Photo: Shutterstock
Illustration by Shutterstock
Photo: Shutterstock

Palestinians cry foul over Facebook pro-Israel bias

New campaign hopes to expose what it calls double-standard policy of social media giant in dealing with Israeli and Palestinian incitement

A social media campaign rejecting what it calls "violations" of Facebook rules by censoring Palestinian content has been launched by Palestinian journalists and activists.



The campaign in cooperation with Sada Social Center, which monitors social media violations against Palestinian content, is calling on users to tweet using the hashtag #FBblockspalestine by Wednesday night at 8 p.m. in order to highlight “the threat posed by Facebook against Palestinian content, and to make it public".


Illustration by Shutterstock
Illustration by Shutterstock


The campaign also hopes to reveal what it calls a policy of double standards by Facebook management in dealing with Israeli and Palestinian incitement on its site.


"Twitter is the first in a series of actions we will take,” says Eyad Rifai, head of Sada Social Center.


“Next week, we will meet with a group of institutions and potential partners to discuss ways to counter the attack on Palestinian content."


He warned action in the field will be taken at a later stage as well.


Rifai said the campaign aims to “protect the digital rights of the Palestinian people so they can practice their right of absolute freedom of speech via cyberspace without the involvement of Facebook management that "limits their freedoms while allowing Israeli users to incite against Arabs as well as call to kill them.”


He added: “Facebook has developed an algorithm that automatically deletes users' posts and accounts if they include names of Palestinian political parties, for example ‘Hamas,’ ‘Jihad,’ ‘Popular Front,’ ‘Qassam,’ ‘Saraya’ and ‘Islamic Jihad,’ or names of martyrs, leaders and others without looking at the context in which they were posted, which sets a historic precedent for infringement on media freedom.”


Rifai pointed out that Palestinian journalists and media people are unable to carry out their work work as a result of "Facebook’s unfair policy, which doesn’t pay attention to professional work standards. This puts the Palestinian narrative on Facebook in real danger.”


He said the campaign had sent a letter to the Middle East management of Facebook to condemn the policy, adding that he “isn’t very optimistic” about receiving a positive response.


“We will receive the same justification, which isn’t new anymore, that Facebook is an American company committed to renouncing terrorism as part of an agreement with the American government.


Dahoud Abu Dalfeh, a Gaza-based journalist who said his Facebook account had been deleted in September for “using content that is against Facebook policy,” said that “Facebook management sees using Palestinian symbols, names or political parties as incitement to violence, regardless of the nature of the work of the publisher.”


He insists he was not trying to provoke anyone.


“I was just doing my job when I lost my account,” he explained.


“Even when we cover news regarding Lebanon, we can’t use terms concerning Hezbollah or its leader Hassan Nasrallah,” he continued claiming he cannot object to or report accounts being deleted.


"When we try, we receive a message that an unknown error has occurred, which creates another issue.” he said.


Abu Dalfeh said Facebook management “does not handle the escalating Israeli incitement against Palestinians the same way or use similar algorithms, which makes it biased toward Israel.”


Clashes along the Gaza border with Israel (Photo: AFP) (Photo: AFP)
Clashes along the Gaza border with Israel (Photo: AFP)


In August, the Sada Center documented more than 17 violations against Palestinian content on social media, most of them on Facebook, “which created a need for the center and other activists to protest against Facebook managerial procedures rather than just continue to monitor its violations.”


Ali Bikhat, a Palestinian social media analyst and head of the Social Media Club at The Palestinian Institute for Communication and Development, claimed that “there has been coordination between Israeli authorities and the management of Facebook.


On the Palestinian side, there isn’t any diplomatic effort to reach agreement with site management to reduce its policy or end it.”


For this reason, he advocates for a more proactive approach.


“We must communicate with Facebook management in regard to these terms in order to change the policy and highlight its manipulation in dealing with Israeli incitement over Palestinian content,” Bikhat said.


The goal of the campaign should be “ending Facebook’s policy against Palestinians accounts,” he added.


“Facebook policy eliminates the Palestinian existence and narrative on its site, which supports and serves the Israeli narrative,” he insisted. “Even if the campaign doesn’t end the policy, at least it highlights the case widely and raises awareness.”


Article written by Dima Abumaria. Reprinted with permission from The Media Line 


פרסום ראשון: 10.08.19, 16:29
 new comment
This will delete your current comment