Jewish Scene
'Islamization of Europe a good thing'
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 11.11.12, 13:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
144 Talkbacks for this article
61. Europe has never been civilized
Jorge   (11.12.12)
It is a land of constant warfare across the centuries, that has been intolerant to the extreme of those of diferent faiths, it is the land of Inquisition, crusades, pogroms and the holocaust, and has always tried to avoid recognizing its terrible guilt for all the bloodshed iniciated there, you people there, have even the chutzpa of preaching to others how to behave, Europe has never shown remorse for the evil it has done to others, and the conquest and destruction on better civilizations
62. Yes, some prophets have said so.
Beary White ,   Norway   (11.12.12)
..like islam is the curse, and europeans, including norwegians have to pay for the killing of jews. The follower of islam is multiplying with increasing rate and will in some few decades outnumber the origin europeans, and begin a new arab spring. Have you ever wondered why muslims flee their own contries to get into the western and taking their evil religion with them??
63. painful to watch this rabbi
Iranian Hunter   (11.12.12)
it is like watching a jew supporting islamist or nazi just for the sake of being anti christian. it will backfire, it will not benefit the jews in long term, very short sighted, very un jewish, and very dumb.
64. All this talk of modesty somehow only impacts women
Global Citizeen ,   Israel & USA   (11.12.12)
as if the real issue is perhaps men's lack of control. When is the last time Islamists attacked a scantily clad male? Demanded that males cover themselves with barely an airhole? Same for extremists Jews, too. Amazing how all this male supremacy stuff is "belied" by putting down females. Putting DOWN, like euthanasia.
65. Nutty Rabbi...
John ,   Akron, USA   (11.12.12)
Cannot see the obvious in various European nations where Jews are being attacked by Muslims, not Christians. When the Christians start believing the Muslims, and stop protecting the Jews, will the good Rabbi be there to help out? In addition, his comments only make white gentiles, and Christians, hate Jews. Maybe that is his true desire, to keep up the persecution. He is one sick man.
66. Kill all whites
Bernard Lazare ,   Ontario,Canada   (11.12.12)
The good rabbi is right. We should do our best and ensure that the white race dies off by choking their nations with as many violent Muslims and Africans as we can until every white man lies dead and every white woman lies raped by immigrants and forced into birthing brown babies. We can do this because of the shoah.
67. the religion in Europe is Leftism, not Christianity
Mike Eskenazi ,   San Diego, CA   (11.12.12)
Europe's religion isn't Christianity anymore. It is leftism. Europe's virulent, immoral socialism usually doesn't agree with Islam, except to sometimes criticize Israel and the American Constitution. I don't think Islam will replace socialism, but rather have to share power with it.
68. A Darwin Award for the Rabbi...
M. Davison ,   Ra'anana, Israel   (11.12.12)
This rabbi deserves a Darwin Award. I hope he hasn't reproduced yet...
69. Rabbi Efrat should show the Jewish way.
(11.11.12)
Israel is to be "a light unto the nations". Rabbi Efrat would serve Hashem/ the Lord by promoting this, especially in the Noahide Laws and leave the vengeance to Hashem. And there are still even in Judaism those who are having a difficult time being able to go the Halachic way to to various reasons of which these social-economic reasons are a factor. The news of prostitutes and LBGT parades doesn't serve Halaka or Jewish standards. Elections are in the horizon. Aside from this and Jacobs and Esaus blessing, these are issues where there is going to need to be a firm united stance. There's no time to lose.
70. Does this rabbi run a PR dept?
Mark ,   London, UK   (11.12.12)
Otherwise how else would such a piece of verbal garbage make it into even the gutter press.
71. Rabbi loves Islam
Lea ,   Barcelona SZpain   (11.11.12)
A priest can be defrocked. What about this rabbi? Why must we put up with so many home-grown fools?
72. Who cares? He is correct, get over it.
TzVi   (11.12.12)
73. Babylon gave to the rabbis traditions and now he gives back
Josh   (11.12.12)
74. So the Rabbi wants revenge on Europe, losing identity.
Art   (11.12.12)
The Rabbi is being a hypocrite. He says it is good for the gentiles and then he says it is revenge on them. Oppression, whether by a Rabbi or by a Mulsim of women to make men listen to messages so they can be rewarded with a wife, is simply mental controls and a trap whether for Hebrews or Gentiles. To rubber stamp them as good followers, of course is viewed by this Rabbi as not just OK but good. Birds of a feather. It is anti Torah to support any religion that takes the words of Moses and Torah out of context. In doing so this man has proven himself unfit to lead and lacking in wisdom. Apparently the Rabbi as well as the other hypocritical religions all missed Dev 13. Hypocrites admiring hypocrytes,
75. Islamization of Europe a good thing
Bryan ,   Calgary, Canada   (11.12.12)
Perhaps Rabbi Efrati should consider changing his name to 'Hananiah son of Azzur'! (Ref: Jeremiah 28:15)
76. Karma.
Bill Weavers ,   Australia   (11.12.12)
This rabbi only tells one side of the story. I strongly believe in karma at times like this. Jews always think they are persecuted by why are they moving back to Germany opening up coffee shops? When a situation suits them everything is "ok." Repeat, I strongly believe in karma at times like this. Because look Israel is 20% Muslim. Have fun racist Jews!
77. the rabbis sponsored bar kochba
sweeter ,   far away   (11.12.12)
and they lost that comnflict with the roman empire, after intial success including the anihilation of the roman 22nd. legion, big time. very big time. historians reckon that close to one million jews were anihilated by the romans in judea subsequently. all because of the rabbis holy war, their jihad. all that led to anti-semitism in the roman empire which led to etc etc.. dear rabbis, get over your failure, and take responsibility for your terrible decisions which are paid for to this day.
78. suicidal religionist crackpot
Leo ,   Haifa, Israel   (11.12.12)
What a complete and utter idiot, this rabbi is ! A medievalist traitor to the civilization. Islamization must be stopped. Long live free, "infidel" Europe !
79. fool..
Ummah Gummah ,   NY NY USA   (11.12.12)
. Tell it to Gilad Shalit, rabbi! Maybe if you rabbi types were obliged to do your hare in Israel's security you'd be singing a different song! .
80. Dangerous Rabbi
Moishe Lipshitz ,   Wood Green London   (11.12.12)
At least he's telling the truth, history forever repeating itself since Babylonian times
81. #52. You are ignorant of History
Tom W ,   USA   (11.12.12)
During those 700 years you cite, Europeans incessantly fought Islam; - does the Battle of Vienna ring the bell? Nowadays Europeans INVITE! the Islamists, provide preferential treatment and financial help for them - and get this: forcefully persecute the natives who oppose the "multikultists". Why don't you walk around in your EU cities and behold the changed demography? Bashing the Jews is easier for you than opening your eyes to world around you?
82. No. 23 Roger
NYC Girl   (11.12.12)
As an atheist, I have no use for rabbis like this one. However, when you make the comment that when you hear the word halacha, you reach for your revolver....you're the bigger goddamn racist.
83. Reply to 47
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (11.12.12)
The expulsion of the Jews from England took place in 1290, quite a few years back. I didn't forget the Spanish Inquisition. I gave a few examples of countries that did not persecute Jews in recent centuries, compared to the Islamic lands that pushed Jews out beginning in 1948.
84. CHRISTIAN VS. MUSLIM
TOM ,   NEW YORK   (11.12.12)
THE RABBI IS WRONG , THE RAMBAM WAS AWARE OF BOTH CHRISTIAN & MUSLIM PERSECUTION , JEWS HAVE BEEN PERSECUTED FOR THE LAST 1800 YEARS WHEN CONSTANTINE MADE CHRISTIANITY THE OFFICIAL RELIGION OF THE ROMAN EMPIRE. WHETHER IT WAS GERMAN LUTHERANS , ROMAN CATHOLICS, OR ORTHODOX , JEWS WERE KILLED BY THE SAME RELIGIONS IN THE HOLOCAUST . HAVE YOU EVER HEARD OF A MASS RALLY BY PRIESTS TO SUPPORT JEWS IN THE FACE OF ARAB TNREATS ? THE SECULAR ALLIES IN THE PRESS AND THE EU COMPLAIN WHEN ISRAEL BUILDS A HOUSE , BUT NEVER WHEN ARABS FIRE 100 ROCKETS IN A A DAY.
85. Good idea
BiksNud ,   Jerusalem, Israel   (11.12.12)
But because Israel is just an outpost of Europe, and is situated in the Levant, the Islamization of Europe must begin with Israel.
86. Number 62 Welfare state
Joseph ,   London UK   (11.12.12)
Post WW II Western Europe created a welfare system to help society recover from the war. More recently we have seen our welfare system used to support unwed teenage mothers, Islamist terrorists whom we spent years trying to deport, and many failed asylum seekers who have disappeared into the woodwork. Many Muslims no doubt arrive in Europe fleeing from Sharia regimes, but some of their children become radicalised and join overseas Islamic students in our universities in their dangerous behaviour. The crux is the very high Muslim birth rate and the very low non-Muslim birth rate.
87. Facts and figures for UK
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (11.12.12)
We are often told, mainly by my fellow Amerocan posters -- that the UK is becoming an Islamic state. In the 2011 census there were about sixty million Brits, of whom two point eight million are Muslims. That's a bit less than five per cent. On the religion question about 80% described themselves as 'broadly Christian.' The USA census does not ask religion, but the figures for American Muslims range from six to nine million, double or triple the UK figure, although a lower %.
88. Islamization also good for USA
Dan ,   NJ, USA   (11.12.12)
The USA is also benefiting from a good dose of Islamic values. With Muslim students inundating the public school system, their parents are pushing back on the depravity that passes for education in America. Muslim students are typically exempted from sex education, co-ed gym, contraception, gay studies, evolution, and other pillars of the American public school curriculum. They go to school in modest dress. They take time out to pray. The school administration accommodates them, either because they are mired in political correctness or because they fear a Muslim riot. Either way, a school that caters to Muslims has a more wholesome environment and is more conducive to learning than a typical American public school with its Bolshevik teachers and their social engineering experiments.
89. #87 Sherlock: your faulty math
Tom W ,   USA   (11.12.12)
During the years of Stalin or "H" the number of card carrying party members were quite small in relation to the overall population. Nevertheless they exercised absolute control over the life of the citizenry because party members populated the state apparatus and set the direction of the nation. The elite of the UK is pro-Islamic and will protect the interest of Islam by laws and other administrative means. In the US 13% black and 15% Hispanic vote neutralized the 72% whites of which 35% joined the minority. Talks of the "Old, white men are dying out" - openly posted and promulgated with aplomb. In short: the EU socialist elite will transform the UK into an Islamic country over several decades. BNP and Nigel Farage will be silenced as Geert Wilders is mute now.
90. Anti-Goy
ZombieRabbi ,   Jersey City, USA   (11.12.12)
Get kicked out of one bar, it might not be your fault. Get kicked out of three bars, it's probably your fault.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article