Opinion
In the service of the Palestinians
Elyakim Haetzni
Published: 23.04.13, 20:06
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
69 Talkbacks for this article
31. apologise?
rm ,   Amsterdan, NL   (04.24.13)
Has Israel ever apologised for anything it has done to the Palestinians...gimme a break....
32. #10 bs
solomon ,   bklyn   (04.24.13)
Ever wonder why the area is called Judea, not arabia? Ever wonder why the British named it Philistina (after long-gone Philistines) to keep Jews out, but not to keep arabs out? Hint; there weren’t any arabs. Read some history, then post.
33. Arabs trained and readt to take orders from whom......?
Martin ,   SA   (04.24.13)
Arabs trained and ready to take orders from whom......? An anticipated militantly anti-Jewish governing authority. They cannot be trust to not lift a hand on their perhaps Jewish cousins Let them protect the Irish in the North or the inhabitant in the Falkans far away from us. Thank you to the author for a very factual summary and reminder of the actions of our British well wishers. There is weakness of politician whom dont find it in their heart to apologise for their deeds or those before them. Perhaps the British and its queen can remind themselves those days and bring themselves to apologize so many years later. Perhaps let them look at the players they would like to entrust with these trainees to and reconsider whether they should ever have been involved.
34. Entire article totally irrelevant
Shachar Shalev ,   Eilat   (04.24.13)
There is absolutely no connection between British mandate Palestine and today's British Gov't. It's a bit like blaming Goldberg for sinking the Titanic.....Goldberg, iceberg what's the difference?!
35. arming and training a terror group
Cipora Julianna Kohn ,   Z   (04.24.13)
the uk is beyond the pale. they have an arms embargo on israel while they are arming and training a terror group.
36. 25. Winston Churchill
Jerry ,   IL   (04.24.13)
Adam, this is not correct. Winston Churchill did want to bomb the death camps. It was Arthur "Bomber" Harris, commander of the RAF who refused to endanger British pilots lives for the sake of the Jews. The IG Farben factories at Auschwitz were bombed on several occasions. His rational for not bombing the train lines and stations at the death camps was that the German war machine was expending close to 20% of its resources on moving the Holocaust victims to the camps - an incredible waste for the German army, and an important factor for Allied victory in the Eastern front.
37. Excellent article
AJ - Raalte   (04.24.13)
It's good to remember the historical injustices done to the Jewish people by the British, for once. The UK is not Israel's friend. Do not trust them. And don not trust the US, either. When the going gets tough, Americans abandon their allies. Remember Saigon!
38. THE BRITS NEED TO STAY OUT OF ISRAEL
Scott ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (04.24.13)
They caused enough problems already.
39. (31) rm, Amsterdam
tiki ,   belgium   (04.24.13)
If you would read some history instead of propaganda, you would know a thing or two about the Romans, the Turks & Brits and their role in the Middle East, the Jewish centuries old claims to the lands of Israel and their eviction from them by the parties mentioned above (and others) and about the ''Palestinians" who exist only since Arafat/Carter decided to make them a 'People with a history & land'.
40. No. 19
Madeleine ,   Israel   (04.24.13)
I'm British though living in Israel for nearly 45 years. I have not one iota of pide inthe land of my birth. The Brits have been pigs in every part of the world they occupied - East Africa, India, to name but a few. They treated the indiginous population like sh*t , and have no better record than what you claim for the Stern and Irgun. British policy was then and still is to support the Arabs not the Jews. Never mind, Britain, with its new capital Londonistan, will soon be under sharia law. You are now to weak and cowardly to stand up for your fast-disappearing rights.
41. Lies, lies, lies!
Mohamed ,   Cairo, Egypt   (04.24.13)
42. THROW THE BRITS OUT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Chris Rettenmoser ,   Bayerisch Gmain Germ   (04.24.13)
NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
43. In the sevice of the Palestinians. right of reply # #22 #40
Elsie. ,   Gush Halav.   (04.24.13)
#Sarah,you say 6 million Jews perished becauseof the British is beyond the pale. #22, Harry, why don't you move to Israel? why stay in a country that is arrogant, snotty and don't learn anything?? #40 Madeleine, I hope you only have one passport, the Israeli one! Has Israel ever said sorry to the British soldiers they killed, including my uncle David, no ,I didn't think so
44. In the sevice of the Palestinians.
Elsie. ,   Gush Halav.   (04.24.13)
#23, Sarah, to say England was the cause of 6 million jews who perished in the holocaust is beyond the pale. #22, H arry, you are living in the wrong country,it is treating you so badly. #40 Madeleine, I hope you only have one passport, the Israeli one. Will Israel say sorry for the British soldiers killed during the British Mandate, for my uncle David who was killed by the Jewish, I doubt it.
45. # 25 ADAM you mean the same Churchill
BUILD BABY BUILD ,   United States   (04.24.13)
that also wrote of his hatred of Muslims over 100 years ago? And Thomas Jefferson who initiated theUS Navy to end Arab piracy of American ships?
46. To No. 23
Bertram ,   London, UK   (04.24.13)
I am grateful for this information. It is important to know where the responsibility for the Holocaust really lies since I was under the misapprehension that the Nazis might have had something to do with it.
47. #25 adam #36 jerry #45 build - point of order
solomon ,   bklyn   (04.24.13)
For the record: let us not forget that FDR also refused to bomb the tracks or the extermination camps. And the US could have made more of a difference than England.
48. great article by a great patriot
pinchas ,   boston   (04.24.13)
even if one chooses not to see a connection between imperious and perfidious albion of yesteryear and the morally degenerate UK of today, the article is a worthy historical compilation of gross deeds, big and small, of the British.
49. 36 - RIght but...
Sean ,   london, uk   (04.24.13)
Jew hating Anthony Eden also vetoed the bombing of the camps against Churchill's wishes. Top Jewish historian of the Holocaust and Churchill's official biographer (has access to documents that noone else can see) Martin Gilbert wrote Auschwitz and the Allies. Well worth reading.
50. 25 - you should read this
Sean ,   london, uk   (04.24.13)
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Auschwitz-Allies-Dr-Martin-Gilbert/dp/0712668063 Churchill wanted to bomb the camps but he did not have absolute power despite being PM. It's convenient how many anti-Brits posting here aren't aware of the Balfour declaration...
51. 29 - the IRA
Sean ,   london, uk   (04.24.13)
...no longer exist. Peace processes between extreme enemies can work out and as an anglo-Irish Jew that makes me proud. (PS - plural words do not use apostrophes...)
52. To #40
Ha!   (04.25.13)
So funny that you don't even realize what a hypocrite you are.
53. Ya But! if they would have protect our people
Yosi ,   Gilo-Jerusalem   (04.24.13)
HaSh-m would have protected these Brits, Instead they decided to continue their evil ways and lost so many more young men.
54. Brits training Palestinians
Al Blau ,   Rananna Isr   (04.25.13)
Great article calling a spade a spade clever way to sort of legally. grow terroriists.
55. 40 - I bet you never gave up your UK passport
Ronny ,   Tel Aviv   (04.24.13)
You old codger. With your daily mail rhetoric. Yeah yeah, that old story about how its easier with travel. You're British when it suits you.
56. what a load of nonsense, to rile up the already dumb readers
Sarah Biser ,   New York and Israel   (04.24.13)
Total propaganda.. I'm sometimes ashamed to be from a country (Israel) that spends its days thinking of articles about who hates us today.. oh I get it, lets have 'Op ed' articles with no hard facts just badly thrown cut and paste jobs from other equally bad articles. Who will hate us tomorrow?
57. Bunch of rubbish, the guy lives in the past
David   (04.25.13)
while present and future dictates strong Palestinian control over security is Israeli interest,
58. British Empire
Beer ,   Germany   (04.25.13)
Britain made a mess in ME by creating states according to her colonial interests, e.g. Trans-Jordan. White Paper of 1939 restricted Jews to settle in Land of Israel. Britain was direct helper to Nazi during Holocaust by preventing Jews to find a shelter in Palestine and not acting to destroy Nazi genocide machine. After the WW2 UK continued this policy and placed Jewish refugees to concentration camps on Cyprus, turned back ships with refugees, murdering Jews in Palestine etc. In our days Britons are actively acting against Israelis supporting and commiting act of terror in Tel Aviv Mikes Place bombing (2003), Mumbai attack (2008) to name a few
59. to #58, Germans? WW2? Are you a hyprocrite?
Drorit   (04.25.13)
YES! Are you talking garbage? YES!!!
60. #59 change your glasses
(04.25.13)
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article