News
Left slams 'hallucinatory' West Bank annexation plan
Moran Azulay
Published: 23.02.12, 22:39
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
31. Bad Vibes
Zivron   (02.24.12)
The Vibes are nasty enough without unnecessary provocations.The most secure remedy is to provide insurmotable security for Jew Palestinian Refugees Gentile and Jewish.
32. Two states ? Jordan already exists!
Marcelo ,   World   (02.24.12)
Jordan, get your citizens back, stop replacing their jordanian passports with refugee status. Israel should annex area C, give to all citizens within area C israeli full citizenship, and totally disconnect from areas A and B, fully opened to Jordan. Period.
33. #16 - Israel doesn't ignore the minorities it has
William ,   Israel   (02.24.12)
Israel spends alot of time (too much I think) in catering to its minorities, some which abuse the fact they live in a democracy. "Palestinians" who become citizens become part of the Israeli Arab population. They are not some special group unto themselves. But with citizenship, they'd also have obligations.
34. #10 - and what of the whore Left?
William ,   Israel   (02.24.12)
They sell themselves to the highest bidder as well. It's an outcome of our strange govt setup based on the English system, not a specific ethnic group, you racist cretin.
35. #14 - the Left is upset whenever anyone is successful
William ,   Israel   (02.24.12)
I saw a great bumper sticker which captures this phenomenon 100%: "Piss off a Leftist - succeed in life"
36. Rocket Science: its a 3-state, not a 2-state. [end]
BUTSeriously ,   Sydney   (02.24.12)
37. Yes 2-State Solution - Israel and Jordan aka Palestine
Mike ,   SD   (02.24.12)
38. Arabs don't need more room here, they have space in Eurabia
Abraham ben Jacob ,   Canada   (02.24.12)
If they are immigrating to Eurabia in huge numbers, what do they want to build more Arab housing in Israel ? Maybe for a summer villa get away. Also, let the Eurabians build in their own countries' many " area C' s " to accomodate their new Arab freindly and democratically minded neighbors.
39. mutually exclusive.
Golan ,   modiin   (02.24.12)
Israel is currently a bi-national state with 20% Arab population. A two state solution calls for a 23rd Arab state with NO jews and a Jewish state with too many Arabs. In the case of annexation of empty land, Israel will remain a binational state with too many Arabs. So as far as Israel is concerned what difference does it make if we are a binational state or a binational state? Instead how about we create an Arab state with no Jews and a Jewish state with no Arabs? One state in Jordan and the other state in Israel. The border can be drawn along the Jordan river.
40. So peace now is against it because palistinians will like it
Potash Katiftof ,   Safed, israel   (02.24.12)
This guy yariv oppenheimer is some piece of work, he doesnt want the plan beaceause the palistinians will all want it? Not becquse they are against it? Sounds lie they want wr forever so that hey can keep funraising from ther leftist. Shame on you yariv, shame on you Sent from my ipad
41. Peace Now
Mark ,   usa   (02.24.12)
While I agree that the palestinians will never accept the Bennett plan, they will in fact never accept ANY plan that safeguards Israel as a Jewish state. The plan that makes the most sense is the Lieberman plan. Israel needs to unilaterally keep the land that they defensively need, and pass a loyalty oath for citizenship. Those who are unwilling to accept Israel as a Jewish state and who refuse to do military or national service of some sort will lose their voting citizenship.Only when Israel puts their national interests before the U.S. and EU will they finally regain the deterrence that they have lost since Oslo.
42. Israel already bi-national state
A ,   Belgium   (02.24.12)
The "palestinians" already have their treasonous representatves in the Knesset, what could be more bi-national than that? Israel will be a more Jewish state....WITH buses in TA on Sabbath...when Tibi, Zoubi and the rest of the hamas spies are gone.
43. Expecting appeasement to satiate the Empire
BH ,   Iowa   (02.24.12)
is hallucinatory
44. Annexing Area C will boost economy
Yossef   (02.24.12)
for israeli and palestinians. I will be able finally to buy a house, in an arab village, coz in J'lem its overpriced, and I dont feel bad in a muslim village. In these villages, there will be soon Aroma, and Hillel cofee-shops, and supermarkets, and a quality of life we use to enjoy everywhere in Israel, in a mixed population, which is not that bad. Everybody, Jews and Arabs will enjoy the blooming of economy. So YES Annex area C, and give their inhabitants the israeli citizenship, it will not destroy more the jewish nature of Israel.
45. The Land of Israel
Brod ,   USA   (02.24.12)
Judea and Samaria-Land of Israel belongs to Israel since ancient time. It is your land. It is GOD-GIVEN and GOD-RESTORED to Israel. Why argue about it? Just continue building on your land to house 3 million or more Jews. It does not matter what the dark forces-Islamist-Jihadists and AntiSemites say about it. It is none of their business to be intruding in Israel's internal affairs. Israel can tell the usurpers-Arab Islamist-Jihadists and their dark forces-supporters to go to Hell. The scoundrels should be returning to their historic homeland in Arabia where they came from in the 7th century instead of usurping the Land of Israel from the Jews. Israel should not allow foreign agents calling themselves 'peace now' crusading against the Land of Israel. Judea and Samaria-Land of Israel belongs to Israel (Read the Biblie, History and Biblical Archaeology). Period.
46. "methinks they doth protest too much.."
Bernard Ross ,   st anns bay, jamaica   (02.25.12)
Are there still fool jews who vote for the israeli left? Their behavior forces ordinary mid roaders to vote far right.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article