Opinion  Ben-Dror Yemini
An auto-anti-Semitic abomination
Ben-Dror Yemini
Published: 23.02.18, 09:27
Comment Comment
Print comment Print comment
Back to article
103 Talkbacks for this article
1. We must remember that...
Phoenix   (02.23.18)
American “Jews” are not actually Jews. For fact 85% of American Jews are not Jews according our law. They are self proclaimed Jewish. But only sects.
And the leftists here in Israel are not really Jewish cause they know nothing about Judaism and many of them are not Jewish by law.
2. Zeev Sternhellis is absolutely and completely correct
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.23.18)
We all know that the Holocaust didn't start with Auschwitz, Bergen Belsen, Treblinka, Dachau or Mauthausen. It started much earlier, even before Kristallnacht in 30 November, 1938. It started with the venomous anti-Jewish discourse, with Mein Kamph, with the Nuremberg laws, with the Hitler Youth.....with laws and media dscorrce similar to the present anti-Arab laws and media discourse in Israel. One Jew ar this forum asked: how many Palestinians will survive the coming holocaust!?

So, the man is a million percent CORRECT.Israel is preparing a real holocaust to get rid of the Palestinians. Israeli leaders speak of "transfer" and expulsion. But we all know that "expulsion" is just a euphemism for genocide.

There are words I can not bring myself to utter. I Just hope humanity, especially Jews who control powerful states, will wake up before it is too late.
3. Unintended cosmetics won't change the basic facts
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.23.18)
"There are (Arab) business people among them—a new generation of young people working in high-tech, engineers, journalists, doctors and judges"

There were also Jewish businesspeople among them—a new generation of young people working in high-tech, engineers, journalists, doctors and judges! in Nazi Germany!

We know the rest of the story
4. Even IslamoNazi Khalid posts his pile of garbage lies here
Steve Benassi ,   Minneapolis USA   (02.23.18)
5. Pity such man escaped the hell of Holocaust only to live now
(02.23.18)
6. We prefear to listen ro Jewish intellectuals
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.23.18)
You are not an intellectual . you are an idiot who also happens to be a fascist, you are a burden unto yourself. You just belch out foolishness. I feel sorry for you. I will ignore you.
7. You are fornicating with truth and common sense
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.23.18)
One doesn't e Nazi by calling for human equality, human rights, non-discrimination on the basis of religion and race. In fact, you are fornicating with truth when you call me Nazi. The real Nazi is the one who advocates apartheid, genocide, detention camps and Jewish supremacy.
8. Trojan Horses
Dan ,   Jerusalem   (02.23.18)
Another self-hating Jew to be added to the list together with Noam Chomsky and Miko Peled.. We don't need anymore enemies. We have enough without these Trojan Horses. F** them and YEMACH SHEMAM!
9. Industry of lies about Israel
Martin   (02.23.18)
Ben-Dror you are an inspiration and honorable person to Israel and the Jewish people. All people who believe in the truth about Israel will be inspired.
10. 1933-1945. Not long at all.
The Istanbulian ,   Istanbul   (02.23.18)
Seems like you are impatient to be cattle carred.
11. TO # 2 Khalid
oleg ,   Sunny Florida   (02.23.18)
If its so bad in East Jerusalem I suggest you move to Amman Palestaine to be among your people. You people never had it so good.
12. Put him in his place....
Steve ,   Teaneck   (02.23.18)
quick, hire onto the editorial staff of Haaretz
13. Palestine,unlike Jews, would rather die than immifrate
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.23.18)
There is no place like home. But tell me why do you thinkso many Jews are returning to Germany?
14. Incurable Jew hater
(02.23.18)
'Israel is preparing a real holocaust to get rid of the Palestinians' - change Iran for Israel and Jews for Palestinians and you have the truth what you write are nothing more than the idiotic scribblings of a mentally challenged maggot.
15. Tear up his citizenship
Empress Trudy ,   Raleigh   (02.23.18)
Kick him out of the country. He can live in Iran or somewhere.
16. Gaza Concentration Camp is proof of Israel ethnic cleansing
Steve Benassi ,   Duluth, Minnesota   (02.23.18)
17. Sound About Right To Me
World Citizen ,   the world   (02.23.18)
Many of the things Israel is doing remind me of the things the Nazis did.
1) Gaza open air prison/ghetto = Warsaw ghetto/concentration camps
2) Naked aggression against Lebanon/Syria/Egypt/Jordan/Palestine = Invasion of Poland/Russia/France/Belgium/ Netherlands/Czechoslovakia /Hungary
3) Murder of innocent civilians in Lebanon/West Bank/Gaza = Murder of civilians in in the countries list in Item 2).
4) Concept of a Greater Israel = Concept of a Greater Reich
5) Dehumanization of Palestinians = Dehumaniation of Jews/Roma/Russians
6) Apartheid of Palestinians = Similar laws for separation of Jews/Roma from German society.
18. Mr Yemini...
Ysosii ,   On   (02.23.18)
...is a smart commentator and this article is good in exposing an abominable creature like Sternhell.. However he espouses a similar discourse: So, anexing J&S="apartheid"? That's the narrative of the terrorist supporting left and the self hating jews: how can annexing your own historic territory become "apartheid"? oh, there are arabs there? well, they came to our historic land, Israel is jewish land, and Israel is not obligated to give them voting rights. Want to become a citizen? be loyal to the state, accept its Jewish nature, respect jewish law.
Granting arabs a state or rights in J&S will eventually result in the end of Israel.
19. Zeev Sternhell is a very sick man
C   (02.23.18)
anyone who compares israel to nazi germany has to be demented or
outright a liar.

the essence of nazi germany was the conquest of europe and the
annihilation of europe's entire jewish population.
six million jews were brutally slaughtered by the nazis, with extreme
thoroughness and diligence.
jews had been subjected to various discriminatory laws and even
pogroms before, but never to a plan of total annihilation based
on racial purity ideology.
people like sternhell cannot be explained or understood and
one should not attempt to do so.
20. A prime specimen of Lupus-Ludaeus, if there ever was one!
(02.24.18)
21. Typical right wing rhetoric - attack the messenger...
(02.24.18)
You can condemn Mr. Sternhal all you like, including take his comments out of context to portray him as a racist lunatic, and many on the right wing love these articles... Gives them yet another phantom enemy to unite around, while allowing them to close their eyes to reality.
Anyone who loves Israel, must never close his eyes to reality and must work hard to keep building and improving our wonderful country!!
The truth-tellers of the left are many times hard to listen to, but we must listen and should embrace the truth rather than hide it...
22. Yemini can not produce hard evidence and plausible arguments
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.24.18)
to refute Sternhell's basic arguments. Yes, there are many students at Israeli universities, and there are Arab Judges in Israeli courts, there are also Arab doctors ar Israeli hospitals and Israel's Arabs are allowed to speak their language.

But the insidious process Nazifying the Israeli Jewish process is continuing unabated.

Arabs and Jews are not treated equally by the Israeli justice system.

For example, the family home of an Arab convicted of killing a Jew is demolished as the first order of business and the family and children are thrown onto the street. However, the family home of a Jew convicted of murdering Arabs is never demolished.

Example: Baruch Goldstein Murdered 29 innocent Arabs at the Hebron mosque, but his home In Kiryat Arba was never demolished. There are hundreds of similar examples....yes thousands not dozens or hundreds. I don't read about the Nazi-like treatment meted out to the Palestinians by Israel. I live and experience it 24 hours a day. I understand Yemini's propensity to defend Israel, but honesty is paramount.
23. Jerusalem, not Amman, is my home
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.24.18)
I suggest you move to NEW YORK tO be among your people. Jews in America never had it so good.. Jews rule America!
24. There is no such a thing as Islamic supremacy.
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.24.18)
No Muslim under the sun considers Muslims God's chosen people or the master race! This is just to correct youn your information!
25. You seem to be bankrupt intellectually
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.24.18)
It is a sign of intellectual bankruptcy to resort to mendacity and red herring tactics. Besides, we all know that Jews in America have a very high representation in the pornography industry.
26. You Israel would only exterminate the Palestinians
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.24.18)
of the territories. And you want us to thank Israel for that!
27. Yossi: Sternhell is former head of the Hebrew University
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.24.18)
History department. Do you Jews hire "garbage" to run your colleges??????
28. Israel is in fact not truly Jewish or democratic
Khalid Amayreh ,   Jerusalem   (02.24.18)
Israel claims to be both Jewish and democratic: Israel is not telling the truth.
Israel is neither truly Jewish nor truly democratic. The Bible on numerous occasions exhort Jews not to "oppress or mistreat strangers living among you because you were strangers in Egypt". Needless to say oppressing and tormenting non-Jews in Israel and Palestine is Israel's modus operandi."

Israel is manifestly undemocratic because democracy is starkly incompatible with the Israeli policy of ethnic cleansing and systematic persecution meted out to the Palestinians. Indeed, what is so democratic about occupying a country and tormenting its people for over 50 years in order to compel them to leave?????????
29. Arabs are not immigrants in Israel!!
Ismail ALjazaeri   (02.24.18)
The writer seems to forget, Arabs are not immigrant in the so called Israel, they are the original inhabitants. comparing them with Europe where Arabs are recent immigrants is outrageous and supremacist racism.
30. Arabs are immigrants to planet Earth, not only to Israel!
(02.25.18)
Next talkbacks
Back to article