News
Abbas calls emergency Arab League meeting to discuss failing peace talks
Ynetnews
Published: 07.04.14, 23:18
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
54 Talkbacks for this article
31. No, you gave up NOTHING, since it has never been yours in
N.L.Katz ,   Qatzrin, Israel   (04.08.14)
the first place. Legally, Palestine/Eretz Israel(Land of Israel) was partitioned in 1922 by the League of Nations which accepted the handover of 77% of the territory, located between the Jordan River and the Arabian desert, to the Arabs; and, 23% of the territory, located between the Jordan River and the Med. Sea to the Jews. This act in international law was then adopted by the UN and etched into the UN Charter, article 80, 1945. So, please, don't tell us your latest "narrative", i.e. fictional story designed for political expediency, that you gave up.
32. misunderstanding
tom ,   toronto, canada   (04.08.14)
78%? the british stole 78% of the palestine mandate, to create the "arab homeland in palestine". and guess what? it's called jordan, and should still be the "arab homeland in palestine". abbas and his band of terrorists is now trying to steal more of the remaining 22%, which should all have been the "jewish homeland" that britain was mandated to facilitate.
33. Abbas:
Israeli 2   (04.08.14)
Israel by any other name is still ISRAEL! The 78% you refer to is Haifa, Tel Aviv and Beer Sheba. Isn't it? So what else is new. By 2016, you wish you still have at least an identity. Don't ride your high horse to fast.
34. Bringing in the Arab League GOOD
USA   (04.08.14)
Good because the world can see how greedy these Arabs are. There are 22 Arab nation states on over 99% of Middle East land with 45% of world oil production and 15% of natural gas reserves. While Israel is a single teeny tiny non-Arab state on less than 1% of ME land, on a fraction of its historic land with no oil. As if Arabs need more land! No it is not about land!!! 22 Arab nations + the Palestinian Arabs versus tiny Israel. Over 99:1 in land, 100% in oil, and over 500:1 in people count. The worlld will then see how these greedy oil rich Arabs who could solve the problem in a week, all gang up against tiny Israel. Bullies THE BULLIES any which way you look at it.
35. Math Lesson
ik ,   USA   (04.08.14)
Abbas' "gave up" = Lost in war they started
36. Unilateral Withdrawal Now (end)
David ,   Minneapolis, USA   (04.08.14)
37. So who has said abbas is a peace partner?
(04.08.14)
This is the vicious face of fatah, he no idea of the meaning of negotiate, let alone the feeling of Peace, Mutual Trust, coexisting and a future for Many generations? This Taker abu mazen should be dethroned Immediatly, elections held and one voice elected for peace. I mean the Fakenstians need to Lie about a history Which Never Exsisted, I still would like to know Who was First king of these mythical people???
38. Abbas trying to appease Jordan's king
Avi   (04.08.14)
In the last decade it seems there's a new historical narrative going around with the Palestinians. This time Palestine borders exactly on Israel's modern borders to the inch, from Eilat and the negev up until the Lebanese border and from the sea to the west and the Jordan river to the east. Quite the coincidence! Only several eyars ago they were still claiming Jordan as well, as part of the British mandate. Thus, their "remaining 22%" would actually be around 3% as 88% of the mandate was Jordan. I suppose this new narrative is meant to appease the king of Jordan and not inflame the Palestinian majority there. Certainly not after the massacre of Black September that saw tens of thousands of Palestinians butchered and exiled after a failed coup d'tat, led by Arafat no less who claimed that "the liberation of Palestine starts with Jordan". Guess they can't make up their minds anymore.
39. Always continuously high on weed
Yael Schlichting ,   Munich - Germany   (04.08.14)
At least they should stop to stretch out their weed with chopped toilet paper.
40. #11 Joyce will you be giving California back
Nancy   (04.08.14)
Is that so Joyce? Thanks for the lecture , so will you be giving California back to the Native Americans ?
41. 'giving up 78% of historic Palestine.'
jon ,   uk   (04.08.14)
Abbas says these words he knows if he keeps on saying this in time the world will get use to it like Palestinian state if you keep on saying lies after a while people will believe it is true Abbas should be asked what history he is talking about did they have parliament ,currency etc. before 1967 do they have history books about it
42. The art of lying creates Inverted truth
Norbus ,   Jerusalem   (04.08.14)
The art of lying creates Inverted truth Adept at appropriation Arabs, a desert people, have no concept of truth. Steal a neighbours wife or cattle, and they are yours; No registry of titles. Say something is yours long enough and it is believed. Jews gave up 78% of the Jewish Home as settled. Now ABBAS has inverted that fact claiming the reverse
43. 7
zionist forever   (04.08.14)
The 78% of Palestine Abbas talks about is the land Israel captured in 1948 and now makes up the so called green line. The other 22% is the land taken in 1967 from Jordan. Israel has already given up around 80% of biblical Judea to create Jordan which was illegally created by the British when against the terms of their League of Nations mandate they imported a Saudi prince then they took a large chunk of the land set aside to be the Jewish homeland and made it his kingdom. If you go into a bookstore you will find arab history books in the fiction section.
44. It is Jewish land for Jews
Harri ,   EU   (04.08.14)
It is Jewish land for Jews and Palestinian land for Palestinians. Jerusalem was also City of God for me when I was younger, now it looks mostly the City of Greed and Unjust.
45. What about Transjordan!
Joe ,   Boston, USA   (04.08.14)
Jordan was Palestine so the Arabs got 90%. There will be no peace agreements until they stop insisting on 100%.
46. Consider the Hand of HaShem, mr. abbas
ASTRONAUT ,   SC, USA   (04.08.14)
47. "We still are occupying 22% of Judea"
blog2038 ,   usa   (04.08.14)
48. Israel's claim to the land is both older & newer.
Steve ,   UK   (04.08.14)
There has been a Jewish presence in all of the disputed territories for nearly 4,000 years, despite attempts to expel them. Former Jewish lands are presently occupied by Arabs in Jordan, Lebanon, Sinai, Syria and territory extending to the Euphrates. The size of ancient Jewish land occupied by Arab states is greater than the size of Israel today. Indeed, the Arabs occupy 99.5% of the Middle East, consisting of some 22 countries. Israel occupies less than 0.5% of the remainder. Yet the Arabs want this too.   Of the Palestine Mandate, 77% was severed to create a new Arab country now called Jordan. Of the remaining 23% the UN tried to divide between remaining Arabs and the Jews, with the Jews having mostly desert. The Jews accepted, the Arabs refused, declaring war to remove the nascent Jewish state in 1948. But who needs facts when you can have a narrative of Israeli oppression which can be used regardless of the circumstances and which doesn't require burdensome details like hard facts or dry empirical data. Israel's claim to the land predates the Arab claim by centuries, if not millenia. Israel's claim is also the most recent, with Israeli sovereignty in the present day. A spurious claim birthed six decades ago does not negate the Israeli claims in any way. There is no cut-off point for Arab expediency.
49. # 28 Use someones else name bozo!
BUILD BABY BUILD!!!!   (04.08.14)
pals will be forced to leave Israel. Jordan is their home according to the UN and the Brits. KEEPING BUSY BUILDING !!!
50. the Arab League used to have 55 members
Lily   (04.08.14)
nowdays it had barely 7 members. the arab world is not keen for more troubles internationaly when they have plenty of interior problems. The other arab country will talk but won't do anything.
51. to #28 simple logic
Lily   (04.08.14)
palestine was a british colony, much like USA used to be 13 british colonies(unofficially there were more but not british), so you should return to british ancestry. start by paying taxes to the queen of England.
52. Arabs owned 0% of 10,000 sq mi in Mandatory Fakstine in 1943
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (04.08.14)
53. Abbas wants $100 million a month from
BUILD BABY BUILD!!!!   (04.08.14)
the Arab League. Let them pay for these animals who serve no purpose or, ship them off to Jordan for free. BUILDING A MIGHTIER ISRAEL !!!
54. To #40: YOU'VE MADE IT CLEAR NANCY
joyce fraser ,   USA   (04.08.14)
How many nations should give back the lands and resources they took during their various nation-forming stages? The answer is: More than we are able to imagine, and only if our world would be a heavenly place. The plunder, the mass murder and conquering, so easily 'accomplished" by the Euro-Caucasian "Christians" in many corners of the globe, is immeasurable!
Previous talkbacks
Back to article