News
Report: Netanyahu told Obama Israel not planning ground op
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 18.11.12, 06:09
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
46 Talkbacks for this article
31. You must have gotten wrong report
Bridget   (11.18.12)
Should be asking your own govt. If necessary, ground op will advance. Preparations underway. Not about Hamas' demands and Arab world/US wishful thinking...
32. 25
zionist forever   (11.18.12)
Since the Suez war I think the only military operation Israel has ever conducted without prior US backing was the hit on Saddam Hussain's nuclear reactor in 1981. Even in 1967 we asked US permission before deciding to preempt so the fact Bibi is going to Obama who he hates is just following decades of protocol especially as he needs US support to stop the UN Security Council on this.
33. There is no leadership and I couldn't
DT ,   TA Israel   (11.18.12)
agree more. Guaranteed we will be back in there in a year or so if not sooner juts like it was a dead certainty after Cast Lead
34. wars never are never black & white
zionist forever   (11.18.12)
All war is always about plans and alternative plans because the political and military situation changes by the hour its never black and white. Even with the best plans sometimes they need to be changed very quickly because of unexpected incidents. A ground war should be avoided if there is a practical alternative that can achieve results but the IDF casualties will be high although we must keep all options on the table which Bibi appears to have as the amount of armour and reserves called up to the border is not just there for show. If there is a ground war it probably won't happen for another couple of days at least because the IDF wants to damage the capabilities of Hamas to fire rockets or kill soldiers if there is a ground operation so we shouldn't expect to see tanks rolling within the next couple of hours. Bibi is also the best out of a bad bunch when it comes to elections unless we prefer the likes of Yair Lapid or Shelly Y whose military experience was journalism and have very little political experience either. Bibi is dealing with Obama because other than the bombing of Saddam Hussain's nuclear reactor no Israeli government has carried out any military operation without approval of the US first. Israel needs US support in the UN Security Council who can pass resolutions ordering Israel to halt operations immediately. Like it or not we need American support and there are always going to be red lines. We just need to do as much damage as we can before the US steps in and causing minimum Israeli casualties.
35. ground atack in gaza
arie pencovici ,   haifa   (11.18.12)
tel aviv is being bombed And other cities Ashkelon Ashdod Would the uk (london) agree to be bombed for 5 days, 600 bombs without a imediate fierce reaction???? Air and ground Would Paris accept it? Belgium? The US???!!
36. They already not only escalated.
Miron ,   USA   (11.18.12)
They are firing 100,000 / launch rockets daily. And they are paying for those rockets with US cash given for Gaza as a charity, as part of Oslo agreement. 3 bn / dollars per year cash assistance. Time to cut the feeding hand. The Congress must convene, now, and enact end of any assistance to the terrorists, and pass it over Obama's head with supermajority.
37. Don't sell Bibi short
Jeffrey in Boston ,   Boston, USA   (11.18.12)
He knows Obama hates him and Israel and is a Muslim Brotherhood member. The Daily Beast is nothing more than liberal, left wing, propaganda site. News story is geared to dispirit Israelis and box in Bibi. Information dissemination by Bibi will be done to confuse the terrorist enemy. Bibi will be sly like a fox. Bibi won't be a fumbler, bumbler, moron like Olmert, Livni, & co. No worries.
38. HMmmm, Support PLO Destroys Hamas, eh?
Jersey Jew ,   New Jersey, USA   (11.18.12)
Reality: Israel reaps what she sows. The reality is that there will always be millions, yes millions of Palestinians who by Israel's own behaviours are represented by a very weak, ELECTED PA government who in frustration, are now ignoring both Israel and our looon-time enabling USA, will achieve Vatican-type status at the UN. This status will lead to criminal charges against Israel at the International Court ... what does Idrael fear??? Does Israel believe that she is legally an International criminal??? Israel's best path forward is to strengthen the PA and jointly with enabler USA destroy Hamas and behave according to Judaic values towards the inevitable Palestinian state. Inevitable reality people, and best for Israel, our USA and the world ...
39. Who cares what the stable-boy thinks?!!!
Jake Stone ,   USA   (11.18.12)
They haven't amassed these resources and troops for nothing! Netanyahu is playing Obama; he doesn't care what that paper-pussy cat thinks. Obama's a joke, and all of the ME thinks so! Israel is on its own, humanly speaking; but, they're not alone, because God fights for them...God also laughs at Obamanutless. Israel will win bigtime, and Obamanutless is going to look like the weak leader he is! God bless, Israel; praying for the peace of Jerusalem!!!
40. Me thinketh that Bibi talks too damn much
BEN JAJBO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (11.18.12)
to Obama, an enemy of Israel
41. Obma = New Shikelgruber
Ish Kabibble ,   Delancey   (11.18.12)
42. Beyond belief
Miche Norman ,   Hod Hasharon   (11.18.12)
If Bibi has made these assurances - he is sending a message to Hammas - just keep on at the present rate and we won't come in - so why are we paying 75000 miluimnikim for to endanger their lives - just as a threat to hammas not to increase the rate of fire - which they should not be able to if the IAF is doing its job???!!!
43. Jake Stone # 39
Eaglebeak ,   Left Coast, USA   (11.18.12)
Jimmy Carter wasn't nutless (peanuts) and like Obama he wasn't any good either. It's a good thing Israel has God to rely on because nobody should rely on Obama for anything. God bless Israel!
44. to no 40 who is talking to much BS in most of the talbacks
Ari ,   Jerusalem   (11.18.12)
This newspaper and BenHorin are puting words in BIBI's mouth that were not said. You guys think the Israel ia Going to call 75.000 reservists only for politics? You are crazy Of course the Worlds is presing BIBI not to launch a Ground operation. But his answe has been we are prepared for a widr operation. Nobody is backing away. This is not a decision of onlt BIBI is a decision of a Security7 Gavinet and the IDF high officers. The talkbacker think this is a movie or a beiball game that you yell when making a Hit. This more than that. And the truth is that the Military should impose a Military censure lkike it was during the 6 day war. To much is published, and the enemy also reads. so Beware
45. 40-Ari -Have you heard of Military Secrets?
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRAEL   (11.19.12)
You don't inform the enemy "Loose lips sink ships"
46. # Ari - rest assured that mhy
BEN JABO (MACHAL) ,   ISRASEL   (11.19.12)
Mispar Zavai is a littlle older than yours, witnh more experience to match Politican 's have a tenden cy to talk too much , just like you
Previous talkbacks
Back to article