Opinion
West should strike Syria
Merav Betito
Published: 08.02.12, 12:08
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
41 Talkbacks for this article
1. How you dare
Ariel ,   São Paulo - Brazil   (02.08.12)
to compare Auschwitz to Syria????? Go and learn what was Auschwitz and then apologise to all of us
2. Learn first about the holocaust
Jorge ,   USA   (02.08.12)
This is one of the worst articles I've seen. Comparin Syria with the Holocaust is completely stupid and non-sense. If we go by this "logic" how many holocaust have the world seen since the end of WWII..... 15-20?
3. Obscene
Avinoam ,   NY, USA   (02.08.12)
How can a 'teacher' be so superficial and simple-minded? Say what you want about Syria on it's own terms. The Auschwitz comparison is foul.
4. Syria is not Auschwitz!!!!
Rachel ,   US   (02.08.12)
5. There are no clear options in Syria
Raymond in DC ,   Washington, USA   (02.08.12)
The author would have "West" do as it did in Libya - strike Syria. But consider the results in Libya. Yes, Qaddafi was evil but he was constrained. He'd surrendered his nuclear project (something Syria has yet to do), but not yet his chemical weapons or ManPADs. So NATO - with support only from Qatar though the Arab League was pushing intervention - drove him out. And who has taken his place? Islamists. Now look at Syria. Yes, the regime has much (if not most) of the populace against it. But who is waiting to take its place? Islamists. Only this time they'll take over Syria's chemical weapons, missiles, and nuclear project.
6. One is not to interrupt when something good is happening!
tom ,   tel aviv   (02.08.12)
7. So you want us to......
James ,   Raleigh US   (02.08.12)
...stay in Afghanistan, go back to Iraq, fix Yemen, go after Iran, clean up Lybia and now go after Syria? I am all for Israel going after her enemies who want to destroy her, but we can't keep sending US troops all over the world. As much as I want the US to stand by Israel, we can't do it all at once.
8. betito is out of his miind
marcel   (02.08.12)
the worst thing to do is to get boots in the ground in an arab uprising. betito is an ignoramus like olmert and livni. let arab countries arm the syrian people againt assad whose wife is living in denial at her husband's iranian brutality.
9. Funny, Jews Trying To Protect Muslims That Want Them Gassed
David H ,   Marietta USA   (02.08.12)
Or worse. Well, the West made a mistake protecting the Muslims during the wars in Croatia and the former Yugoslavia. That sure helped the world a lot! I say let the Syrians do their thing, just make sure they don't go nuclear, and keep you nose out of it until it's over. Syria truly deserves Bashar al-Assad M.D., the butcher and rightful heir of Dr Mengele.
10. And if a strike by the "west" leads to chaos?
Tom ,   PA   (02.08.12)
Then what, Mr. Armchair warrior? It's easy to get into wars, often impossible to get out of them. And your bringing up the Holocaust is beyond contempt. What a silly, horrible article.
11. Unbelievably bad article
AJ ,   Raalte   (02.08.12)
This must be one of the worst articles I've ever read on Y-net. If you really had to compare the Holocaust to any other atrocity, why not chose the 1994 genocide in Rwanda where the Hutus slaughtered almost a MILLION Tutsis in 100 days, nazi-style. This low-level civil war in Syria doesn't even come close.
12. At the same time we will strike Iran!
Mark ,   Jerusalem   (02.08.12)
13. I am with Putin , China on Syria
USA   (02.08.12)
I am also with republican presidential candidate Ron Paul on Syria. It's non of our business. Let Egypt and Saudi Arabia handle Assad.
14. WHAT UTTER NONSENSE
LAWRENCE BADEN FOUL ,   SAFED ISRAEL   (02.08.12)
Merav Betito is totally detached from reality.What is occuring in Syria is no big dea;l, it is merely a domestic argument with a few hundred victims .An internal power struggle ,a civil affair.Ms. Betito is woefully ignorant is she dares to call this a Holocaust.
15. Here we go again
Human ,   Australia   (02.08.12)
with Holocaust to drum up more war. Cue the violins..........
16. Stop treating Auschwitz as though it is holy
Aharon   (02.08.12)
I'm appalled by all these commentators whining about the article's comparison with Auschwitz. Auschwitz is not some holy place that we're forbidden to mention. The author wasn't saying that the killing was occurring on the same scale - he was making the perfectly reasonable point that the world did nothing to stop the massacre of Jews, and is doing nothing to stop the massacre of Syrians by their own regime. We're all human beings first - some of you would do well to remember that.
17. What's the problem ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (02.08.12)
I prefer a assad above islamists . Look what happens in Egypt , there a dictator was ousted , great said the world . And now ? replaced by extremist islamists . Is this better ?
18. The West Won't Strike.
manicdrummer ,   Galilee, Israel   (02.08.12)
The US won't lift a finger. they've got too much riding on a secret deal with OPEC, in which they'll get cheap crude oil for kissing off Israel altogether. The US is in crisis and cheap oil would certainly make things easier for them...not to say that The Lord won't throw a wrench in their plans. Anything that jeopardizes Israeli national security will be sure to get a response.
19. BIG DIFFERENCE : (
Robert ,   Farmington,wv   (02.08.12)
Big difference , in what happened in Auschwitz , then whats going on in Syria. The people that was lead or taken to Auschwitz had no warning what was in store for them and was given no way to defend themselves. Now my heart does bleeds for the Syrian people that are being murder , but I'm sure if war would break out between Israel and Syria most of them would be saying death to Israel. once again my heart bleeds for them , but lets not forget who they are.
20. SILENCE FROM RICHARD THE TURD
LAWRENCE OF ARABIA ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (02.08.12)
Total silence from Richard the Turd a.k.a. Goldstone .
21. BETITO HAS IT BACKWARDS
LAWRENCE OF ARABIA ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (02.08.12)
It is Syria ,Libya etc which should strike the interfering ,bullying evil and arrogant west. Does Betito not understand that after the west strike Syria the west will one day strike Israel ??
22. How this Merav dares to compare Syria with Auschwitz ?!
Against again   (02.08.12)
Stop to talk about the Shoah for everything ! There is ONLY one Auschwitz ! Syrians are a people who wants the destruction of Israel. So I don' t care about their fate
23. Your Op-Ed
vmdeeb ,   Somewhere USA   (02.08.12)
Does any sane person read the war-mongering garbage that is the stable of Zionist / Jewish propaganda. If the west did bomb Syria, what guarantee do you have about the replacement, Iran is correct in its assessment of the Zionist / Israeli war mongers
24. I do not agree
mike cato ,   USA   (02.08.12)
My belief is that from Israel's point of view, what will follow Assad will be much worse than it is now. In this part of the Arab/Muslim world,events go in only one direction--from bad to worse.
25. self-serving lies
fed up   (02.08.12)
the author is so divorced from the current feeling in the USA that he could be from Mars. One more war for Israel ( oh sorry, humanitarian intervention....pfft ) and Americans will explode and drive organised Jewry out of their land. This is the most deceitful self-serving load of garbage I ever read. Since when do Israelis care one whit about Arabs? Secondly the author seems to think the west has a right to invade any country it likes. Where did he get that idea from? Oh, I remember , it was from neo-cons like Wolfowitz and his friends who got the USA to invade Iraq. The allies failed to stop the Holocaust? Wrong! The allies stopped it by invading Germany and winning the war, at considerable loss of life among their soldiers. Your whining about rail roads is an appalling insult to those soldiers. Ynet must publish a full apology for this outrageous slander which is deeply hurtful to millions of people around the world who lost family members who served in allied armies. Shame on you.
26. Ain't losin' no sleep over it
Cameron ,   USA   (02.08.12)
Fed up with having to save these Muslim duffers from themselves. If barbarians need to rage & tear amongst one another, then they must be left alone to do so. One does not stick an arm in the middle of a dog fight.
27. #25 TAKE A HIKE MORON
LAWRENCE BADEN FOUL ,   SAFED OPERA HOUSE   (02.08.12)
You sorely need psychiatric help ,LOSER.
28. antisemitism
(02.08.12)
I've read antisemitic writings which say Jews are deceitful and manipulative and only interested in what is good for Jews. Is it any wonder these stereotypes never die when people like Merav produce these dreadful op eds. Lets see, last week it was Mr Adler suggesting Israel should assasinate Obamma and direct the replacement President to invade Iran . Now Merav calls for an invasion of Syria and tries to use ''Holocaust guilt'' to back up his demand, all the while pretending that his motives are humanitarian rather than selfish.
29. Author is poorly informed ...
leo ,   usa   (02.08.12)
"I pray that the idiot will let his young children flee before the masses butcher them as well" === Actually Assad tried to get his family out of the country a week or so ago and his convoy could not get through to the airport. So, you cannot blame Assad for not trying, can you.
30. Everyone who got offended by comparisson to Auschwitz.
leo ,   usa   (02.08.12)
Spare me. Do you want millions to die before we will decide to move. If anything it is moral obligation for Israel to stop Assad exactly because of Auschwitz.
Next talkbacks
Back to article