News
Israeli missile defense loses out to US in Poland tender
Reuters
Published: 15.05.14, 14:41
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
15 Talkbacks for this article
1. Poland Chose US System Over US/Israel System
Jersey Jew ,   New Jersey, USA   (05.15.14)
Clearly a rational Polish decision, albeit resulting in less Israel economic, technology & military aid ...
2. I can drink to that ;) ,...
split ,   US   (05.15.14)
It's US anyway ,...
3. Obama let Poland down before and will do it again
Steve Benassi ,   Silver Bay, MN USA   (05.15.14)
4. Free market, free choice
Ephraim ,   Jerusalem   (05.15.14)
I don't see the problem. If the US product is better, they win. If not, they lose. There are two parts to business; product and marketing. Stop crying and do a better job next time.
5. Ephraim #4, Yes, try to read the article first next time
Jake   (05.15.14)
"US executive says Poland favored American bid in order to cement relationship with Washington, in light of tensions with Russia. This has nothing to do with product quality or marketing. And no one is "crying"; it's just you, jumping to wrong conclusions.
6. to #4: try reading it this time
(05.15.14)
try reading the article again: the poles did not decide based on which system was better, but because of political considerations, like the ukranian situation (which will be irrelevant by the time the system becomes operational), and america vetoing the sale of certain israeli products. (not the first time the americans have used "foreign aid" as a lever to block israeli interests, and stifle competition.) nothing to do with price or quality of the product, just "american knowhow" in marketing.
7. hope it works out for them
tom ,   toronto, canada   (05.15.14)
chances are, poland will never actually need to shoot down incoming ballistic missiles, because very few countries have the capability and the desire to shoot at them. iran, for example, would be foolish to target warsaw instead of london or paris. but poland's military history does include some remarkable choices, like having the finest cavalry in the world, in ww2. choosing a derivative of the patriot system, which has an almost perfect record of zero proven intercepts (except for 2 kills of friendly aircraft!), may continue that fine tradition.
8. Correction to post @ 2 ,...
split ,   US   (05.15.14)
It's US technology anyway ,...
9. What's the problem?
Ephraim ,   Jerusalem   (05.15.14)
Why is everyone hating on me and comment? There are many cell phone companies in Israel. We chose Orange because of their children's games, which was an added benefit that suited us. If the Poles want to work with an American company and receive political or other benefits, that seems the same to me. I live here, and always want the best for Israel. Next time sweeten the pot and get the deal. That's called salesmanship, Have none of you ever gone to the shuk? Haggling is part of the fun.
10. pinhead @ 5 ,...
split ,   US   (05.15.14)
Poland re-emerged broke and devastated 20 years prior to WWII after almost 150 years of partition, defeated Soviets in 1922 ,... Better ask 3.5 million of Jews living in Poland at that time why Polish banks were empty before WWII? Unlike your homies that deserted in Palestine from Anders' Army on the way to join Allies in N. Africa Poles proved themselves on WWII battlefields from Russian Kursk to Normandy over British Islands and Africa. By the way my friend unlike your tribe Poles didn't behave like rounded sheep on the way to slaughter house they fought to the end. Have a good day ,...
11. #8, split., LOL really?
Jake   (05.16.14)
Let's see if you can tell us what part of David's Sling will be US technology, developed in the US?
12. tom @ 7 ,...
split ,   US   (05.16.14)
By the way, from US or Israel it's a waste of money anyway. Also, Poland got screwed up by Israelis in the past, their anti-tank missiles are living exhaust trail pointing to the launch spot. They're not made for European climate
13. To split #10, I would love to ask 3.5 million Polish Jews
Jake   (05.16.14)
what they think about that, but most of them were murdered. And don't put words in my mouth. I have never belittled Polish fighting abilities or contributions, and I have always sympathasized with Poland invaded and divided between Nazi Germany and Soviet Union. It's antisemitic posters like you that are pouring salt on old wounds.
14. Wrong number Jake ,...
split ,   US   (05.17.14)
My post was a response to Tom @ #7 for his smart-ass cavalry comment, sorry. Pinhead have no idea that no idea that cavalry resisted German invasion longer than the Frenchies with their Maginot line and up to date military toys ,...
15. David's Sling missile defense system- its DAVID's defence system-
Israel   (05.18.14)
and should stay (even with parts/technology) in Israel. Why? because it is NOT JESUS' nor Hubbert's or whatever defence system !! Tragic, but Israel always at the wrong side. Why Poland is afraid and U.S. is making once more a kind of self-invitation -hmmm?? | Eyes up:  WE  are helping the Fascists and Scientology brainwashing clans to take ground in Ukraine...! HOW STUPID ONE CAN BE ? better to look to Russian side and the East ( Ex Oriente Lux ! and not from the West, there is the SUN-DOWN !)
Back to article