the Arab Times, a Kuwait publication. Now check this out, here is a link to a list of countries with the worst Christian persecution around the world. Out of 50 countries, 38 are Muslim: http://www.opendoorsusa.org/persecution/country-profiles/ However, Christians may be like sheep led to the slaughter- just like Jesus said, but Jesus also said that in the end, WE get the victory.
79. Oh & I forgot...
Jessi ,   Salmiya, Kuwait   (01.06.12)
This article was kind of a wake-up call for me in that I did not realize at all that there were Arab Christians who were anti-semitic. I'm American. I disagree with any Christian who is anti-semitic because of the love God has for his chosen people. If they hate, it is because they have been brainwashed rather than washed by the Spirit of truth. To all Jews who have experienced hate from Christians, I'm SO sorry- that's NOT what Christianity is about. To all Arab Christians reading this- remember that we are SUPPOSED to love our neighbor! Even if they're Jewish and you're Palestinian!
80. #12 palestinian
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.06.12)
The PLO and Israel imposed the civil war on Lebanon?! The PLO, yes. Israel, no. The civil war began years before Israel invaded in order to stop attacks on Israelis. You Lebanese did it to yourselves. And this is just one of many points in your post that are wrong.
81. #75 palestinian
solomon ,   bklyn   (01.06.12)
I suggest you read news reports instead of relying on what you want to believe. Christians are leaving because of the justifiable fear of Islam. They are being attacked while they pray, during funerals of people killed by Muslims and during demonstrations against the attacks and killings. Even the Christian churches recognize this. If they can leave for Europe or the US, they do so. If they can't, they go to Israel, the only place in the ME they can practice their religion without fear. In Israel they find themselves among other Christians of many different sects (including Copts, Armenians, Ethiopians, etc.), Jews, Moslems, Druse, Bahai, etc.
82. MEOTTI: STOP FISHING IN TROUBLED WATERS!
Rafi ,   US   (01.06.12)
Stay out of other peoples' troubles... we have enough of our own.
83. To: No. 56
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (01.06.12)
Who was it that massacred Maronite Christians in South Lebanon until Israel saved the Lebanese Christians from extinction? Hmm? Wasn't it Moslems? Ersatz "Palestinian" ones? I wonder if the survivors of the massacres feel as strongly as do you about draping a PLO flag over a crucifix. I'm inclined to think that they do not. Please cite and document the expulsions of ersatz "Palestinian" Christians from their homes which you allege and which I know never happened. Oh -- legitimate sources only, please.
84. #71, Pope is Catholic not Christian.
will ,   WA, USA   (01.06.12)
Fundamental Christians, those that believe that Jesus is the only way, are the ones that are slaughtered. It is really too bad that there is a common misconception (read lie/deception) that Catholicism is Christianity. That's what you get for Modern popular belief/media. This fact stands out very clearly in Fox's book of martyrs where the Catholic church executed anyone preaching Jesus's priesthood instead of Catholic priesthood. Looks like there will need to be a new Fox's book of martyrs to catalog all the Christian suffering at Islam's hand.
85. I had posted a list of Christian problems
BEN JABO ,   ISRAEL   (01.06.12)
in the area,Y net must have thought it was too extensive, they didn't publish it However, you can do exactly as I did, GOOGLE "Christian problems caused by Muslims" you have a lot to learn if you'll only open your ears and minds to the facts
86. The Religion of Peace
LJ ,   WA, USA   (01.06.12)
This has been going on since the Mohammedans wiped out most of Coptic Christianity in the 1st jihad. They're just finishing up and with Western help inadvertently. Many good books out there on this and other subjects by Walid Shoebat, Joel Richarson, Ellis Skolfied and others.
87. #3 - the Christians themselves demanded it
William ,   Israel   (01.06.12)
They considered themselves "Palestinians" first, then Christians afterwards....and were anti-Israel. Even after PLO Muslims created false land deeds and stole land from Christians, they still remained pro-"Palestinian". Don't blame Israel. We can't save Arabs from themselves, we only have responsibility for our own citizens, and did very well in protecting the Plaza in Nazareth from the Israeli Arab usurpers who wanted to steal it from the Christians there.
88. #7 - it wasn't Israel who took over the Bethlehem grotto
William ,   Israel   (01.06.12)
It was Arab Muslim terrorists. It wasn't Israel who attacked Christians in Gaza and burnt schools and book shops. It was Gazan Islamists. It wasn't Israel who tried to take over the Holy Sepluchar and mock Christians on the Via Delarosa. It was MUSLIMS! Israel, time and again, protected Christians in the area, protected their holy places, and ensured freedom of worship. As "Palestinian" Christians who ran from the region why. They won't say Israel.
89. #12 - get your facts straight
William ,   Israel   (01.06.12)
Israel never imposed a civil war in Lebanon. That was a sectarian war which we had nothing to do with. Israel wouldn't have even looked at Lebanon if the PLO didn't arrive there and begin launching terrorists attacks on us. It was Arafat who carved out his own autonomous region for the PLO, abusing the Lebanese people while he was at it. Ever wonder why "Palestinians" are treated like second-class bastard children in Lebanon? Perhaps you need to go further back in history where Christians were persecuted by Muslims for 1000 years, not just in the past 30 years. Many Jews and Christians were forcibly converted in the 7th-10th centuries from the invading Muslim hordes of the Peninsula. Never forget that.
90. #14 - justice for whom?
William ,   Israel   (01.06.12)
Under Islam, people are protected but not as equal citizens. Let's look at every place where "Islam reigns supreme": Somalia, Nigeria, Sudan, Lebanon, Iraq, Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Libya, Algeria, Chechnya, Iran, and the list goes on... and how are minorities fairing their? Not well amid the massive violence perpetrated in the name of Allah. So your statement really means - only if Islam is fully accepted, allowed to reign fully even in place of other cultures and religions, and non-Muslims pay both a tax and accept Islamic dictates, will there be peace. Well sure - every despotic ideology has that claim. However, in Israel, where Islam does NOT reign, is there freedom and equality for all religions, is there a place for B'hais to exist freely without persecution, is there true justice and a means to achieve it via a mature court system. In Jordan, the only "justice" is that which the King allows, or that occurs at the hands of racist soccer fans.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article