News
Ministerial committee approves annexing Jordan Valley
Moran Azulay
Published: 29.12.13, 18:30
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
85 Talkbacks for this article
61. 48
jonathan ,   adelaide/Israel   (12.30.13)
Lydia your post is nonsense-Israel does not need Inter Law permission.It's on Israel's side.Read post 53 or use your computer.Arabs like you need to educate your self even if you "live" in Australia.
62. #53
Eyal ,   USA Israel   (12.30.13)
Bla bla bla. The Jordan valley is disputed land under Israel's control. Israel can Annex by law. The international parties can disagree, but by law, Israel has every right. U lose. Israel wins. Now go write more bs.
63. disputed territory
k ,   USA   (12.30.13)
The West bank never ever belonged to the Arabs /palestinians. It belonged to Turkey, Britain, Jordan and now Israel. The Arabs are simply repeating the BIG LIE!!!!
64. 53 EVERYTHING outside Israels borders is Palestine
lydia ,   Brisbane   (12.30.13)
NOTHING outside of Israel's Unilaterally declared borders as enshrined in UN181, belongs to Israel. That's why all this nonsense talk of EIGHT Israeli ministers approval of Jordon Valley 'Annexation'.
65. Israel ought to annex the whole of Area C now, including the
Geulah ,   Tzur Hadassah, Isr.   (12.30.13)
Jordan Valley, in the widest meaning of the term, as the late Mr. Rabin called for in his last speech at the Knesset on Oct. 5, 1995.
66. #34, 44 and 47
Daniel   (12.30.13)
Indeed, I do like Haaretz and I like YA as well. Two good Israeli newspapers. And I do dislike racists. A racist is a racist, pure and simple. It doesn't matter which people you shun for their ethnicity, there is no moral difference between writing hateful remarks about Arabs or about Jews, and I dislike people doing either. In defending everyone's human rights, I'm proud to align myself with the best of Judaism. In denying and attacking those right, you align yourself morally with the worst enemies of Judaism in its entire history.
67. #48,Where is your int. approval of 100% Aborigine annexation
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (12.30.13)
68. 55
Birdi ,   Israel   (12.30.13)
When are you coming home? We need you here.
69. Two questions for Abbas .. then end the charade!
Michael Redbourn ,   Lisbon Portugal   (12.30.13)
Will Abbas drop the "right of return"? Would Jews be allowed to live in a future Palestinian State? If he answers, "No" to either question then he might as well be shown the door.
70. Livni, Lapid, you do not belong in government
(12.30.13)
for you have no feel for what it takes for AM Yisrael to live in peace
71. Annexation of Jordan Valley
Lorraine Melzer ,   Ramat Hasharon   (12.30.13)
Israel is mentally ill and badly in need of psychiatric aid. To think that this is a move to improve our future is insane.
72. 69ROR Is guaranteed under theGeneva Convention
lydia ,   Brisbane   (12.30.13)
Genuine Jews will be allowed to live in Palestine. Fake Jewish pagan squatters/hoodlums can return to Est. Europe and Birobidzan.
73. 61 Go educate yourself about Israels Unilateral declaration
lydia ,   Brisbane   (12.30.13)
Occupation of land by war is illegal and if and until ALL aspects of UN242 is complied with etc. etc is the Palestinian obliged to approve Israel annexation of the 1967 borders. It stands to reason therefore that the borders of the Jewish State is Israels own Unilateral declaration of Independence as entrenched in UN181.
74. 63 'Disputed' land can't be annexed
lydia ,   Brisbane   (12.30.13)
Since 1948 annexation of land is illegal without the approval of the high stake holders and since the Palestinians will not recognize /legitimize Israel illegal annexation of their land if and until Israel complies with ALL aspects of its own obligation ie UN242. Your lot of crazies are only pi**ing in the wind.
75. #71 mentally ill in need of psychiatric aid:L Melzer ,
norbus ,   Jerusalem   (12.30.13)
You are ill, Lorraine Melzer, Refuah Shlemah, with no clue about what goes on. Peace for Jews comes from strength and security. Annexing the edge of the horseshoe, gives better security against infiltrators allows Arabs freedom to move We face a blizzard of enemies all around us and even across Oceans. We need to do our bit to protect our people, and let the G-d of Israel do the rest
76. "giving up on the government's authority"
Zev ,   Israel   (12.30.13)
And I thought this was passed by a government committee.
77. The title is a lie and it's just propaganda
Italian in Israel   (12.30.13)
The annexation of the Jordan valley has not been okayed. It's the proposal of the bill that has been okayed by only 8 ministers. This bill will never see the light thank god. Miri Regev is a populist loser. KapaƮym
78. 77# Spaghetti ball , you know Nuttink
(12.30.13)
79. 75 Israel is' "Out of the frying pan into the fire"
lydia ,   Brisbane   (12.30.13)
A bit daft to go pitch tents for your illegal settlement in the midst of a blizzard of your enemies'. Who asked you to? Perhaps your lot should have stayed in Birobidzan where you really belong instead of coming half way across the seas to steal and pillage..
80. Jordan Valley annexation
Lorraine Melzer ,   Ramat Hasharon   (12.30.13)
#74 With attitudes like yours it wouldn't need more than a half normal IQ to figure out why the Jews are unloved the world over.
81. Harry 45, there are no Arabs in J. Valley
know the facts   (12.30.13)
For 45 years now, the Jordan Valley is full with Jewish communities, and with almost no Arab population.
82. #80 ; Calm down Lorraine; take a pill
(12.30.13)
You are confused; the number is 75, not 74, post of Hajjia Lydia Sorry about your IQ; I do not need to be loved, I need to be safe. It was mostly the Askenaz ms Melzer who caused hatred , money lending, and developing strange habits in Ghettos
83. To: No. 29
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.30.13)
They will be repatriated to Jordan, country of their citizenship. Won't be the first time in history there's been a massive transfer of people due to changes in borders. And, unlike what happened to nearly one million Jews in Arab and Moslem lands, they will be permitted to leave with everything they own. Don't even think about saying "what about the land?" They don't OWN the land; never did.
84. To: No. 3
Sarah B ,   U.S.A. / Israel   (12.30.13)
Palestine was never a country. In 1947, there was a vote on partition. Israel accepted partition; the Arabs did not. They chose to go to war instead. They LOST. They LOST. And they lost five additional wars which were all started by the Arabs. What part of the word "LOST" do you NOT understand? What on this green earth makes you think that you are entitled to multiple bites at the apple? Think you'll get a different outcome? You won't.
85. #81. Nonsense of course.
Dan   (12.31.13)
Previous talkbacks
Back to article