Photo: Reuters
David Irving. 'A moral threat to the truth'
Photo: Reuters

Jews upset by Shoah denier's Polish trip

Jewish leaders express disgust over British writer David Irving's visit; anti-racist group calls for legal action against him. 'Mr. Irving is not a historian but a charlatan and a vicious liar,' says chief rabbi

Polish Jewish leaders expressed disgust on Wednesday over a visit to Poland by British writer and convicted Holocaust denier David Irving, and an anti-racist group called for legal action against him.


Irving, 72, is the author of several books which defend Adolf Hitler and deny that the Nazis murdered six million Jews during World War Two. He has begun an eight-day study tour of wartime sites in Poland with a group of followers.


Poland was home to one of the world's largest Jewish communities before 1939. The vast majority were killed by the Nazis, many in death camps such as Treblinka which Irving said he plans to visit.


"In Poland, the ideas of Mr. Irving sound exceptionally absurd and absolutely unacceptable," said Piotr Kadlcik, head of the Polish Jewish community.


Poland's chief rabbi, Michael Schudrich, said: "Mr. Irving is not a historian but a charlatan and a vicious liar ... The fact that he is here justifies the strength of democracy in Poland that it does not close its doors. He is not a terrorist threat but a moral threat, to the truth."


Irving, who spent more than a year in an Austrian jail in 2005-06 for denying the Holocaust, told Reuters he would keep a low profile in Poland for the sake of his "guests" who he said had paid more than 2,000 pounds ($3,000) for the trip.


Their itinerary will include a visit to the "Wolf's Lair", Hitler's Eastern Front headquarters, and the camps of Majdanek, Treblinka, Sobibor and Belzec.


"We are not going to Auschwitz this time because I believe it is overrated," Irving said in a short interview.


"The Jews tried to turn Auschwitz and their tragedy into a money-making machine and they persecute historians who ask legitimate questions about what actually happened there."


Irving's 'money machine'

Some 1.5 million people, mostly Jews, perished in Auschwitz during the war.


Open Republic, a group that fights anti-Semitism and xenophobia, said it had informed Poland's Institute of National Remembrance (IPN) about Irving's visit. The IPN can prosecute those it believes have committed "crimes against the nation".


"We have asked that he be detained in regard to denying the Holocaust, which in Polish law is called 'the Auschwitz lie', as well as in regard to his book 'Hitler's War'," said Anna Kwiecien of Open Republic.

Kadlcik said Irving's claim that Jews had commercialized the Holocaust was ironic.


"Mr. Irving accuses the Jewish lobby of making money from the Holocaust. Well, in fact it is a sort of money machine but for Mr. Irving himself. He's making real money on this," he said.


"Unfortunately, as long as he just travels around the sites of the Shoah and does not publicly say anything that could be persecuted by law, he is safe."


פרסום ראשון: 09.22.10, 16:46
 new comment
This will delete your current comment