News
MK El-Sana: Zionists to blame for anti-Islam film
Hassan Shaalan
Published: 13.09.12, 13:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
57 Talkbacks for this article
31. Israel is the only country in the world
Sidney ,   USA   (09.13.12)
where members of its legislature are openly disloyal and are not expelled.
32. a challenge
zionist forever   (09.13.12)
All you people who know aabout world history here is a challenge for you: Can anybody name even one bad thing in the world that zionists are not responsible for? Can anybody name a single good thing in the world zionists are responsible for?
33. The actigs was so lousy
Ish Kabibble ,   Delancey   (09.13.12)
it should have been classified as a Comedy
34. Always a double standard with Muslims
Abie Dee ,   New York   (09.13.12)
I'd like to hear what Mr. Tibi has to say about all the anti-semitic crap being played on Arab Tv all across the middle east, day and night. Hmmm, might that also go under the category of 'fostering intolerance for religious values'. ???
35. How Many?
Douglas Fireman ,   Chicago, USA   (09.13.12)
Jumping the gun again. Blaming the Jews/Zionists. The Egyptian Christian Copt who made the film should be blamed/punished. How long will This jihad last- this rampage? How many will be killed? How many will be wounded? How many buildings will be burned. down? How many embassies will be attacked?....and all in the name of Ignorance.
36. Ignorance is bliss
olavi ,   espoo, finland   (09.13.12)
There millions of illiterate jobless waste in Middle east who have no ability to do anything useful. The west must cease funding these idiot countries so they can show their inability to organize any functioning systems to lead to progress in their living. Israel shall inhabit West Bank and Sinai so these areas will blossom.
37. More offensive...
yoni ,   nyc yo   (09.13.12)
I would say that the hundreds of films out there showing beheadings, suicide bombings, honor killings, and other assorted villainy, all to the tune of "god is great, god is great, god is great!" should be far more offensive to muslims. sadly though, this is not the case. im sure god, would not want people committing these heinous crimes to call his name in blessing. Although, I'm not sure the same could be said for his prophet!
38. Double Standard
Salim ,   Canada   (09.13.12)
When Egyptian television presented a hit series on the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, no Jews came out on the streets and started raising havoc. That series was based on a book that has been proven to be a complete lie. Why don't the Muslims prove that the Muhamed movie (which I only saw a few minutes of) is not factual??
39. #31: Sidney
Israeli 2   (09.13.12)
True! But this is nothing Israel ought to be proud of. In fact it is a disgrace and a clear indication of the enemy from within who allow this to happen. ISRAEL should and cannot be a Democracy as we know it today. It has to be fair and just and honest with minority's rights but not this way.
40. Nothing but lies and fabrications
Shai ,   Mexico city   (09.13.12)
Nothing but lies and fabrications to be added to the long, long list of lies and fabrications coming from the arab world. The only thing demonizing muslims and islam is muslim's own deranged actions
41. Now Zeider says Mossad has gone into Hollywood movie making
(09.13.12)
42. MK El-Sana: Zionists to blame
joe ,   uk   (09.13.12)
he says this because he knows that what muslim love to hear even if they dont belive him and he knows it will stire up trouble why dont he talk about muslims burning mosques their law is one way trafic against israel and west
43. Sir.Salman Rushdie Vertion 2012 reloaded
NATAN ,   ISRAEL   (09.13.12)
The Muslims kill are pederast, make terrorism in the name of his god and a chip film make them so angry, were is the arab spring??? the world must open the eyes this people is a plage, hope to Ynet post my coment.
44. Double talk and double standards
Ian ,   Newcastle upon Tyne   (09.13.12)
I have to gasp in admiration at the way that Arab MKs maintain their right to freedom of expression by denying it to others. What I take issue with is: "The Arab MK further blasted "Zionist elements" for encouraging Islamophobia and antagonism towards Islam, to serve political interests." It seems to me that the Arab Mks are grasping a pretext to further THEIR political interests. THREE CHEERS FOR ISRAEL!!!
45. mk Saba
Aaron ,   Toronto,canada   (09.13.12)
Isn't it nice to live in a democratic country where you can stand up and say something against the government without fear for your life? Try saying something good that Israel does once in a while.
46. Along with Freedom of Speech, West has Freedom of Responsibi
William ,   Israel   (09.13.12)
Along with Freedom of Speech, West has Freedom of Responsibility. Muslims have neither.
47. PRovocation
umish ,   fort liquordale USA`   (09.13.12)
So while all the moslems riot... read this UPDATE: Sept. 13, 11:34 a.m. -- The Associated Press has identified Californian Nakoula Basseley Nakoula as the man behind the anti-Muslim film that's been the target of protests across the Middle East. The AP says its source for the information is an official in U.S. law enforcement who "spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to discuss an ongoing investigation." In earlier interviews, Nakoula said he was the manager of the company that made the film but did not say he was the actual filmmaker. He identified himself as a Coptic Christian and said that the film's director supported concerns about the treatment of the Copts by Muslims. He also denied posing as Sam Bacile, the mysterious man whom initial reports on Tuesday quoted and identified as an Israeli Jewish filmmaker, but AP reports that telephone numbers for Bacile and Nakoula trace to the same address. Questions remain as to why Bacile, who was interviewed by the AP and the Wall Street Journal, said he was an Israeli Jew.
48. #25 - now you know Muslim mentality
William ,   Israel   (09.13.12)
Their actions actually underscore the message of films like this, not contradict it.
49. the murder and arson
Hilda ,   US   (09.13.12)
As usual the media immediately blamed Israel claiming the Cioptic Egyptian was an Israel and nothing about his real and actual adentity. I have no doubt at asll that it was a planned affair to coinside with 9/11 anniversary. They pklanned to do siomething terrible in US and apparently they were thwarted in some way and had to settle for this. what they did was an act of War. not an appology by our president.
50. What about the synagogues in Gush Katif?
Jessica Smith ,   Israel   (09.13.12)
Hey Tibi, you didn't mention the synagogues in Gush Katif that your "people" destroyed immediately after Israel left Gaza. I guess you forgot about that, huh?
51. WELL DONE ISRAEL< BLESS ISRAEL
ZIMBI ,   NJUSA   (09.13.12)
52. Arrest El-Sana foer treason.
Reuven   (09.14.12)
Arrest Zoabi and Tibi for treason too!
53. Still waiting for an apology ...
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.13.12)
... now that we know for a certainty that the filmmaker is not Israeli and not Jewish. What are the odds of that happening? Censure of the Arab MKs until they apologize would be very much in order.
54. The muslims have their 'protocols of Zion"
Bad Ased Jew ,   United States   (09.14.12)
and the Christians have this badly made, factual flick of a sicko pedophile child and woman abuser. Why should the muslims have all the fun?
55. MK Tibi ...you are a hatemongerer and a traitor...
EST ,   Miami USA   (09.14.12)
MK Tibi, no..."The West is NOT responsible for demonizing Muslims and Islam,"....the Muslims are solely responsible for doing that....How do you expect us to react when all you do is seize any pretext to rape, murder and destroy?????That type of animalistic behavior in the name of your prophet and religion make you demons in a civilized world....
56. THEY GOT IT WRONG; ITS THE SETTLEMENTS
MBenFaivol ,   Beverly Hills, USA   (09.14.12)
Its wrong. Its not the Zionists or Israel, or the U.S. for the film, its the settlements. Its the Israeli settlements that's the cause of the Syrian civil war. Its the Israeli settlements that's the cause of why the Arab Spring started in Tunisia. Its the Israeli settlements that's responsible for the Egyptian overthrow of Mubarak. Its the Israeli settlements that are responsible for the Iranian's nuclear bomb ambitions. Its the Israel settlements that are responsible for my cat having kittens. Did I miss many other false canards or other great Muslim thinking????
57. Arab made film
Chaim Ben Kahan ,   Efrat, Israel   (09.15.12)
Ironic, no???
Previous talkbacks
Back to article