Jewish Scene
High Court overturns rabbinical court's forced circumcision ruling
Aviel Megnazi
Published: 30.06.14, 09:44
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
14 Talkbacks for this article
1. inaccurate headline
(06.30.14)
There was no issue of a woman being forced to circumcise her son at his father's request. It was the court forcibly preventing a father from circumcising his son at his ex-wife's demand. It was the civil court once again deciding that fathers have no rights, just obligations. Why is it the court supports a nasty woman who perjures herself in court to get more money from the child's father? Where is the justice?
2. Jewish uncircumcised children...
ORA ,   JERUSALEM   (06.30.14)
lack the feeling of belonging to the Jewish people and are mostly not in peace with themselves and therefor not with others. That is why many circumcise at a later age. They would rather have it done at eight days. Hence,it is in the child's interest to circumcise him, the sooner the better.
3. All based on a fairy tale.
(06.30.14)
4. Another Proof Why We are Not at....
Reuven Brauner ,   Raanana, Israel   (06.30.14)
the "beginning of the Redemption:. Do not be misled by errant ideologies! The State of Israel has no mandate or interest in promoting Torah, Judaism or the observance of Halacha. At every turn it can, the Courts undermine the authority of the rabbis and weaken matters of the public observance of Jewish Law. Why are we not yelling "Secular Coercion?"
5. Karen Singer and Jeremy from FB
Chaim ,   Israel   (06.30.14)
Is it more barbaric than murdering healthy babies in the mother's wombs? Where's your outcry on that? - and there are thousand of innocent healthy babies who get killed yearly even in the Jewish land. Jeremy, you're right, but sadly these are self-hating Galut mentality Jews ashamed of their ancestors and of being Jewish whose goal is to destroy G-d's Torah.
6. Judaism is dying
CJK   (07.01.14)
circumcision is the very heart of judaism. what is the point of having a jewish state when jewish identity is being denied. throughout the ages boys have been circumcised as a sign of the covenant. secular jews were not any different in this respect than the orthodox. parents defied the authorities in european countries and circumcised their sons in secret.
7. circumcision in adulthood is not possible
CJK   (07.01.14)
1 it is a violation of a fundamental jewish law. 2 circumcision is painful in adulthood, whereas a baby of eight days old gets over it in a few minutes. 3 a boy who is not circumcised is not considered jewish. he is mocked by his comrades.
8. At last - some decent news
Talula ,   Israel   (07.01.14)
The rabbinical court should NOT be able to 'rule' that anyone do anything. We are a secular country with ONE judicial system - and the religious are not included - not in that and they also have no say in the government. Thank GOD!
9. No 6 CKJ please define "Jewish state"
Non Jewish immigrant ,   Haifa   (07.01.14)
10. Compared with THESE  SEVENERS there is Olmert's doing a nothing...!
(07.01.14)
and didnt harm Israel that much, as these traitors are doing!!
11. THEORETICAL BULLSHIT's decisions- eternities away from
(07.01.14)
practical developing and protecting JEWISH LIVE and nation! just doing the opposite! send em back to campuses -TILL  NOW  they did NOT  UNDERSTAND how the HOLOCAUST began and: WHAT LIVE (and Live for Jews) means and why it is necessary to protect... !!
12. THESE 7 JUDGES should be PROSECUTED immed., bec.of destroying
Aaron   (07.01.14)
the basis of Jewishness, our NATION and defin.as a NATION !
13. Ora no2 read your own comment
Non Jewish immigrant ,   Haifa   (07.01.14)
But replace the word circumcised by mutilated (since circumcision is a sort of accepted mutilation). It's in the interest of the child to mutilate him.... It's scary
14. #8 so
(07.01.14)
So you subscribe to the belief that fathers are nothing but cash machines for lazy lying women to use?
Back to article