An unusual halachic ruling published Wednesday calls for a consumer boycott on carp fish and the traditional gefilte fish dish, in a bid to prevent fish merchants from charging exaggerated prices ahead of the Passover Seder.
In about three weeks, the Jewish people will gather around the table for the Seder meals. Many homes, particularly Ashkenazi ones, will enjoy a dish of ground carp with a piece of carrot on top – also known as gefilte fish. Yet quite a few stores have the habit of raising the price of that particular fish right before the holiday.
A halachic ruling issued by Rabbi Shmuel Eliezer Stern of Bnei Brak seeks to prevent that from happening. The rabbi is calling for a gefilte fish boycott, stating that "all halachic rulers believe that the unfair exaggerated raising of prices must be stopped."
The ruling, which was published in ultra-Orthodox newspaper Hamodia, explains that after receiving information on fish prices, the rabbi suggested "a regulation of the generation's great sages to forbid the purchase of fish for a limited period of time, until all those involved understand that they must back down on the unjustified price hike and reduce the prices to a reasonable and appropriate level."
The rabbi further describes how one of the rebbes of the Chabad Hasidic movement announced a fish boycott hundreds of years ago, which lasted about two months.
According to Yehuda Ashlag, who owns a Bnei Brak delicatessen called "Leibale," gefilte fish sales soar every year ahead of Passover. "It's really part of the holiday tradition," he says. "Some people cannot do without gefilte on Passover, and the sellers use it to their advantage. I personally don't raise the price," he says.
Aviad Nurieli, a fishpond worker in northern Israel, says that "it's all a matter of supply and demand, and these are the market rules."