News
Lt. Col. Eisner: I didn't put anyone's life at risk
Ynet
Published: 17.04.12, 21:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
113 Talkbacks for this article
31. you are the kind of officers we need.
ralph   (04.17.12)
32. Eisner is nothing but a COWARD...
Mark Wilson ,   U.S.A.   (04.17.12)
It is not very macho to hit an unarmed protester when you are armed to the teeth and backed by an equally armed group of Jewish war criminals... I bet that Eisner will break world records running south when a Hezbollah flag is planted on the border fence up north...
33. #3 The problem is, it wasn't just a 5 minute penalty.
Noodles ,   Coney Island   (04.17.12)
It was a "game misconduct" from the PM, DM, and Chief of Staff.
34. Apocalypse Now Oscar performance
avramele   (04.17.12)
At first i thought this incident happened .Now we understand it was simply an old clip from Pinochet' s Chile or Argentina under rhe Junta or some lefty anti Viet nam war movie. The actor playing Eisner rivals De Niro or Brando with pretty newcomer as his wife. No worry Israel its just a movie-our tzahal never behaves as such. What a relief!
35. #24
Sam M ,   UK   (04.17.12)
Sounds good to me Danny! These muppets could do with a good workout before their flight home!
36. # 6 & all like minds...This Jew is an honorable Israel......
Edithann ,   USA   (04.17.12)
Todays breaking Ynet news... An Israeli MIT researcher facing federal charges of traveling to Colorado to have sex with children has apparently killed himself in prison, the Boston Globe reported, citing officials. According to the report, Yaron Segal, 30, died Friday, said John Sell, executive assistant with the Federal Correctional Institution Englewood. Guards found Segal alone, hanging from a homemade noose in his cell at the detention center, where defendants are held while awaiting trial, Sell said. (Ynet) TATA
37. The patriot
soldier ,   Jerusalem   (04.17.12)
Eisner sacrified his little finger for the country
38. reaction
chaim witz   (04.17.12)
I was delighted to see a jew hitting back in the face of an anti-jew that offended him. Beware now, jews hit back.
39. guilty or stupid
vitenberg ,   france   (04.17.12)
He is not guilty, nor stupid; Just his behaviour was inapropriate for an officerIn a general way, the army is too much cool with these people
40. Split # 17
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (04.17.12)
Some simple minded person once said that for a boxer to be good it wasn't how hard he punched but his ability to make his opponent mad. Well, Israel the good boxer sure made you mad Split. Why shouldn't a sucker get a sucker punch? After all, he asked for it. Today you call Mr. Eisner an out of control bully. Yesterday you called him a tootles bully. Make up your silly mind.
41. Edithann # 36
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (04.17.12)
And just what does that story have to do with Sarah B's post or this story? We can read that story for ourselves without the help of an imbecile who always ends her assinine posts with TATA.
42. Violence on either side is wrong
Galut ia ,   Selah   (04.17.12)
if in the leadup to this event ,the demonstrators engaged in violent acts that exacerbates the patience of those responsible for controlling the situation ...then they have some culpability in returned violence.,,, but instead of taking responsibility these demonstrators will exploit this event for their own ends. Yes Eisner needed to have controlled his temper... but I am willing to bet that there is very few that are reading this that haven't in a moment of frustration ... lost it at least momentary... enough time to tell a story about you that you wouldn't want out there...
43. KOL HAKAVOD EISNER
Eliyahu ,   London, England   (04.17.12)
Thank you for securing our borders! - KOL HAKAVOD! Keep up the good job. And refua shelema for your finger and arm.
44. Extreme and soldiers
Opinion   (04.17.12)
To be honest I hate the way the army has treated him! Recently I have read on BBC the interview with one policemen which didn't interfere in some brutal case during last riots in England. His logic was simple: "If I do, the whole media is after me and I lose a job. It is better not to!" I hope that those people which did what they did understand that at some point in time it will be here too! A soldier is a soldier! He is in the extreme situation and it does cover him. Leftists hardly understand this since they are afraid of any power including of their own physical body! Extreme is extreme and soldier is a soldier. He is allowed to be heavy!
45. LtCol Eisner
Leon ,   Adelaide South Austr   (04.17.12)
Well done Sir
46. The guy's got what it takes to do the job he was handed
AB ,   TheRock   (04.17.12)
Question is why his army superiors didn't do their job, knowing that these anarchists were intent on making trouble and did not put their own cameras in place - especially knowing full well that these anarchists would do anything to get a good video for themselves.
47. HE'S A HERO
TRIPP ,   LA PAZ, BOLIVIA   (04.17.12)
all the jew haters are pumped with this one,is it killing them that israel in a few short years is a miracle.europe is bankrupt,egypt and the rest of the israel haters are in the toilet, it's people wake up in the morning with 50% unemployement,am yisroel chai, god bless this soldier
48. israel and the activists
joel ,   usa   (04.18.12)
if israel will listen to the UN and the rest of the hating world, then it is listening to the devil who is up to destroy the nation; do what is needful to protect the israelis from terrorists whoever they are, that's the basic importance!
49. eisner is a loser
marcel ,   nyc   (04.17.12)
i love israel and the idf, served myself.sorry to say but eisner was wrong in hitting the illegal dane , he lost his cool which is a weak , and then the whining about his superior , topping it with a lousy try to fix the damage by wasting good doctors time to put a band aid on the finger. no respect from my end!! , israel spend a fortune again to fight the flytilla and all we get is another PR loss, no thanks to eisner
50. 40 - Eaglebeak , Left Coast, USA
split ,   US   (04.18.12)
Finally I got the answer why I never bothered to confront your stupid comments - Have a good day ,...
51. #41 - Eaglebeak
Devorah   (04.18.12)
Edithann is running out of material, and since she can't come up with anything intelligent on her own, she's using unrelated articles. If she wasn't such a jackass, it would almost be sad.
52. Eisner, YOU SHOULDA HIT HIM HARDER!
Bad Assed Jew ,   United States   (04.18.12)
You did well.
53. IDF learns fast from Syia/Iran how to handle protestors.
Igor   (04.18.12)
54. To Mark # 32
Don ,   Indy USA   (04.18.12)
Mark, you are the typical liberal coward. Where you from Ca ???
55. MR pathetic end
cc ,   T-A   (04.18.12)
56. # 38 You are pathetic
Ben Alofs ,   Bangor, UK   (04.18.12)
You apparently see opposition against Israel's occupation of Palestine through the lens of anti-semitism. You are proud now to see a Jew behave like a brutal thug against an unarmed person who has both hands down. I pity you. Is this what you aspire Jews to be?
57. Lots of excuses for un-necessary violance here
spyguy ,   seattle USA   (04.18.12)
Israelis need to take the long view of history and realize that they are less than 0.1% of the people on earth, which means if they make enough people angry they have no future because in very practical terms the will of the 99.9% will always be forced on the 0.1%. While it may feel good that one stupid IDF officer beat a protestor, in the end that feeling will be negated by the terrible consequences for every Israeli. Israelis may want to give an obscene gesture to the whole world but in the end they will pay a terrible price for that immature attitude. For the long term good of Israel, Eisner should be severely punished NOT applauded.
58. Eisner forgot his moves
Yerushalmi ,   Jerusalem   (04.18.12)
Eisner, Eisner... Them youngsters these days don't know how to deal with those jerks. Learn a bit about what films well and what doesn't. Next time hide out of sight and take a potshot with a rubber bullet. Aim at the ass, he won't be sitting for weeks after that which will give him time to ponder traffic safety and blocking highways where cars drive 100 km/h.
59. 25
john Darren ,   cairns-Australia   (04.18.12)
You obviously can't decipher the video You are an idiot.
60. eisner... the kind of Jew that really bugs anti-semites
Mark ,   johannesburg south Africa   (04.18.12)
strong and forceful Jews like Eisner really bug European anti-semites. they far prefer the shy retiring types who don yellow stars on this shoulders . sorry if we offended you but we don't take your abuse anymore. we are a powerful nation, one people under one G-d.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article