Jewish Scene
'Islamization of Europe a good thing'
Kobi Nahshoni
Published: 11.11.12, 13:52
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
144 Talkbacks for this article
91. I do not think the rav is well informed!
JD ,   NY   (11.12.12)
He is dead wrong! 1. Early Muslims were not the Muslims of today. He is obviously not too aware of what he is talking about - he certainly has no background in early Muslim accomplishments in humanities and sciences. 2. His statement, that he is holding Christianity accountable for atrocities against Jews, does not make sense! Islam is going through te process of radicalization just like Christianity up until Middle Ages. And just like Christians, Muslims will slaughter a lot of Jews before they are stopped! 3. Christianity is not idolatry according to everyone - there are those Rishonim that say it is completely okay for the nations but not for Jews. 4. Christianity believes in dialogue - Islam in force! 5. There are many more reasons - but why waste all this space, if the first five are already compelling?!?!?! So what is he talking about, again?!?!?!
92. time to wake up folks
(11.12.12)
please read the long essay about this at jihadwatch dot org. It is time for Christians and Jews to stop squabbling. The Nazis and the Russian Bolsheviks in the 30s and 40s both indulged in genocide against many different populations including Jews for various reasons which are far more complex than anything to do with Christianity. The least antisemitic folk in Christian countries are the practising Christians ...the far left wing and right wing seculars are more of a problem and essays like the one above add enormous fuel to the fire of conspiracy theories aboutb the Jews being in a plot to destroy other nations via promoting diversity.
93. Sherlock #4
DavidR ,   USA   (11.12.12)
Your statement that Catholics do not worship idols is blatantly false. They most certainly do! Also, all the so called Protestant churches do also as they observe Christmas with its santa clause, Easter, with its egg laying bunnie in the tradition of Tamuz etc. The fact is that both Christianity and Judaism have played the harlot and that is the reason for the diaspora. Read Scripture! It will enlighten you.
94. #39 Jake
DavidR ,   USA   (11.12.12)
I am afraid that it is you who are drinking the cool aid Jake. You are correct that Christians do not properly understand who is Mashiach but there is nothing idolatrous about believing in a "Son" of Eloheim! I myself am one and it is very Biblical. Yeshua was flesh and as such, His flesh cannot be considered "God." However, His Ruach was the Ruach HaKodesh which is very much "Eloheim." But, it is obvious from your post that it will take nothing less than a true spiritual awakening and paradigm shift to get you to see it.
95. agree with the Rabbi 100%
k ,   US   (11.12.12)
screw all you cowards Go read about what Europe did to the Jews I am glad the Muslims are invading
96. Damn, who forgot...
Walt K ,   Sherbrooke, Canada   (11.12.12)
To throw away the keys of his asylum ? If Europe fall, USA and Israel will fall too. Let's think about the youth's future.
97. islamists play god when
Monotheist ,   Maryland, USA   (11.13.12)
they freely take life away do the follow one god? have they left the tradition of noah?
98. The Filthy Jews.....
Rob ,   Los angeles, CA.   (11.13.12)
are finally starting to let the mask drop. Indeed, it was and is they who still promote multiculturalism in white and only white lands in order to genocide white people. This filth will always be humanity's doppelgangers.
99. Good for who
Norman Gellman ,   Rehovot   (11.13.12)
Islamism wants to dominate a country and change its laws their laws. Islam does not tolerate other religions. For example in Saudi Arabia there are no churches or synagogues.
100. You're such an ignorant
Proud Jewish ,   Sefarad (Spain)   (11.13.12)
Europe's Islamization would harm European Jews, Israel, the USA and the whole world you fool! 99% of anti-Semitic attacks in Europe are carried out by Muslims. Anyway Europeans are not to blame for what their ancestors did. Who is killing Jews and want to destroy Israel? Christians? The allies Israel has abroad are Christians. Go read about what Muslims did and are doing now to Jews!
101. #98 Take your meds
Ron ,   US   (11.13.12)
Before you start frothing at the mouth.
102. What the...
Englishman ,   London   (11.13.12)
What a stupid Rabbi!!! Why don't he preach it out in the Holy Land of Israel instead!!! The governments in Europe are Severely breaching Article 2 of UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. http://www.hrweb.org/legal/genocide.html
103. THIS IS LAME YNET - YOU CAN DO BETTER!
Andrew ,   Miami,FL   (11.13.12)
104. Love each other
Christian ,   Suomi Finland   (11.13.12)
"He praises Islam for promoting modesty" - what really is that islamic modesty or this "healthier life"- how it really manifests itself in practise? And when you look at many of those islamic countries - you get a very good picture of what kind is the status of non-muslims or even muslim minorities. And what about women's situation? But anyway Christians are already nowadays the most persecuted religious group in the world - so don't worry, be patient rabbi! No really - the revenge is not ours. But what comes to Israel - are muslims really that great allies and supporters of Israel when comparing to Christians. USA by the way is very Christian - and many americans are from European Origin. But how can anyone even talk about Europe, European culture or European history without talking about Jews? Are't they also essential part of Europe because of their enormous impact?
105. #95 K
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (11.13.12)
You will be next. That should wipe the smile off your face.
106. Inquisition
Jay ,   UK   (11.13.12)
We need another inquisition....world wide this time.We want you jews and muslims out . jew do you remember what happened the last time you were asked to leave, and you wouldn't?
107. Rabbi supports genocide against whites?
Janet ,   Seattle, USA   (11.13.12)
SOOO, this rabbi wishes to go on the record as supporting white genocide..? He may want to re-think this. While Christians are forgiving, International Law on this subject is not.
108. rabbi
T'oma ,   Denver,USA   (11.13.12)
First and foremost, the god of islam is NOT Ha Shem. Second, it won't seem so good when the muslims control all of Europes nuclear weapons.
109. This man is a complete idiot, the famous
J.K. ,   Brooklyn USA   (11.13.12)
19 century jester,Hershele of Ostropolia,was seen dancing while his house vent up in flames,when people asked him about his strange behavior,Hershele responded ,that's my revenge on the bed bugs.
110. I am Christian
Paulo Morgado ,   Portugal   (11.13.12)
I believe that God gave the land(and not only what is there now but more) to the Jews, and I don't agree that Israel shoulg give land in exchange for 'peace'(this is an utopia it will never work with ISLAM) as their prophecies call for the end of Israel. The Jews are God's people. I don't believe in a Trinity, I think that is just completely wrong. Am I worse than a muslim who can't see the name "Israel" without feeling hatred? I pray for the peace of Jerusalem every day. I agree that the so called Christians(mostly Catholics/Trinitarians) played the true Christian for ages but they were not true Christians, they just usurped the place of true Christianity, they killed Jews but also lots of Christians because these didn't conform to their views on religion. Power corrupts. Even if you don't believe in Jesus, his teaching never teach hate or killing or mixing with politics. Now look at Islam and you'll see the opposite is true. We Christians are not guilty for some who played the christian and did a lot of harm. Shalom aleikhem
111. Islam and Europe.
Al ,   Glasgow, UK   (11.14.12)
This rabbi is hysterical, misinformed and deluded. If Europe WERE Christian, which it never really has been, then Israel would have no threat on its doorstep. On the other hand if Europe became Islamic...well fill in the space anyway you like but it won't be pretty.
112. The US president will turn his back
Jay ,   USA   (11.14.12)
on israel when Iran drops the bomb on them ROTHFLMFAO
113. roger zurich the nutcase
The Lady, zurich   (11.14.12)
when I see the name roger zurich switzerland I want to dig a hole and hide. The idiot is suicidal! trouble is he would probably take a lot with him. Ugggggh he gives me the creeps. Maybe the poor guy is going mental and desperately seeks help.
114. Finally!
Joe Bull ,   Bristol, UK   (11.14.12)
I always thought the conspiracy lunatics were just barking mad, when they said SOMEONE must have an agenda to keep Africa for Africans, Asia for Asians, and white countries for EVERYONE. Now it all makes sense. Sadly these kind of statements from Jewish rabbis just reinforces antisemitic sentiments.
115. Islamisation of Europe
John Marsh ,   Bridgetown Barbados   (11.14.12)
Religion is quite simply an insidious virus on humanity .
116. baruch the racist rabbi
drew ,   walla walla , wa   (11.14.12)
Pure jealousy. this is a great article. could go viral.
117. And there falls the Mask!
Cristão Branco ,   Portugal   (11.14.12)
A sincere Rabbi, at long last! I find it great that Zionists are finally revealing out loud who they side with. This will make it much harder for them to conceal the truth once again when Europe awakens. And beware, for it's already starting to happen.. ;)
118. When Rabbi Efrati was 8 days old
Jerry ,   home   (11.15.12)
The "Mohel" must have made a mistake and chopped off some of the wrong end. Otherwise, his comments display at best a two digit IQ, if not lower. Read Articles Seven of the "Hamas Covenant" and then consider sending him to Hamas Land in Gaza and then treat the Rabbi either as an idiot which probably he is, or, alternatively, as a traitor.
119. Tom New York
Mercy   (11.15.12)
Please do me a big favour by not writing all CAPITALS. It's an eyesore so I just pass over it to read all other messages.
120. Response from a Christian
Tammy ,   Ontario, Canada   (11.18.12)
I have prayed with weeping before the God of Abraham for the peace of Jerusalem these past few days. I pray always for your peace but have been disturbed to tears at this latest conflict. I love the Jewish people and the land of Israel and despite what you think of me as a Christian I will continue to pray for your nation. One day, Israel will be the joy of the whole earth and I cannot wait until you are exalted as a nation, for the glory of God, forever and ever.
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article