News
Court rejects Corrie family civil suit
Reuters, Ahiya Raved
Published: 28.08.12, 10:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
86 Talkbacks for this article
31. Corrie ten Boom
T. eccentricus ,   Tiarajú   (08.28.12)
Am I the only one who was misled by the headline? I thought it had to do with the Corrie ten Boom story set in the Nazi-occupied Netherlands, and it was puzzling to see that now, so many years later, there seemed to be a lawsuit involved. Were Corrie's relatives being sued??? That didn't make any sense. I've seen the movie on television about five times and it's one of the best ones I've ever seen. It's rather old, and in the end Corrie, who was already about 90 years old, is shown and she says a few words.
32. #4 she was not a fool
israel israeli ,   tel aviv   (08.28.12)
She was just trying to be the all-time Darwin Award champion.
33. "International Law" is any BS "Law" that can punish Israel
Alan ,   SA   (08.28.12)
34. Why do Israelis demolish houses
Tomek ,   Poland   (08.28.12)
belonging to Palestinians? If you think it is normal, there is something inherently wrong with you.
35. (23) Stefan in Hamburg
tiki ,   belgium   (08.28.12)
So true!
36. #5 They are garbage and they raised the delirious garbage.
Michael ,   USA   (08.28.12)
37. @#1
Dan ,   Tel-Aviv   (08.28.12)
Do you know how many nations consider themselves 'chosen'..........your probably just to focused on Israel to think Jews are the ony one.
38. facts
joe ,   earth   (08.28.12)
to #1 and #16 i really regret that people like you got no education enough to read/see/check facts and to get an understanding about them. i am also sorry that the world is plenty of people in the same situation of yours. the bad consequence of this is that insane comments like yours are public and so may affect he understanding of more people like you. i may suggest ynet to make available an option that could help you: drawing information instead of just writing about it. maybe if you see a girl pushing herself inside a war zone against all possible advises she got and standing in front of a moving bulldozer it will help you understand what happened (as words didnt work).
39. apartheid courts
bill ,   canada   (08.28.12)
she did her job; jews are now unsafe in the world; boycotts using her name have grown; her name will be remembered; she is a martyr who will never die; a symbol of freedom; thank you Rachel Corrie for your life
40. Try this in Afganistan
R ,   Israel   (08.28.12)
Suppose an Israeli doesn't agree with America being in Afganistan. Suppose the Israeli goes to Afganistan, defies all signs and fences that would keep him/her out of the war zone, and throws themself in front of a bulldozer driven by an American soldier. Suppose the American soldier didn't see the Israel and runs him/her over. Would the Israeli's family be justified in suing America and the soldier? Doubt it.
41. @ Tomek: Because...
Ariksan ,   Zurich   (08.28.12)
... they were used as entry points and cover for weapon smuggling tunnels and terrorists.
42. what kinda parents let their daughter go
ghostq   (08.28.12)
to area with active terror org aka hamas. I think the award for the best parents of the year won't be given to them, anyway the family can't claim it was IDF accident since there was no asphalt or even a road no other pedestrian, they just want revenge, very backward way of thinking indeed.
43. Not a single US soldier died in Israel
TZVI MANOR ,   EVEN YEHUDA   (08.28.12)
Be a little more gratefull Kirsty, we are the wavebraker and you know it. If Israel is not here you might be in combat with the arabs in Europe You should have more respect for the only ME ally that never turn your back on you.UHHH!and regrding moneys we are paying our debts in due time.So please become less ignorant
44. Y'day soldier was run over by a tank; where are the Corries?
IsaacG ,   Israel   (08.28.12)
The soldier was seriously injured yesterday in a combat exercise on the Golan Heights. When in a battle zone, whether in training or combat, your life is in danger. The ISM leadership knows this. After Corrie's death Thomas Saffold said "we’re like a peace army. Generals send young men and women off to operations, and some die." ISM a "peace group"? Gimme a break!
45. to no 16. Let's not put nationality to this death.
(08.28.12)
It could had been also an Israeli leftist, it could have been a swedish leftist or a Spaniard. This death was not the fault of the IDF it was the fault of some imprudent stupid leftists who disregards all rules of safety in a War zone. You guys are so ideologicall motivated, why don't you go and protest in Syria. Why dont you go to protest in Egypt where they are violating criatians and womens rights. As for americans deaths, let me tell you. NOT even one american has died in an Israeli wars defending Israel
46. Morale of the story
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (08.28.12)
don't play chicken with a bulldozer. i hope this puts an end to this matter. She gambled and lost... her life. If on the other hand she had been on Israel's side, that decision might have saved her foolish life. A tragic irony. She died in vain for a terroristic organization and a terroristic people.
47. Foolish negligence is awarded to Rachel Corrie
Big bad Jew ,   United States   (08.28.12)
and the highest award is reserved for her non realistic parents. Too bad they didn't school her in accident prevention. Who stands in front of a moving bulldozer? A soon to be dead person.
48. A reply to your question
To Tomek   (08.28.12)
Different reasons: In this particular context, the houses were used to hide tunnels, that are used to bring rockets that are fired in Israeli cities - Do you think THAT is normal? would you agree to have rockets fired at YOUR home. In other cases, building were demolished because many of them were booby-trapped and it was the only safe way to move through - when it comes to lives v.s. houses I choose lives - houses can be rebuild. Did I answer you question? at least partially?
49. The correct verdict,blame the ISM
Tom ,   USA   (08.28.12)
and blame the college whereshe was radicalized with half truths.
50. One has to be nuts to go to a war zone
Melody ,   USA   (08.28.12)
and than complain about it. Israel must defend herself.
51. Why did not she go to Chechnya, Sudan or Somalia?
Lisa ,   USA   (08.28.12)
What is the matter had she been hurt there nobody in the world would care?
52. Tomek,inherently uniformed and hateful Polish Israel-basher:
ab   (08.28.12)
Houses were used as entraces to tunnels to Israel .Suffices ?
53. Court rejects Corrie family civil suit.
Elsie. ,   Gush Halav   (08.28.12)
# 23, dumb and ignorant is all I can say about your post, don't you have anything better to do?? Sarah, it was a one doller lawsuit, they were not interested in money.
54. Kirsty Wark - if you put yourself in a dangerous situation
Michelle ,   Israel   (08.28.12)
BAD THINGS CAN AND OFTEN DO HAPPEN - to expect anything else is showing a lack of maturity and brains.
55. @Stefan from Amburg
deavman ,   Acco, Israel   (08.28.12)
Thank you for such a well put perspective on this tragic incident. Indeed the members of the ISM know too well the Israelis as not to be threatened by armed to the teeth soldiers...Yet they are willing to place Israelis in the Palestinian line of fire with no qualms whatsoever . Coincidentally just yesterday, an IDF soldier got ran over by a tank...S--t happens.
56. #2 Sarah B
Lio ,   London England   (08.28.12)
Profit from their daughter's death? No, Sarah, all they wanted was justice. Not everyone idolises money y'know. As expected, not a modicum of compassion from the usual suspects here, just pure venom and hatred.
57. For Corrie's parents
Reuven36 ,   Herzliya Israel   (08.28.12)
I can understand your grief. However the facts are undeniable. Your daughter placed herself in mortal danger in an area designated a war zone with prohibited entry to civilians. Also, your (US) govt advised it's citizens not to enter Gaza. What more can one say.
58. to #34 cause they were ilegal houses
ghostq   (08.28.12)
that used terror activists families.
59. #34
Jorge ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (08.28.12)
The same question I will ask you: Why do the Polish loot the Jewish houses during WWII and after? Why do the Polish kill Jewish in pogroms before, during and after WWI?
60. Carrie
Jorge ,   Israel/USA/Argentina   (08.28.12)
I am sure that Rachel's love for the hate of the Jewish would go further if she is still alive. Where are her Arabs friends now showing support to her family? I am sure they do not care, she is only a piece of propaganda now like the Italian useful idiot.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article