News
Canada: PM plays rock n' roll for Israel, Palestinians protest
Ofer Petersburg
Published: 02.12.13, 09:34
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
27 Talkbacks for this article
1. Palestians your hatred of Jews = "apartheid"..
Ivan ,   South Africa   (12.02.13)
2. What a bunch
Isac   (12.02.13)
of losers those left wingers and Arab fascists are. They dare too call Israel an apartheid state. Than Egypt, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon, Libya, Algeria must indeed be world role models of democracy?! This is not about Israel it is about hating Jews. Get a life idiots!
3. The left wing fascists are protesting again
tiki ,   belgium   (12.02.13)
What a sorry bunch.
4. Harper would make a better PM for Israel than Netanyahu
Al   (12.02.13)
He would never invite a holocaust denier and a murderer the honor of addressing the Knesset. Yes that's how low Netanyahu has fallen. I am proud of Harper. I am ashamed of Netanyahu.
5. Pro-Palestinians are such party-poopers
Tahl   (12.02.13)
Everywhere there is some event in favor of Israel, these obnoxious lot always stick their ugly noses and holler their hateful shrieks. Interestingly, we almost never hear about Jewish demonstrations anywhere in the world were pro-Palestinians events are held, unless they really go overboard with their anti-Israel propaganda. But in this case there was nothing anti-Palestinian in this dinner.
6. Not Richest - Author does Jews a disservice
E Goldenberg ,   Toronto, Canada   (12.02.13)
Ignorant columnist - I was at the dinner last night with two tables - complete with 20 people! None of us are "rich" - we are in our mid-thirties and middle class and face the same path to raise a family as any other Canadian citizen. We don't need columnists who make these assumptions and write about them falsely. We have a hard enough time trying to make the world realize all Jews are not rich. This guy does the Jewish people a disservice and he should be ashamed about his negative impact on us..
7. Oh, Canada!
Yoni ,   Shomron   (12.02.13)
HARPER ROCKS!!! Those who bless Israel will be blessed (Harper). Those who curse Israel will be cursed (O'bummer). The choice is yours to make. Choose smartly!
8. Talented PM & Talented Musician!
Logic ,   Israel   (12.02.13)
What a great guy!
9. Mr Harper is SO GREAT ! Pals must come back to Saudi Arabia
(12.02.13)
10. Harper is a traitor!
Darren Ben John ,   Townsville Australia   (12.02.13)
The Bedouins need to be protected and so does their way of life. Harper's shame knows no boundaries.
11. you are right #6! not all Jews are rich!
Ilan ,   Toronto, Canada   (12.02.13)
but "Us Jews" have a different problem to deal with. they were outside protesting because of lies over 1 billion Muslims have been pushing on the rest of the world against us. and you are worried about your stupid social status? Muslims i work withl with actually believe Israel has this great plan of world domination. they take a map of the ancient kingdom of Israel, change some titles around , add the current date and run with it. All those people outside the event, indoctrinated and spreading hate against us, and all you care about is your social status! WOW! Don't take me the wrong way, we all thank you for supporting the country we love so much with your "not so big "wallet. But wow guy! the article says SOME of Toronto's richest jews, it didn't say all. Relax!
12. #10 "The Bedouins need to be protected"
A ,   Belgium   (12.02.13)
As do the rightful owners of Australia, the Aboriginals, hypocrite. Maybe it's time to disband your British penal colony and send you all back to the lands of your predecessors..
13. Toronto's richest Jews!!!
A.F. ,   Boulder   (12.02.13)
The man from Toronto makes a valid point because the writer starts with the words Toronto's richest Jews.He did not start the article with some of Toronto's richest but the richest.I did understand your point but what he is saying just adds to your point which is just adding fuel to the fire.
14. subversive behavior against the PM! They should be in jail !
Frederic   (12.02.13)
15. ugly pro-palestinians must leave Canada for Gaza
(12.02.13)
16. Good to know Israel has at least 1 friend in N. America
Scott ,   Ramat Gan, Israel   (12.02.13)
As for the protesters, these are anti-Semitic mindless idiots who have know idea what they are talking about. They juts repeat Arab propaganda like parrots.
17. To #6 and # 11
(12.02.13)
You are both right but have different perspectives. When comes to talk about wealth, knowledge or accomplishement, jews always pop up. It can make some, very upset. So it does's have a pervert side to it. Bottom line jews have learned from the past....
18. Wonderful
Loved this piece ,   Israel   (12.02.13)
He should come here and sing together with our wonderful Gat Brothers, Arik and Gal. That would truly be something Or, invite the Gats there. You won't regret it They are stars and they shine bright.
19. 12@100% agree with you
dovdevan ,   ashdod,paris   (12.02.13)
those who try to delegitimate israel should look themselves in the mirror twice australian ,american ,arabs who are living in africa all those people are the true colonialist
20. Ignormauses that no nothing about apartheid
michael redbourn ,   Lisbon Portugal   (12.02.13)
Ignoramuses that no nothing about apartheid I'm not sure why the media even gives fools the time of day?! Do Arabs in Israel? Eat in the same restaurants as Jews; use the same toilets; serve in the (Knesset) government: ride on the same buses ? The answer is "yes" to each question. Under apartheid in South Africa the answer was "no" to each question. There is nothing in Israel proper that compares to apartheid, nothing! The West Bank does have security restrictions, but they cannot be compared in any way shape or form to the apartheid that existed in South Africa of days gone by. South Africa went from riches to rags and now has one of the worst crime rates in the world. If the PA were to ever get a State it would most likely be as badly run as South Africa is and have similar problems.
21. No experience needed
Ezra ,   San Diego   (12.02.13)
None of those vietnam war protester have ever had to live next to neighbors who seek to kill you on a daily basis. They all need to quit pretending and move to gaza. Let's see how long they drag their cross around.
22. To nr 10 Bedouins are protected- they have democratic rights
Alexander ,   Tel Aviv, Israel   (12.02.13)
Bedouins are protected by the law and they have democratic rights and the Bedouins are as "native" to Israel as you are to Australia. They have democratic rights but those rights do not include claiming public land in the same way as you cannot invoke your Australian demoratic rights to arbitrarily claim every hilltop and valley you lay your eyes on in Australia. The only reason you interfer and the only reason they protest is because you and they don't want Jews to live in their Jewish homeland and to exercise their Jewish national rights which include independence and sovereignty. What Israel is doing is not outrageous at all and Israel hasn't "stolen" the "native" Bedouins' land since the Bedouins are de facto NO natives of Israel which history proves without a shred of doubt. The natives of Australia are the Aboriginals and the natives of Israel are the Jews. I'm not interested in your racist and blatant distortions of historical facts - the Jews are the native and historical population of Israel. Since you do not even approve of Harper expressing any sympathy at all for Israel only because it happens to be the homeland of the Jewish people, it proves therefore beyond any reasonable shred of doubt, that you hate Jews and Israel because of our ethnic identity which makes you not a romantic freedom fighter or proponent for democracy and human rights, rather it makes you a deceitful and insincere racist genocidal ideologist POSING as a human rights champion. You don't fool anyone Darren Ben John.
23. By far the best article in today's edition
Thank you Ynet   (12.02.13)
More like this, in Hebrew even more. But that is sadly not ynets forte....yet:)
24. #22 Alexander you just need to stop,,,,
Ronald Bisque ,   Birmingham, U.K.   (12.02.13)
not these Jews,,,, sad to say but it is the truth,,,, these modern day Jews are not,,,, let me emphasize "not these Jews",, I know it hurts but it is the truth, these peoples are not native to this land.
25. Our PM
LJH ,   Canada   (12.02.13)
I am very proud of our PM Mr Harper and I hope he continues to lead our country into the next election and beyond. Go Stevie!!
26. Harper is fighting for his political life
Toronto citizen ,   Toronto, Canada   (12.02.13)
He is way down in the polls, for the deception, ;ying, stealing money from Canada of his friends and office. Maybe he will end up charged. After 8 years he finally wnats to go to Israel, maybe to bolster his image. His opponent has been 3 times. He has made compassion of the government a misery in Canada. Enough Jews beleive in him but his policy to Israel is each time parroting a script written by Bibi. Nobody in Israel should depend on him - you will fall with him.
27. Harper
LDL ,   Canada   (12.03.13)
I agree. We need to stand up for Harper and his stand for Israel.
Back to article