News
US media: Israel may win battle but Hamas wins war
Yitzhak Benhorin
Published: 20.11.12, 13:05
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
79 Talkbacks for this article
61. "How Hamas Won The War"
Mark Saichek ,   Milwaukee, Wisconsin   (11.20.12)
I guess Mr. Miller and Mr. Goldberg feel that Israel's best strategic response to Hamas aggression is; surrender. What a penetrating analysis. Why didn't Bebe think of that?
62. Journalists Should read the polls
Mea   (11.20.12)
63. #6 Jason
David   (11.20.12)
Would you mind shutting your silly mouth. Can't you stop your silly politics at least temporarily while people are dying and being injured?
64. Nonsense!
Carl (not #1) ,   USA   (11.20.12)
It is only because of the media's biased one-sided reporting that the Hamas terrorists have any traction at all. Media portrays a "tit-for-tat" equality, instead of contantly stressing the random Hamas attacks against civilians and Israel's precision strikes against weapons and military targets. And the death toll is always just "Palestinian" with no mention that half to two-thirds have been combatants. Hundreds of Hamas terror missiles have resulted in few Israeli casualties because of effective civil defense and Iron Dome. Many hundreds of successful Israeli strikes resulted in relatively few Palestinian civilian casualties because of the extraodinary care and accuracy of the IDF. But the media much prefers playing up the human shields that Hamas holds up to sacrifice.
65. #37 - Arabs invaded and bombed TA, Jerusalem in '48
William ,   Israel   (11.20.12)
and looked how we survived since then? Israel is extremely powerful, has a very good economy, and a high tourist trade. and since 1948 the "palestinans" have....brought themselves more destruction, allowed their Arab brethren to force them into refugee camps in the hopes of one day destroying Israel, and allowing terrorists to place rockets right next to their own kids. You need UN aid to get education and employment. You need an "enemy" to blame and take your minds off your own responsibilities. Your own "export" is terrorism and a narrative based on a fake history, and you still claim Israel blockades Gaza when Gazans are over-weight and Egypt left the backdoor open. AreYOU sure you're able to survive in the region?
66. #38 - yeah, but its been that way for decades
William ,   Israel   (11.20.12)
and still the Gazans eat it up because its what they desire, not what they see.
67. #48 - I would say a pretty damn big deterrent
William ,   Israel   (11.20.12)
and proof that an urban battle with terrorists hiding behind civilians can indeed result in a low civilian death count. Bibi took away the main weapon of Hamas and Islamic Jihad - the Gazan population as shields. I know you're still salivating over the "Israeli loss" but consider this - even with a self-described victory by Hizbullah in 2006 Israel still received quiet on its Northern front. Now let's see what Hamas had to give up to get the cease-fire.
68. #48 - "Ceasefire begins at 6:30pm Israel time"
William ,   Israel   (11.20.12)
Let's see how many minutes it takes before Gazans break it....again.
69. Abbas is a much more dangerous enemy than Hamas.
Chaim ,   Israel   (11.20.12)
Hamas are honest terrorists. They are genocidists and don't pretend to be anything else. Abbas, on the other hand, is a dishonest genocidist. Abbas and the P.A. have the same goals as Hamas but they use slightly different tactics. Abbas is a much more dangerous enemy than Hamas.
70. To #69 Abbas is enemy of right wings because he wants peace?
jon ,   USA   (11.20.12)
Abbas told the Israeli TV that he will give up the right of return. What did Netaniaho? spit in his eyes. Regardless of politics, the reality is that status qua is impossible to maintain. I suggest that all right wings get together and invade Aza. There they will find their match in fanaticism.
71. #70. Nothing fanatical about keeping our tiny land.
Chaim ,   Israel   (11.20.12)
#70. There is nothing fanatical about Jews keeping our tiny land, which is about a six hundredth the size of the Arab lands. This land is ours, has been ours for more than 3,500 years and always will be ours. Abbas is a Holocaust denying terrorist who is far more dangerous than the honest Hamas terrorists. Israel should let Hamas have Abbas and the P.A. for breakfast. Then drive them out of our land, where they don't belong.
72. If Sarah B can peak out of her underground bunker...
Marco ,   Spain   (11.20.12)
and see what is going on and how bad Israel is losing this war, then may be, just may be she can buy a one way ticket to the U.S... It would be one less idiot to worry about on this site...
73. #10 Salma -In the 6 Day War Egypt Tried their Propoganda
meir elazar   (11.20.12)
and Egyptian announced "We are Winning in all Brassieres". He wanted to say "Fronts" but did not know the correct plural and came out "Brassieres" [Hayiyot instead of Hazitot]. So please dish out more of your comedy routine. We could use a good laugh right now.
74. Do You want to know who Really Won?
meir elazar   (11.20.12)
Today I took my mother for service on her hearing aid in Kiryat Bialik and the Audiologist was an Arab. I went to a Home Repair Store in Haifa and the wonderful guy who helped me was also an Arab and we have been friends for years. I also took my mother to the Health Care Center Kupat Holim Zevulun and both Arabs and Israeli medical staff work together to care for ALL patients regardless of religion or other factors. You can see this over and over in one store after another in Haifa, Krayot, Akko, and other cities in this area. We live together in TRUE PEACE AND PROSPERITY but this never makes the headlines. If only HAMAS knew what they could have if only they were not obsessed with our destruction. But every terrorist action ends with a counter-terrorist measure and the quality of life (if there is any) only continues to get worse. There are not options left.
75. Salma no 10
LION OF JUDAH ,   Jews fight like LION   (11.21.12)
Of course Palestinians won 3 DOWN Keep smoking $$$$
76. hamuda Gaza no 37
QUDS AL YAHUDI ,   QUDS HAKA AL YAHUD   (11.21.12)
hamuda, You better go and listen to the music called hamuda, hamuda, and relax.
77. Marco bankrupt spain
(11.21.12)
you have been drinking too much wine. not yet X,mas
78. More loony Left non-sense.
Sherlock Holmes ,   London England   (11.21.12)
When has the NY Times not been hostile to Israel? The real solution would be to give Gaza back to Egypt. Israel tried to return Gaza to Egypt when negotiating the peace treaty, but Egypt refused to accept Gaza. Let the Arab League and the UN consider it. Hamas is linked to Iran, who want a port on the Mediterranean. The Arabs and the EU do NOT want an Iranian port on the Med.
79. Never Take Advise From Haters
Paul ,   New York   (11.21.12)
The media taking this position have always reported on how bad actions taken by Israel are for Israel. They thought the west bank barrier would never work, but it did. They felt then operation against the WB in 2002 would fail, but it did not. They insist Israel lost in Lebanon in 2006, but we see Hezbollah sitting on their hands. Publications like the NYT, in the end, want to see Israel defenseless and terminated. They would object to such a characterization, but their advice would always lead to that result.
Previous talkbacks
Back to article