News
'Israel making threats over compensation for Jews'
Elior Levy
Published: 17.08.12, 11:00
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
91 Talkbacks for this article
61. The conection was made by Iraq regime...
Ian ,   Newcastle upon Tyne   (08.17.12)
...at the time when they forced all the Iraqi Jews to leave in the 1940s and 50s.They were tricked into registering all their assets to facilitate transferring them abroad...then they were simply confiscated by the Iraq government leaving the Iraqi Jews as penniless refugees. The interesting point is the REASON that the Iraq regime gave for its action.It said that the very considerable assets would be used to compensate and resettle the Palestinian Arab displaced persons.The confiscated assets were huge and could have done just that several times over but instead they simply disappeared into private pockets of the Iraq elite. It's so refreshing to see that there's still somebody like Mr Ayalon who is determined to stand up to Arab League lies and misinformation.I hope that he makes the disappearance of the Iraqi Jews' assets a major issue and demands that the present Iraq government repairs the wrong done by its predecessor.Lets not forget that the Iraq army was one of the major participants in 1948 that caused today's mess and bears a heavy historical responsibility for displacing the Arab residents of Israel into Jordan. THREE CHEERS FOR ISRAEL!!!
62. Running scared!
Sam M ,   UK   (08.17.12)
It's high time the arabs admitted publicly that some 700,000 Jews were forced to flee their homes in arab lands and were robbed of their worldly possessions. In return Israel should symbolically waive any right to financial compensation from arab countries on the understanding that the palestinian 'refugees' be absorbed by their arab 'brethren' in the same way that Israel has absorbed it's own people. Moreover the pals should also withdraw their snouts from the international aid trough where they have been guzzling voraciously for far too long and stand on their own two feet. If not the Israeli government should apply for ‘REFUGEE STATUS’ for all the surviving Jewish refugees and their far more numerous descendants from iraq, egypt ect. At the very least this would be good PR!! What’s good for the goose is good for the gander!! Fat chance that the arabs will ever acknowledge anyone else as a victim such as the long suffering Kurds who they continue to persecute and who unlike the fictitious pals actually do have a distinct language and culture of their own. An honour based culture my foot!
63. IS ISRAEL BECOMING LESS STUPID, FINALLY ?
Nowhere Man ,   Metropolos, Zion.   (08.17.12)
64. How many arab"refugees"were even born in what is now Israel?
Yosi ,   Gilo, Jerusalem   (08.17.12)
If you look at the lies that the English were doing, they stamped newcomer arab papers as if they were native. How many arab "refugees" were just freeloaders from their respective countries(Lebanon, Syria, Jordan) just trying to make a buck? HOW MANY dollars have been given to these "refugees" from 1948 on? Millions going into the billions. How much has been given to us Morrocan Jews or to Algerian, Lybian or our other brethren? Zero! Let's get that out in the open. Let these idiot talkbackers that know zero respond "intelligently & coherantly to that!
65. expel arabs as they expelled the jews
bernard ross   (08.17.12)
One day Israel will invade all the arab countries and seize their assets as reparations and leave devastation behind. It is the least they deserve.
66. #24 Arabs fled to permit slaughter of Jews
David ,   FL/US   (08.17.12)
Fact: The Arabs attacked Israel when Israel declared independence, as a result of UN partition of Palestine. The mufti of Jerusalem, a well known Nazi sympatizer ( who made broadcasts from Berlin during WWII) who told the Arabs to rise up during the war and kill all Jews living in Palestine, told the Arabs to leave, so that the Arab armies could drive the Jews into the sea. They could then return and have all of Palestine to themselves. There has always been a continued presence of Jew in Palestine, even during the Diaspora. Arabs living in Israel, and who did not flee during the war of independence, were not kicked out. That's why there is such a large Israeli-Arab population in Israel today. Only those Arabs who fled, were not permitted to return. Israel did not want a hostile Arab population inside it's borders. If they hadn't left, they would still be there today.
67. #26
David ,   FL/US   (08.17.12)
You are wrong! The Ottomans, who controlled Palestine, permitted Jews to return. They started by buying land, legitimately. After WWI, England controlled Palestine, and the continued immigration was permitted under the Balfour Declaration. Also, Arabia also supported the idea of a Jewish homeland at the time, before the Saudi family overthrew the king. Under the Armistice, that ended the war, the Jewish homeland was to consist of all of Palestine, incorporating what is now Jordan, as well, and even parts of Syria. This never came about because of the Saudi coup. You don't have to believe me. Just check out the details of the armistice. A non-Jewish legal scholar researched who legally owns Jerusalem, for over 25 years, and those were the legal documents that he discovered. (This does NOT mean, btw, that the Arab population was to be forced out of their homes.)
68. 800,000 jews turned into refugees as they fled arab states
Avi   (08.17.12)
Their property that was confiscated is 4 times the size of Israel and 360 billion in worth of property. This cannot be ignored and the arab states are terrified. The arabs monopolized global opinion on the palestinian refugees but the jewish refugees which were just as much if not more and definitely richer must have at the very least an equal stage in the international arena. Any compensation given to palestinian refugees must be deducted from the compensation for the jewish refugees.
69. Refugees
Rosie   (08.18.12)
Bravo!!!! Bravo!!!!! Bravo, deputy foreign minister, Mr.Danny Ayalon!!!!!!! Kol Hakavod! Ishar koah! And to think that NO ONE raised this issue for such a long time!! Shame on all those politicians!!!! But better late than never.
70. About time!
Chaim Ben Kahan ,   Efrat, Israel   (08.18.12)
It's about time that the Arab world pays reparations to Israel for the property it robbed and Jews they cleansed. This amount is in the trillions of dollars.
71. #51, #51 mr. myopia
solomon ,   bklyn   (08.18.12)
What, your garbage again?! Your fantasies know no bounds. BTW: Blockade is an act of war; something Egypt did. The truth hurts, doesn't it? No wonder you avoid it like the plague.
72. #43 yael
solomon ,   bklyn   (08.18.12)
That’s some bit of research. Kol ha’kavod!
73. #51, Observer, you run out of Copts ?
(08.18.12)
You have nothing to offer Jews but Sharia, forced conversions, kidnapping and forced marriages of Jewish girls, terror and intimidation. Before you can invite Jews into your country, you must show , at the very least, that you can coexist with Egyptian Copts.
74. Time to pay up
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (08.18.12)
I love Danny Ayalon, he's beat the arabs at their own game. I figure that with interest on the stolen Jewish property alone runs into the billions. Good luck with getting these cheap charlie's to pay up. This will at least draw attention to the fact that these Jews were robbed of all they had. Excellent a yiddisha cup. Hope you win big time from your enemies. Loooong overdue.
75. # 24 Steve not so
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (08.18.12)
Israel practically begged the pals to stay. They left in droves after an arab radio announcement that the Jews would rape their women when they came back to israel( thinking that would boost their fighting ) so, what did the pals do? They pals split. Maybe you should read Golda Meir's book and learn some facts? Many other documented reports to back this up.
76. Observer.. When you can allow Copts to pray in peace,call us
(08.18.12)
77. # 31 dani The miracle of Israel.
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (08.18.12)
if not for our G-d we would be stateless. Whatever the Gentiles decide has no power against our G-d, the G-d of Israel. There is but one and it is He.
78. # 33 my name, my country If it's of any consolation to you,
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (08.18.12)
Russia is broke, her citizens miserable and some poor Russians have to give up their own children to orphanages to feed them. My mother left the Ukraine after WW11, oh! the stories I could tell you, none of them good except, their escape fro that barbaric nation that stalin ended up murdering 30 million of his own nations people. Russia is cursed for what she's done to Jews, Christians, and just plain folks without religion ( as is communism)
79. Too bad any arabs stayed in Israel.
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (08.18.12)
They don't belong in the Holy Land, that land belongs to "The Jewish People", according to the UN. Time they move or be moved. Wait for it, it's coming. The 'Arab spring' needs replacements.
80. # 70 Chaim Ben Kahan Efrat, Israel.YES TO TAHT!!
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (08.18.12)
This reminds me of another case one with a stolen hit song. The lawyer advised the legitimate writer to wait until all the money was counted from the proceeds of the hit and THEN sue. ( more money, more money! )
81. # 63 bernard ross from your lips to G-ds ears.
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (08.18.12)
82. IM VERY PROUD TO BE A JEW
TANNY TAWIL ,   ENGLAND   (08.18.12)
I WOULD LIKE TO ANNOUNCE THROUGH YNETS READERS THAT THE FOUNDER OF THE PARALMPIC GAMES WAS A JEW WHO ESCAPED FROM GERMANY AND WENT TO THE STOKE MANDEVILLE HOSPITAL AND ANOUNCED HIM SELF, MY NAME IS DR LUDWIG GUTTERMAN, WHO BECAME SIR LUDWIG GUTTERMAN IN 1966. TELL YOUR FRIENDS A MATTER OF FACT TELL THE WORLD.
83. YES! //END
JFJAW   (08.19.12)
84. re: Israel Started it
Myriam Obadia ,   Ashkelon Israel   (08.19.12)
Nope. The Arab countries started to expel and dispossess "their" Jews in 1928 (with the complicity of the UK), 20 years before Israel regained it's independence in 1948.
85. 77 , big bad jew
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (08.19.12)
If not for the Braves who fought there would be NO state of Israel . Your god does not exists , so could not intervene in 1948 . You deserve your name : bad jew .
86. Tanny 82 , it's Guttmann TRY # 2
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (08.19.12)
not Gutterman . If Guttmann is your reason to be proud as a Jew , what about the others who made it possible to save thousands of lives ? Never heard about Sir Boris Chain , Nobel prize , for the discovery of the way to produce penicillin ? Karl Landsteiner , blood groups ; Salk and Sabin , polyo vaccines . To name just four of the hundreds
87. Finally! It is time Israel was more proactive
Eric L ,   Chicago, USA   (08.26.12)
It is about time Israel bring these things up internationally. The fact there are Palestinian Arab Israeli's and almost no Jews left anywhere in the Arab world with citizenship proves the lie the Arab world has always claimed about ALL refugees. It is just sad the Palestinian refugees pay the price of being pawns and suckers. UNWRA is a major part of the problem, and not ANY part a solution.
88. Don't forget refugeeship goes to several generations
kate b ,   uk 'refugee'   (08.26.12)
89. Jewish compensation
Ron Thompson ,   Fairfax, Va, USA   (08.27.12)
My comment couldn't be simpler: WAY OVERDUE. It was only about 15 years ago I even learned about the evictions of Jews from several Arab countries, and the confiscation of all their properties. This whole slice of history ought to be brought up anew, even if only for educative purposes. Also, what so many of those refugees made of themselves after the evictions and confiscations. Nor do I believe the Palestinians, whose true refugee number may have been about 1% (39,000??) of the Jewish evictees have any comparable claim, given the record, which should be clear, of their decades-long refusal to work toward any kind of genuine peace with Israel.
90. AAS Syndrome no 52
LION OF JUDAH   (08.29.12)
Again you are telling bullshit. Jews won the war in 1948 against all odds. Small new army against well equipped 9 Arab armies. One Jewish soldier against 500 Arabs soldier. Yom Kippur war in 1973, the first few days Israel may have lost the war, after that Israel kicked your fat a$$es and the IDF was few km from Damascus & Cairo. Arabs will never win against Israel.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article