News
Navy seizes Gaza-bound Finnish ship
Yoav Zitun
Published: 20.10.12, 22:06
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
139 Talkbacks for this article
61. Vivi 36 . It's LEGAL
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.20.12)
Was declared a legal act of defense .
62. Kitty 37 . They have everything they need
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.20.12)
And , if needed , they can have medical treatement in Israel for difficult cases .
63. Wasn't aware that Israel
Andre Villas Boas ,   Tottenham Hotspur   (10.20.12)
now has responsigbility tfor Egypt's territorial waters. The Estelle was captured in Egypt's soveriegn territory, I hope for an appropriate response from Egypt shortly
64. They are so critical of Israel yet they know
David ,   Israel   (10.20.12)
That they can perform such a wasteful act without being sunk or murdered at sea like would have happened to them had they tried breaching any Arab country's sovereignty
65. the estelle......
patrick a.hammel ,   zermatt,switzerland   (10.20.12)
Do not release the parliament members from Greece and Spain before both countries repay their salaries to the European Union.After all I don't think European workers would agree that their money is being lended (given) so that Greeks and Spaniards can go on a cruise or go on strike every second day instead of looking for a job.....
66. #13 Mladen
MR   (10.20.12)
Excellent!
67. #36 Vivfant -Tell that to your Government
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (10.20.12)
which is encouraging Arabs to attack Israel
68. # 15, # 16
MR   (10.20.12)
Thank you for your reasuring words regarding the Finnish people. However, this boat is sailing under a Finnish FLAG. Anything sailing under a Finnish flag is the responsibility of the Finnish government and as long as that government doesn't say otherwise, it represents Finland. May I suggest that you post your thoughts in a Finnish web site that may make a difference. Please don't get me wrong, I have much sympathy for the Finnish people.
69. The copncrete would be used to build
Reuven   (10.20.12)
tunnels to smuggle weapond into Gaza. Ten years in prison is needed for each of the Israel-haters aboard.
70. Jail & pay hefty bail before release!
Benny ,   Iran   (10.20.12)
To prevent these bumbling idiotic radicals from such acts, confiscate their ship & send them to jail & make them pay a hefty fine for playing with Jewish lives. Europe is already in the throes of Islam & their radicals. They will pine for Israeli justice when they meet their fate with the Islamist terrorists!
71. #34 ,MORON
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (10.20.12)
Passenger on board the ship you mentioned, didn't make the voyage just to get their pictures in the news, those of the Estelle did
72. #40 Jouko - Lest you forgot
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (10.20.12)
Crusades, Spanish Inquisition, Pogroms all incited & carried out by Priests
73. 46 , cement in a ship without holds ?
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.20.12)
Where was this cement then , if not in one of the two holds ? And insulting people [ even if they are 100 % wrong as in this case ] shows again your "level"
74. Andre 63 , International waters are NOT Egyptian
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.20.12)
Read what the Israeli guy on board said , don't invent untrue facts .
75. The flotilla fools
KATE ,   ISRAEL   (10.20.12)
When will these deluded fools understand that Gaza has everything needing nothing barring the STOPPING of their lobing rockects everyday into innocent Jewish civiians. It would behoove these lot to read the Hamas Charter before embarking on another stupid venture. They sure have far too much EMPTY TIME on their hands . When will this comedy stop? Firstly the BLOCKADE IS LEGAL Secondly if they insist then Ashdod waits for them. Frankly it angers me on the fact of inflicting more work on our people having unwanted additional work they have enough to carry out without these damn silly people .
76. #63 what do you want to be when you grow up?
raquel squelch ,   not in kansas   (10.20.12)
I have egyptian friends living and working in the sinai and they can do without anything else bringing them closer to violence and further from tourist dollars. the estelle got what it hoped for and all its goods will still get to gaza but its not enough for you? what more? a long term egyptian israel border closure so the families of taba staff can go hungry? what about another three way border skirmish so some mothers can mourn? maybe the tension could go high enough to turn sharm into a ghost town of unemployed egyptian youth? you have no evidence the estelle was seized in egyptian waters (and it almost certainly wasnt) or what effect that would have on the legality of all parties actions if it was. when are you "pro arab" self righteous types going to actually get around to being pro arab?
77. Olive trees?
Lippy ,   Proud Israeli   (10.20.12)
Olive trees in the cargo? Are they nuts? There is a world olive glut and everyone is pulling trees out!
78. To: No. 63
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.20.12)
Israel has the right to enforce its fully legal and internationally recognized blockade of Gaza ANYWHERE. What part of the word ANYWHERE do you not understand?
79. Viv Fiant Ohio
Daniel ,   Tel Aviv   (10.20.12)
Poor Vivi: If a blockade against a terrorist organization is a problem for you please invite the Russians to put missiles in Cuba again. Better still why don't you take a ship up the Somali coast? Be sure there are no Israeli security guards on your ship. As an American tax payer you should just trust your country to keep you safe. I trust mine to attempt to do the same. Sadly we fight a war against terrorists not nations on a daily basis. Missiles fly out of Gaza and land in Israel near kindergartens and pizza parlours. Finland, Norway and Spain as nations understand this. Only foolish people who believe terrorist propaganda think there is a humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Running the blockade is illegal and anyone who attempts it can LEGALLY be sunk by the Israeli military. That Israel hasn't done this is proof of Israel's humanitarian nature. Were the positions reversed I promise you Hamas would sink vessels
80. YOU CAN LIE TO MANY LITTLE TIME
X   (10.20.12)
BUT YOU CAN NOT LIE TO EVERYONE ALL THE TIME
81. To: No. 73
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (10.20.12)
Gosh, Charles, why don't you watch or read the news? The cement was on pallets ON THE DECK OF THE VESSEL. Get a fricken' education, can't you? No, of course you can't. You're far too stupid. Pauvre con, toi! Just get lost.
82. Ship Seizure
Herbert ,   Austin, USA   (10.20.12)
BRAVO! It is wonderful to see some good news for a change. Naturally, our state run media here has not, and will not report on this matter. I wonder if Mr. obama will call this an act of terrorism? The murder of our ambassador and others, the massacre at Ft. Hood stc., were not considered terrorism by this pro islamist administration.....but siezure of a ship? How awful. What an inconvenience for the "Usual suspects" - islamists, communists and their ilk on board this ship. Again, a huge BRAVO to Israel and its leadership for this act. Israeli leadership, obviously does not "Lead from behind" as our present administration does.
83. Pver 10 thousand dead but nobody cares
David Israel ,   New Yurk, USA   (10.20.12)
Only recently over 10 thousand people died in Syria. Hundreds of thousands had to leave their homes as refugees to neighboring countries. They need food, clothes and shelter, they don't care about iPhones but not one ship sails to help them. Not one so called humanitarian activist acts for them. If this is not hypocrisy if this is not anti Semitism what is it?
84. #37 Kitty of Sweden
Daniel ,   Tel Aviv   (10.20.12)
Your understanding is sadly misinformed. You need to check the law first. Israel has a legal right to blockade Gaza. Humanitarian aid can and is brought in via land crossings. The need for these supplies is actually fairly limited Gaza has most of what it needs in terms of medical and basic necessities. The ship was offered safe passage to the legal port of Ashdod and refused to go. Legally Israel could sink the ship but chose to board it instead and force it to Ashdod. I hope that helps with your "understanding." If not, do some research on your own
85. Man without a country
Sidney ,   USA   (10.20.12)
There is an American short story, ""The Man Without a Country" is a short story by American writer Edward Everett Hale, first published anonymously in The Atlantic in December 1863." that should guide the government of Israel. Take away the Israeli citizenship and passport of these Israeli traitors aboard. Let them go to Sweden, South Africa, Iran, or hell but not pollute Israel.
86. Gaza bound ship
Mark ,   Pasadena, USA   (10.20.12)
These aging hippies on the good ship Estelle, watched one too many episodes of Gilligan's Island. The photo posted shows them smug, with an inflated sense of infantile self importance. They pretend to care about the manufactured issue of Gaza but in reality only gloat on seeing themselves in the press.
87. 2 #10
ol ,   nj   (10.20.12)
are u talking about Finland?
88. It is time to make people like that financially
leo ,   usa   (10.20.12)
responsible for all the trouble they have caused. Make them part with $20K - $30K and that should do it. Keep them safe and well looked after, but incarcerated and incommunicado with the rest of the World until their obligations are paid off. While at it keep running the tap to encourage speedy response.
89. 81 , give your source
Charles ,   Petach Tikva   (10.20.12)
And , intervene in territorial waters of an other country ? Insults is the only thing that comes ou of your mouth [ sale bec }
90. Confiscate everything, try and imprison everyone
YairJ   (10.20.12)
Make it clear to the next ones that it will cost them dearly.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article