Opinion
Disarm Israel of nuclear weapons
Yuval Eylon
Published: 08.09.13, 10:10
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
93 Talkbacks for this article
61. a nuclear bomb does provide an Israeli magical solution
DAV ZEE ,   ATLANTA   (09.08.13)
hitting IRAN: now you see it, now you don't... this is the magic of having the SAMSON option!
62. And this kind of idiots teach in our universities
Yael ,   Tel Aviv   (09.08.13)
Mr Aylon, thanks for proving again that intellectuals can also be the biggest idiots on earth. Go back to teaching philosophy and spare us your stupid, dangerous theories.
63. 27
Bob w ,   West Allis, USA   (09.08.13)
I totally agree with you that this guy should go back to school (not the university), and not only re-take this class, but history of the Middle East in general. It is unbelievable how stupid these people are, and how naive people like this actually live in this world. 9 million Jews were executed by the Germans during WWII, and it seems like the Holocaust is not reminding them how dangerous it is for Jews to disarm, but because it is not these people's skin, who cares right? I am not a Jew, but I love Israel 100%, and I am deeply saddened to see how the world hates Jews and how much hatred they hold against Jews. I very much hope, these Mullahs and their regime is wiped-out of the face of the earth once and for all so that the true Iranian people can live in peace and enjoy good relations with the West and her neighborhoods. Same with Syria, I hope to see the Assad regimen gone, and gone for good, and the Russians with it, because they are as guilty as the same regimen they are protecting anyway. So, long live Israel, and God Bless Jews anywhere in the world!!!!
64. Amen Mr. Eylon !!! ,...
split ,   US   (09.08.13)
Nuke free M. East, back to pre '67 borders, right to return for Pali refugees is the only trail to try that may lead to an acceptance and peace ,...
65. Some jews won't be happy until more jews die
Lawyer ,   Nyc   (09.08.13)
The insanity of ashkenazi self destruction knows no bounds April fools
66. TO # 9
FO ,   Belgium   (09.08.13)
You wrote:..."the same Leftists who imported Arafat, gave Lebanon to Hezbolla and gave Gaza to Hamas". And I would add, the same Leftists, headed by Weizmann and Sokolow who disowned the Jewish State proposed by the League of Nations in 1922 and brought upon the Jewish people the biggest tragedy of its history, the Shoah., by not having an independent state that could have been born before WW II. I disagree with you, when you write that Rabin imported the PLO. In an interview to the Belgian TV, Rabin said; "The so-called PLO will never be part for negotiations. It does not mean that Israel does not see that there is a Palestinian issue. We believe that the Palestinian issue can and should be solved in a context of peace that will be negotiated between Israel and Jordan. With Jordan we have got borders, south of the Dead Sea, till the Golf of Aqaba, north of the West Bank, along the Beit Shean Valley, and the Jordan Valley. Therefore, in a solution, peace solution between Jordan and Israel, I believe that the Palestinian issue can be solved in a way that the Palestinians will find their right to express their special identity, but, it will never be trough the so called PLO or through a third independent state. Because a third independent state between Jordan and Israel cannot solve the Palestinian issue, and will serve as a time bomb against Jordan as well as against Israel". Rather amazing, isn't it? So, what happened to Rabin? Well, he has been pushed in his back by his party, and mainly by his challenger, Peres, to accept and sign what he totally disagreed with.
67. Head in the sand?
ASTRONAUT ,   SC, USA   (09.08.13)
to Joe #17: his head is in a different place, and it isn't "the sand."
68. shilling for Obama
CJK   (09.09.13)
nuclear disarmament is obama's darling baby, as is the support of the muslim brotherhood, and so many other lunatic ideas.
69. #22... personally? what's that supposed to mean?
Ilan ,   Toronto, Canada   (09.09.13)
are you admitting,but not taking personal responsibility since you were not there when it happened? just like the Palestinians because none of them living today were alive when they occupied our land over a 1000 years ago? yes, at least you eventually gave most of the land you occupied back but the Palestinians are not, and even worse are claiming it as theirs, and no one is bothering to check their facts because in this day and age any blogger is all of a sudden a qualified historian, and you just pick and choose any blog,news site, or any youtube video to reinforce what you already blindly believe anyways!
70. Mr. Obama recently asked Mr. Olland of Fance
Miron ,   USA   (09.09.13)
of a similar undertaking. What followed from Mr. Holland's mouth could be put as a advanced University course in innormative language that would make Harvard proud.
71. To: Mohamed at No. 35
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (09.09.13)
Inch'Allah. Take good care. You are on the wrong side of a politically-charged battle. Please keep your family safe. You have nothing to fear from the Jews, but you have a great deal to fear from your fellow Moslems.
72. Reality check
Etienne Prinsloo ,   Nova Scotia Canada   (09.09.13)
Sun Tzu: if you wish for peace, prepare for war. Since when has weakness been a deterrent? No, Israel will not roll over and die to appease a Muslim loving philosophy delusionista.
73. Deal with the devil will not materialize
Brod ,   USA   (09.09.13)
Making a deal with the devil is a mistake. It will not materialize. The devil uses it to deceive Israel to giving away its liberated historic and biblical homeland-Land of Israel. It is the devil's greatest Taqiyya. Israel must never fall for it. It is time to stop the stupidity of making a deal with the devil. The Bible says the devil is the father of lies, violence and hate. His followers share his character. Suggesting that Israel should disarm itself from its deterrent power is foolishness. It would mean enabling new Hitlers to do what Hitler did in the Holocaust.
74. Astronaut- I was trying to be nice but agree100%
Joe Fraser   (09.09.13)
75. #57 - I have read the history and you are wrong
Gee ,   Zikron Yaakov   (09.09.13)
Operation Downfall - the invasion of Japan was estimated to cost 10 million Japanese and 1 million Allied lives. A VERY conservative estimate. Yes not only did it save 11 million lives, but most likely at least 100 million Chinese lives as well. If not used to end World War 2 - it would have been used on China in Korea. Your knowledge of history is lacking
76. Ydeiot Ahahron or Idiot Aharon
Avram Goldsmith ,   Toronto, Canada   (09.09.13)
Good plan for you PR using idot shock syndrom. It's time to open eyes arround you and grow because Israel is changing and you set up of '50 doesn't work more: no Mapai and no Havoda, what are you doing is : Avoda B'enaiim'
77. Utter rubbish!
Lee ,   Londonderry   (09.09.13)
It has been shown that the supposed 'occupation' is NOT the reason why there has not been peace in the Middle East. The real reason is that 'they' cannot recognise Israel as in 'their' book once a Muslim lives in an area it becomes holy Islamic soil FOREVER. This therefore explains why Yasser even though offered 95% of all that he asked for could not officially recognise Israel. Abbas will also find some excuse in order not to accept Israel.
78. #75
mark ,   ca   (09.09.13)
You should read my post again before you post something. It was a response to # 43 statement and his quote.
79. 32
(09.09.13)
i'm obliged to add to the previous insults. are all turks this naive, dumb and unaware of this issue as you are?
80. Foolish idea
Vlad   (09.09.13)
Even if Israel one day finds peace, God willing, I would still strongly oppose nuclear disarmament. Nuclear bombs give you more power and prestige, and force the world to take you seriously.
81. Israel would be foolish to disarm
Andrew ,   Delhi, Canada   (09.09.13)
It isn't just deterrence against Iran, it is deterrence against every one of its neighbours. It's a lot more daunting of a prospect to launch another intifada when facing the potential for nuclear annihilation in the event they succeed (if they win, they still lose a great deal). Maybe there will come a day when Israel's enemies won't care. That day will certainly come sooner if Israel disarmed and abandoned its nuclear weapons. America cannot be relied upon to shield Israel. Presidents change every four or eight years and the one in office now probably wouldn't care too much if Israel were attacked and annihilated. He seems to have a lot more favour for Israel's enemies than for Israel.
82. The regional security system, Israel
Jassim Hussian ,   Kit, Iraq   (09.10.13)
It is ultimately not about Jews, Arabs, or Persians , or Turkish , it is really about the Iranian ideological aggression , and malicious deeds to undermine peace .The security system is held partially but still very important way by Israel , so of Israel fails to stand up to Iran , the system will be impaired with huge risks to all .
83. Yuval is an absolute moron!
Reuven   (09.10.13)
84. Who does this guy think he is?
drdon ,   Scarsdale, NY   (09.10.13)
Typical response from an academic flyweight. Just what you would expect of scatterbrained ultra left wing philosophers.
85. facts vs fiction
Marcel ,   San Jose, Costa Rica   (09.10.13)
Neither Yuval Eylon nor me nor any of the readers of this column KNOW whether Israel has any nuclear weapons and that's just fine with me. Personally, I hope they do. I know that Israel will never used them premeditatedly. But if they were to exist, they would act as a perfect deterrent against anybody threatening the very existence of the country.
86. Ahhh, the Radical, Ignorant Idealists---
iNetFraud ,   USA   (09.10.13)
They've accounted for the deaths of millions due to their mindless nonsense. "Occupation"....lol. This IDIOT should be living in N. Korea with a brain-washed mentality like that. It would be nice if he weren't in Israel and didnt have anything to do with ANY Jews for the rest of his life. He's 'one of them'. Troll.
87. And if we are REAL nice, the Arabs will love us too...
frauss ,   Jerusalem   (09.10.13)
Another sterling proposition from the Left's fantasy land. Given that Syria gasses its' own population, they wouldn't have any qualms doing it to us. Why haven't they? It is called a strong deterrent and the fact that we could do far worse to them than they could do to us. I suggest we keep it that way until the Messiah comes.
88. Israel has hundreds of nukes
Bill ,   New York, USA   (09.10.13)
So how exactly did a tiny little country that depends on American foreign aid for it's existence manage to build itself 200 (300?) or more nuclear warheads anyway? These things cost a huge amount of money to build. Where'd you get it?
89. #88
mark ,   ca   (09.10.13)
Darwin Award.
90. 88
anton ,   istanbul   (09.10.13)
israel nukes are built with the help of france israel had good relations with afew african countries back in the day uranium etc were bought from them american aid did not start untill the threat of nuclear weapons arose from israel when israel asked for americans toys against advancing arab armies usa first refused then agreed the myth of israel saying she wont be the first one to use nuclear weapons is farce, history is evident deterrence is excuse the real purpose is to have upper hand in war threfore every country on earth has the right to persue nukes
Previous talkbacks
Next talkbacks
Back to article